Court denies motion to dismiss DRAM price fixing case
Judge Noël Wise denied Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron’s joint motion to dismiss a proposed class action. She found the complaint plausibly alleged an agreement to restrict conventional DRAM supply in violation of Section 1 of the Sherman Act. The ruling means the case can proceed, not that the companies have been found guilty or liable. The distinction matters because the judge had to assess whether the allegations, taken as true for this stage, could support a legal claim. The plaintiffs alleged coordinated production cuts and shifts toward HBM, alongside other conduct. Wise found those allegations sufficient to move forward, while rejecting some proposed evidence as too weak or neutral. The companies argued the case repeated DRAM II, an earlier case dismissed in 2022. Wise disagreed. The case remains unresolved, and the allegations have not been proven. The companies’ answers are due Dec. 7, 2026, and the initial case management conference is set for Jan. 12, 2027.
What did the judge decide by denying the motion to dismiss, and does that mean the companies have been found guilty?
Judge Noël Wise denied Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron’s joint motion to dismiss a proposed class action. She found the complaint plausibly alleged an agreement to restrict conventional DRAM supply in violation of Section 1 of the Sherman Act. The ruling means the case can proceed, not that the companies have been found guilty or liable.
The distinction matters because the judge had to assess whether the allegations, taken as true for this stage, could support a legal claim. The plaintiffs alleged coordinated production cuts and shifts toward HBM, alongside other conduct. Wise found those allegations sufficient to move forward, while rejecting some proposed evidence as too weak or neutral.
The companies argued the case repeated DRAM II, an earlier case dismissed in 2022. Wise disagreed. The case remains unresolved, and the allegations have not been proven. The companies’ answers are due Dec. 7, 2026, and the initial case management conference is set for Jan. 12, 2027.
What is conventional DRAM, and how is it different from HBM memory used in AI accelerators?
Conventional DRAM is standardized memory built to industry specifications and sold for ordinary purposes. The complaint identifies DDR5 modules made for computers as an example. DRAM is used in computers, phones and servers, so changes in its supply can matter to buyers of many everyday devices.
HBM, or high bandwidth memory, is a specialized kind of DRAM used for AI accelerators. The complaint says HBM requires approximately three to four times the silicon wafer area per gigabyte compared with conventional DDR5. That difference is central to the case: when manufacturers shift production capacity toward HBM, that capacity may no longer be available to produce as much conventional memory.
The complaint alleges the companies began shifting capacity to HBM in 2023 as they cut conventional DRAM production. Judge Wise found that a pivot to HBM alone might not establish a conspiracy, but said related conduct helped the allegations plausibly suggest agreement. The court has not determined that the companies conspired or that consumers experienced particular effects.
How much of global DRAM revenue did the three companies reportedly control, and how sharply did conventional DRAM prices rise?
The complaint says Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron controlled more than 91% of global DRAM revenue in the third quarter of 2025. That figure describes their reported combined share of revenue, not a court finding that they controlled a particular percentage of production. Their position matters to the lawsuit because the plaintiffs allege the three firms’ actions affected supply across the market.
The complaint also alleges conventional DRAM prices rose 171.8% in one year by the third quarter of 2025. It separately alleges a 697% increase over 18 months. These are complaint figures cited in the article, not price increases independently established by the ruling.
The judge denied the motion to dismiss after finding the overall allegations plausible, including the companies’ alleged supply cuts and failure to meaningfully expand conventional DRAM capacity despite record prices. The case will now proceed, but the companies have not been found liable. Their answers are due Dec. 7, 2026, and the initial case management conference is set for Jan. 12, 2027.
Why can shifting chip-making capacity from conventional DRAM to HBM reduce the supply of ordinary memory?
Chip-making capacity is not interchangeable without consequence: the complaint alleges that manufacturers shifted capacity from conventional DRAM to HBM. Conventional DRAM includes standardized memory such as DDR5, while HBM is specialized memory used in AI accelerators. If production resources are redirected, less capacity may be available to make ordinary memory.
The complaint says HBM requires approximately three to four times the silicon wafer area per gigabyte compared with conventional DDR5. That greater area requirement helps explain the alleged supply effect: a given amount of wafer capacity devoted to HBM may produce less memory measured in gigabytes than if devoted to conventional DRAM. The article does not quantify exactly how much conventional output was lost.
The plaintiffs allege the companies began cutting production in late 2022 and shifting capacity to HBM in 2023. Judge Wise said the HBM pivot by itself might not be enough to suggest agreement, but related conduct supported the case at this stage. Whether the firms actually conspired remains unresolved.
What evidence did the judge say could suggest the companies agreed to restrict supply rather than simply making similar decisions independently?
Because the plaintiffs had no direct evidence of an agreement, they needed additional facts—called plus factors—to make coordination more plausible than independent, similar business decisions. Judge Wise found that several allegations, considered together, could support that inference at the motion-to-dismiss stage.
The complaint alleged that all three firms locked in HBM supply through long-term contracts; Samsung and SK Hynix reportedly refused long-term agreements with major conventional DRAM customers; and Micron announced it would close its Crucial consumer brand. The judge also pointed to fab delays, no meaningful expansion despite record prices, similar customer vetting and the firms’ prior cartel history.
Wise said a move to HBM alone might not be enough, but related conduct tipped the factor in the plaintiffs’ favor. She gave no weight to investor statements about “supply discipline,” conference meetings without details of exchanges, or the three-company market structure, which she called neutral. These are plausible allegations, not proven facts.
If conventional DRAM supply is restricted, what effects can consumers and small businesses face when buying computers, phones, or servers?
If less conventional DRAM is available, buyers could face higher prices or fewer choices when purchasing products that use it. That could matter to consumers buying computers or phones and to small businesses purchasing computers or servers. These are possible downstream effects of restricted supply, not outcomes the article says have been proven in this case.
The complaint alleges conventional DRAM prices rose 171.8% in one year by the third quarter of 2025, and 697% over 18 months. It also alleges that the firms cut production and did not meaningfully expand conventional capacity despite record prices. Those allegations describe the market conditions plaintiffs rely on; they do not establish how much more any particular device cost.
The judge found the complaint plausible enough to proceed, not that the companies caused a proven price effect for consumers or small businesses. The lawsuit seeks to represent consumers and small businesses, and its claims remain allegations. The article gives no specific figures for retail device prices, availability, or buyer losses.
What does Section 1 of the Sherman Act prohibit, and why is it not enough to show that competitors made similar business moves?
Section 1 of the Sherman Act prohibits contracts, combinations or conspiracies that restrain trade. In this case, the plaintiffs allege that three DRAM makers agreed to limit conventional memory supply. The judge ruled only that the complaint plausibly alleged such an agreement; she did not decide that the law was violated.
A key issue is the difference between coordination and conscious parallelism. Competitors may independently make similar choices, such as reducing output, without agreeing with one another. The article explains that plaintiffs without direct evidence need plus factors: additional facts suggesting a preceding agreement rather than independent decisions. The judge assessed whether the alleged conduct could support that inference.
Wise found the alleged production cuts and capacity shifts, together with long-term contracts, customer-contract refusals and other conduct, sufficient at this stage. She rejected reliance on the three-company market structure alone, calling it neutral. This is general antitrust background applied to the ruling; the case continues, and the alleged agreement has not been proven.
This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.
Read more in the JupiteX app
Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.
Or read more news on the web