‘Pull back the curtain’ on treatment of sexual assault victims in court, says UK government adviser
Russell Brand’s conviction for rape brought renewed public attention to sexual-offence trials. Government adviser Prof Katrin Hohl says this attention should help reveal what often remains hidden: how complainants are treated during investigations and in court. She argues that this matters because problems in the justice process can go unnoticed when trial practices are not studied. Hohl wants proper research into what barristers, judges and juries do during trials. That includes examining whether rape myths are raised and how juries are directed when they are. During Brand’s trial, his barrister said the women who accused him had not “resisted or screamed or even tried to leave”. Hohl’s concern is that such practices may affect how evidence is considered. Her call comes as a report found cases prepared under Operation Soteria could encounter “a cliff edge” at trial. Hohl says police and prosecutors have made progress, but the court system is lagging. More research could show where trial practices need attention and help victims obtain the justice the law promises.
What prompted Katrin Hohl to call for more transparency, and what does she want researchers to examine about sexual-offence trials?
Russell Brand’s conviction for rape brought renewed public attention to sexual-offence trials. Government adviser Prof Katrin Hohl says this attention should help reveal what often remains hidden: how complainants are treated during investigations and in court. She argues that this matters because problems in the justice process can go unnoticed when trial practices are not studied.
Hohl wants proper research into what barristers, judges and juries do during trials. That includes examining whether rape myths are raised and how juries are directed when they are. During Brand’s trial, his barrister said the women who accused him had not “resisted or screamed or even tried to leave”. Hohl’s concern is that such practices may affect how evidence is considered.
Her call comes as a report found cases prepared under Operation Soteria could encounter “a cliff edge” at trial. Hohl says police and prosecutors have made progress, but the court system is lagging. More research could show where trial practices need attention and help victims obtain the justice the law promises.
What are rape myths, and how might they influence the way a jury views evidence?
Rape myths are stereotypes or misconceptions about rape, victims and how people “should” behave during an assault. They are not evidence that an allegation is true or false. This definition draws on well-established understanding; the article itself refers to rape myths but does not define the term.
One example in the article came from the Brand trial. His barrister said the women who accused him had not “resisted or screamed or even tried to leave”. Treating those expected reactions as necessary could lead jurors to doubt an account because someone did not behave in a particular way. But a stereotype cannot establish what happened in an individual case.
Hohl says cases investigated under Operation Soteria may encounter practices such as the use of rape myths when they reach trial. Claire Waxman has called for judges to direct juries if such myths are raised. Those directions could help jurors focus on the evidence rather than assumptions, though the article does not say what wording judges should use.
How does Operation Soteria change the way police and prosecutors investigate rape cases?
Operation Soteria is a system that directs police forces and the Crown Prosecution Service to make rape investigations more focused on suspects rather than on victim behaviour. The change matters because it shifts investigative attention away from scrutinising the person making an allegation and toward examining the suspect.
The article does not set out specific investigative steps or protocols. It does report that police forces and the CPS have been directed to make this shift, and Hohl says they have made “significant progress”. Her report also suggests that sexual-assault cases prepared under the new system may face a “cliff edge” once they come to trial.
That gap points to a concern: changes to investigations may not carry through to court practices. Hohl says cases could meet practices such as defence use of rape myths, and she wants research into trial actions by barristers, judges and juries. The article gives no timetable for further changes, but makes clear that Hohl sees the court system as lagging behind.
How much have calls to the 24/7 rape and sexual abuse support line increased, according to the article?
The supplied article text does not give a precise increase in calls to the 24/7 rape and sexual abuse support line. Its final sentence begins, “Bergman said calls to the 24/7 rape and sexual ab…” and then cuts off. So there is no count, percentage or comparison period to report from the text provided.
What the article does state is that several support services experienced a significant increase in calls and messages after Brand’s trial. Ciara Bergman, chief executive of Rape Crisis England & Wales, said centres were facing “very significant demand” and phonelines had been inundated since Brand was convicted of rape.
The exact scale for the 24/7 line therefore remains unavailable here. The article describes services under pressure but does not provide figures for staffing, waiting times or capacity. It also reports that some women are questioning their experiences with older men after allegations involving Brand and David Walliams became public.
What can happen to survivors and support services when high-profile cases bring past experiences back into public view?
High-profile cases can bring sexual violence and past experiences back into public discussion. The article reports that, after Brand’s conviction, several services saw a significant increase in calls and messages. Rape Crisis England & Wales chief executive Ciara Bergman said centres faced “very significant demand” and their phonelines were inundated.
The article also describes a personal consequence: Bergman said many women were questioning their own experiences with older men. That came after the Brand case and separate allegations about David Walliams became public. One woman described an alleged encounter with Walliams, when she was 15, as “sexual assault”; Walliams denies wrongdoing. Police were looking at a series of “serious” sexual-offence allegations against him.
The article does not give an exact rise in calls or say how long demand lasted. It does show that support services may face heavier contact when cases draw attention to sexual abuse. The wider public discussion also includes concerns about treatment in court and whether reporting abuse can harm survivors’ careers, mental health and future.
What role can judges play in helping juries assess evidence without relying on rape myths?
Judges can guide juries on how to approach evidence during a trial. Victims commissioner Claire Waxman has called for a new legal duty requiring judges to direct juries if rape myths have been raised. She says justice must be grounded in evidence, not misconceptions. The proposal matters because stereotypes about how a person should act could otherwise shape how jurors interpret an allegation.
The article gives an example from Brand’s trial: his barrister said the women who accused him had not “resisted or screamed or even tried to leave”. If such claims invite jurors to rely on a stereotype, a judge’s direction could help them distinguish assumptions from evidence. The article does not specify the wording or content of any proposed direction.
Waxman’s call is one of several developments following the trial. Hohl also wants research into how judges, juries and barristers act in sexual-offence trials. The article does not say that a new legal duty has been adopted. If pursued, the proposal would put judges at the centre of efforts to address rape myths in court.
What does consent mean in law, and how is the age of consent different from whether someone freely agrees to sex?
In law in England and Wales, consent to sex generally means agreeing by choice, with the freedom and capacity to make that choice. This is established legal background; the article does not define consent. The age of consent is generally 16. It sets an age-related legal threshold, while the question of consent concerns whether a person freely agrees to the activity.
The article reports that ministers are considering calls for a “staggered” consent law. The proposed change would make it illegal for adults over a certain age to have sex with 16- and 17-year-olds. Mia Latter, who says she was 16 during an abusive relationship with Brand, supports changing the law. The article does not state what the proposed age threshold would be.
The ideas should not be confused: reaching the general age of consent does not itself establish that a person freely agreed in a particular situation. Nor does the article say that the proposed change has become law. Pat McFadden said ministers would discuss the issue but could not say what their conclusion would be.
This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.
Read more in the JupiteX app
Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.
Or read more news on the web