JupiteX Get the app
Politics & Governance15 Nov 2026 · about 7 min

10 years on, homebuyers seek PM Modi’s intervention to fix RERA; Cabinet Secretariat takes note

The brief

The Cabinet Secretariat responded to FPCE’s request with both a written reply and a meeting. This mattered because the homebuyers’ forum said its concerns about RERA had remained unresolved despite years of representations. The response did not announce that any proposed change had been accepted. FPCE wrote to Prime Minister Narendra Modi on October 26. On November 2, Cabinet Secretary T V Somanathan thanked the forum for its “thoughtful, well-analysed and wide-ranging suggestions” and said they would be looked into. On November 12, Cabinet Secretariat officials met FPCE president Abhay Upadhyay and members Ratul Mazumder and Jai Pal Raheja. At the meeting, FPCE explained its proposal to separate real estate promotion from homebuyer protection and handed over a compilation of representations made since 2018. The forum said Sunday that none of the issues it had raised had been resolved. The officials’ meeting gave FPCE a chance to present its case directly, but the article reports no decision or timetable for action.

01

What did the Cabinet Secretariat do after FPCE asked the Prime Minister to address problems with RERA?

The Cabinet Secretariat responded to FPCE’s request with both a written reply and a meeting. This mattered because the homebuyers’ forum said its concerns about RERA had remained unresolved despite years of representations. The response did not announce that any proposed change had been accepted.

FPCE wrote to Prime Minister Narendra Modi on October 26. On November 2, Cabinet Secretary T V Somanathan thanked the forum for its “thoughtful, well-analysed and wide-ranging suggestions” and said they would be looked into. On November 12, Cabinet Secretariat officials met FPCE president Abhay Upadhyay and members Ratul Mazumder and Jai Pal Raheja.

At the meeting, FPCE explained its proposal to separate real estate promotion from homebuyer protection and handed over a compilation of representations made since 2018. The forum said Sunday that none of the issues it had raised had been resolved. The officials’ meeting gave FPCE a chance to present its case directly, but the article reports no decision or timetable for action.

02

What is RERA, and what was it created to do for homebuyers and the real estate sector?

RERA stands for the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016. It is the central law at the heart of the article’s discussion. The text does not set out all of the Act’s provisions, but it describes RERA as a law whose objectives, in FPCE’s view, remain far from achieved. That matters because the forum represents homebuyers and campaigned for the Act’s enactment.

The article links RERA to two important interests: developing the real estate sector and protecting people who buy homes. FPCE says the current arrangement places homebuyer welfare under the Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs, which is also entrusted with promoting real estate. It wants those responsibilities separated so buyer protection is not handled by the same ministry promoting the sector.

The article reports that FPCE is still seeking changes, saying problems persist “10 years on.” Its proposals include a national appellate tribunal and stronger statutory protections for buyers. It does not describe the Act’s full legal requirements or report that any amendments have been adopted. The suggested changes remain proposals under consideration.

03

How long after RERA’s enactment are homebuyers still seeking changes, and since when has FPCE been raising concerns?

The article describes a long-running effort to address problems with RERA. FPCE told Prime Minister Narendra Modi that the law’s objectives were “far from being achieved” even 10 years after enactment. That span is striking because the forum says it has been making representations about these concerns since 2018, rather than raising them only in its recent letter.

FPCE wrote to the Prime Minister on October 26 and included proposals to change how homebuyers are protected. At a November 12 meeting with Cabinet Secretariat officials, the delegation handed over a compilation of its representations since 2018. It said these issues had been raised continuously at available forums and that not one had been resolved.

The Cabinet Secretary replied on November 2 that the suggestions would be looked into. That response acknowledged the proposals but did not confirm a change to RERA or provide a timeline. The forum’s account therefore shows both sustained advocacy and continued uncertainty: homebuyers are seeking amendments, while the government has so far offered attention and a discussion rather than a reported resolution.

04

What changes are homebuyers proposing, including the national appellate tribunal and a statutory exit from a purchase agreement?

FPCE has proposed several changes aimed at making homebuyer protection more consistent and practical. It wants responsibility for protecting buyers separated from real estate promotion, a national appellate tribunal instead of the existing state appellate tribunals, and an agreement for sale made a binding statutory document. These proposals matter because the forum says buyers’ protections and access to remedies can vary.

The forum argues that different states read the same provision of the central Act differently. A single national appellate forum, it says, could build one body of RERA law for the country, as the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal and National Green Tribunal have done in their fields. FPCE also proposes a statutory exit from a purchase agreement if a buyer loses a job or an earning family member dies.

These are proposals, not changes the article reports as adopted. Cabinet Secretary T V Somanathan said they would be looked into, and Cabinet Secretariat officials met the forum’s delegation. The article gives no decision or implementation schedule, so the next step remains uncertain.

05

Why does FPCE want homebuyer protection moved from the ministry that promotes real estate to the Consumer Affairs Department?

FPCE’s central institutional proposal is to separate promoting real estate from protecting homebuyers. The forum wants responsibility for buyer interests shifted from the Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs to the Consumer Affairs Department. This matters, in FPCE’s view, because people buying homes need an authority focused on their welfare.

The reason it gives is a potential conflict between the ministry’s two responsibilities: MoHUA is in charge of homebuyers’ welfare while also being entrusted with promoting the real estate sector. FPCE explained this proposed separation at its meeting with Cabinet Secretariat officials and provided a record of representations made since 2018. It says those issues have repeatedly been raised but not resolved.

The article reports that the Cabinet Secretary welcomed FPCE’s suggestions and said they would be looked into. It does not say that responsibility has been transferred or that the Consumer Affairs Department has taken on this role. The change remains a proposal, alongside FPCE’s calls for a national appellate tribunal and other statutory protections for buyers.

06

What can happen to buyers’ rights when different states interpret the same central law differently?

When states interpret the same central law differently, homebuyers may encounter different understandings of their rights depending on where they purchased. FPCE raised this concern while arguing for a national appellate tribunal. The issue matters because a central law may not offer buyers a consistent experience if its provisions are read differently across states.

FPCE said the same provision of the central Act is “today read differently from State to State.” It described the consequence plainly: a homebuyer’s rights depend on where the buyer happened to purchase. Its proposed remedy is one appellate forum for real estate across the country, rather than the existing state appellate tribunals. The forum says this could help build one body of RERA law.

The article presents this as FPCE’s argument and proposal, not as a government finding or an adopted reform. Cabinet Secretariat officials heard the suggestion at a meeting, after the Cabinet Secretary said the forum’s proposals would be looked into. The article does not report whether state interpretations have changed or whether a national tribunal will be created.

07

What does an appellate tribunal do when someone challenges a decision, and how can a shared tribunal help make the law more consistent?

In general, an appellate tribunal considers a challenge to an earlier decision and determines whether that decision should stand or be changed. The article does not explain the tribunal process in detail, but it identifies existing state appellate tribunals and reports FPCE’s proposal for a national one. Such a forum matters here because the forum says states interpret the same central RERA provision differently.

FPCE argues that one appellate forum could help create a shared body of RERA law for the whole country. It compares the idea with the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal and the National Green Tribunal, which it says have built one body of law in their respective fields. The proposed national tribunal would replace the existing state appellate tribunals, according to the forum’s suggestion.

This is not a change the article says has been approved. Cabinet Secretariat officials met FPCE’s delegation after the Cabinet Secretary responded that its suggestions would be looked into. The forum’s proposal aims at more consistency, but the article reports no decision, creation date, or details about how such a tribunal would operate.

This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.

Read more in the JupiteX app

Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.

Or read more news on the web