JupiteX Get the app
Economy & Business16 Nov 2026 · about 6 min

Bigger pay may make you more diligent, slightly less agreeable

The brief

Income growth was followed by small increases in conscientiousness and emotional stability. At the same time, the researchers found small decreases in agreeableness and extraversion. These traits describe different ways people handle responsibilities, stress and social interactions. For example, conscientiousness includes being organised and dependable, while emotional stability involves staying calm under pressure. Agreeableness includes being considerate and cooperative, and extraversion relates to sociability and enthusiasm for social interaction. A change in income was followed by shifts in each of these traits, not by a change in every Big Five trait. The findings come from a meta-analysis of 11 longitudinal studies involving about 134,515 workers in five countries. The reported shifts were small, and the study identified patterns over time rather than proving that a raise directly changed someone’s personality. Openness to experience is described in the article, but no income-related change in it is reported.

01

Which personality traits tended to rise or fall after income increased?

Income growth was followed by small increases in conscientiousness and emotional stability. At the same time, the researchers found small decreases in agreeableness and extraversion. These traits describe different ways people handle responsibilities, stress and social interactions.

For example, conscientiousness includes being organised and dependable, while emotional stability involves staying calm under pressure. Agreeableness includes being considerate and cooperative, and extraversion relates to sociability and enthusiasm for social interaction. A change in income was followed by shifts in each of these traits, not by a change in every Big Five trait.

The findings come from a meta-analysis of 11 longitudinal studies involving about 134,515 workers in five countries. The reported shifts were small, and the study identified patterns over time rather than proving that a raise directly changed someone’s personality. Openness to experience is described in the article, but no income-related change in it is reported.

02

How small were the reported changes, and how many workers and studies were included?

The researchers described the personality changes linked with rising income as small. The article gives no numerical effect sizes, so it does not specify exactly how much any trait changed. The finding points to gradual shifts, rather than a sudden or dramatic transformation in personality.

The scale of the evidence was substantial: the researchers combined 11 large-scale longitudinal studies. Together, those studies involved approximately 134,515 workers across five countries. Longitudinal studies track people over time, allowing researchers to examine whether income changes come before later personality changes.

Even with a large combined sample, the results describe average patterns across the studies, not what must happen to each individual. The researchers found small increases in conscientiousness and emotional stability after income rose, and small decreases in agreeableness and extraversion. The article does not provide exact effect-size figures or further country-by-country breakdowns.

03

What do conscientiousness, emotional stability, agreeableness and extraversion mean?

Conscientiousness means tending to be organised, dependable and hard-working. Emotional stability describes how calmly someone handles stress and uncertainty. Together, these traits relate to managing responsibilities and difficult situations, which can matter in demanding work roles.

Agreeableness involves being cooperative, considerate and empathetic. Extraversion relates to sociability, outgoing behaviour and enthusiasm for social interaction. Imagine a worker promoted to supervise colleagues: dependability and composure may help with the new duties, while the role may also change how the person spends time interacting with others. That example illustrates the traits, not a proven cause of change.

In the meta-analysis, income increases were followed by small increases in conscientiousness and emotional stability, and small decreases in agreeableness and extraversion. These are average patterns reported across studies. The article does not claim that every worker experiences the same shifts or that a higher salary directly produces them.

04

How might the demands of a higher-paying role gradually affect someone's habits and personality?

A demanding role can require new ways of working. The article’s social investment explanation proposes that repeatedly meeting those expectations may shape habits and, gradually, personality. This matters because personality is not necessarily fixed throughout adulthood, even though its patterns are relatively stable.

For instance, a promotion might require someone to supervise colleagues, manage larger projects, meet demanding deadlines and make decisions affecting a team. To keep up, the worker may become more organised and accountable. At first, those behaviours may be ways to meet workplace expectations; with repetition, they may become part of the person’s everyday approach.

The researchers found that income increases were followed by small increases in conscientiousness, a trait linked to dependability and discipline. The example shows one possible mechanism, not a proven explanation for every worker. The meta-analysis found a connection over time, but it did not establish that higher pay itself caused the personality change.

05

Does the study prove that earning more causes these personality changes?

The study does not establish that a raise directly changes personality. It identifies a pattern over time: income increases tended to be followed by small increases in conscientiousness and emotional stability, and small decreases in agreeableness and extraversion. That distinction matters when interpreting the findings.

The researchers combined 11 large-scale longitudinal studies involving approximately 134,515 workers across five countries. Tracking people over time helps researchers examine which changes come first. However, a sequence between income growth and later personality shifts does not by itself establish that the income change caused the shifts.

The article offers possible explanations, including greater financial security reducing everyday worries and professional achievement providing a sense of competence and control. It also describes demanding work roles as a possible influence on habits. These are explanations under discussion, not proof of a direct effect. The findings support a connection between income and personality development, while leaving the cause unresolved.

06

How can personality traits also influence a person's future income?

Income may be followed by personality shifts, but the relationship also runs the other way. The article reports that certain personality traits predict future changes in income. This possibility matters because it means income and personality may be connected through more than one pathway.

The traditional Five Factor Model emphasises biological influences and natural personality development. It suggests that people with certain traits may be more likely to enter particular professions or achieve higher earnings. For example, a person’s existing traits could influence which kind of work they pursue, rather than work being the only influence on their personality.

This is called the selection effect: people with particular traits may move toward certain careers or higher earnings. The article does not name which specific traits predict income changes, or explain the size of those predictions. The meta-analysis therefore highlights a reciprocal relationship, while leaving open how much each direction contributes for any individual.

07

Why do psychologists see adult personality as relatively stable but still capable of changing?

Personality traits are relatively stable patterns of thinking, feeling and behaving that distinguish people. That stability helps explain why psychologists have often treated adult personality as largely fixed. Yet contemporary personality research recognises that life experiences can gradually influence these patterns.

The article presents two explanations for change. The Five Factor Model gives considerable weight to biological influences and natural development. The Neo-Socioanalytic Model instead proposes that professional and social experiences can actively shape personality. Its social investment principle suggests that taking on demanding roles calls for certain behaviours.

Repeated behaviours may become habitual and influence underlying personality over time. For example, a worker managing larger projects may develop more structured habits to meet the role’s demands. The meta-analysis found small personality shifts following income increases, but it does not settle the debate about why adult personality changes. Both natural development and life experience are part of the explanations described.

This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.

Read more in the JupiteX app

Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.

Or read more news on the web