ICC judges order end to investigation into alleged crimes by US forces in Afghanistan
The closure does not end every part of the ICC’s Afghanistan work. Judges ordered the original investigation strand covering the conduct of US forces and the Islamic State-Khorasan Province group, or IS-K, closed. That decision matters because the investigation had covered alleged crimes by several parties, and pursuing allegations against US forces was a longstanding objection by Washington. The Taliban inquiry is being handled separately. Judges opened Afghanistan II on 20 October and transferred relevant records to it, including four Taliban arrest warrants. The separate inquiry concerns alleged crimes against humanity by the Taliban against women and other groups while the Taliban acted as Afghanistan’s de facto government. The prosecutor has appealed the latest closure decision, so the closure is being challenged. The article says appeals over opening the separate Taliban investigation and transferring records are also pending. The Taliban inquiry remains open, while the appeals chamber has not yet resolved those challenges. The article does not say whether the latest closure order is suspended during the appeal.
Which parts of the ICC’s Afghanistan investigation did the judges order closed?
The closure does not end every part of the ICC’s Afghanistan work. Judges ordered the original investigation strand covering the conduct of US forces and the Islamic State-Khorasan Province group, or IS-K, closed. That decision matters because the investigation had covered alleged crimes by several parties, and pursuing allegations against US forces was a longstanding objection by Washington.
The Taliban inquiry is being handled separately. Judges opened Afghanistan II on 20 October and transferred relevant records to it, including four Taliban arrest warrants. The separate inquiry concerns alleged crimes against humanity by the Taliban against women and other groups while the Taliban acted as Afghanistan’s de facto government.
The prosecutor has appealed the latest closure decision, so the closure is being challenged. The article says appeals over opening the separate Taliban investigation and transferring records are also pending. The Taliban inquiry remains open, while the appeals chamber has not yet resolved those challenges. The article does not say whether the latest closure order is suspended during the appeal.
Which allegations and arrest warrants will remain part of the separate Afghanistan II investigation?
Afghanistan II is the separate ICC situation for examining alleged Taliban crimes after the Taliban returned to power in August 2021. Its importance is that the judges closed the original investigation strand covering US forces and IS-K while leaving this Taliban inquiry open.
The inquiry focuses on alleged crimes against humanity committed against women and other groups while the Taliban acted as Afghanistan’s de facto government. In November 2024, six states referred allegations of crimes against women and girls since the Taliban’s return, asking prosecutors to include them in the existing investigation. Judges later opened Afghanistan II and ordered relevant records transferred, including four Taliban arrest warrants.
The article does not name the people covered by those warrants or list every allegation in them. It says the Taliban inquiry is now part of Afghanistan II, while the prosecutor’s appeals against the separate investigation and transfer of records remain pending. So the investigation continues, but the scope and legal status of particular allegations may be affected by the pending appeals.
How broad was the original investigation—what period did it cover and which groups were accused of crimes?
The original ICC Afghanistan investigation was broad: prosecutors sought to examine alleged crimes committed since 2003. It mattered because the inquiry covered multiple parties to Afghanistan’s conflict, rather than focusing on only one group.
In November 2017, then-prosecutor Fatou Bensouda requested permission to investigate alleged crimes by Afghan and US forces, the Taliban, and the Islamic State-Khorasan Province group, known as IS-K. A pre-trial chamber initially rejected the request in 2019. In March 2020, the appeals chamber overturned that decision and authorised the investigation to proceed.
The investigation’s scope has since been divided. Judges closed the strand covering US forces and IS-K, but left the Taliban inquiry open as Afghanistan II. That does not mean the allegations in the original request were proven: the article describes them as allegations. The prosecutor has appealed the closure, and appeals over the separate Taliban investigation and the transfer of records are also pending.
Why might the closure not be final, and what can happen while the prosecutor’s appeal is pending?
The closure may not be the last word because the Office of the Prosecutor has appealed the judges’ latest decision. The appeal gives the appeals chamber an opportunity to review the closure, which matters because the order affects whether the original investigation continues to cover alleged crimes by US forces and IS-K.
The prosecutor had also appealed two earlier decisions: opening a separate Taliban investigation and transferring court records to it. Those appeals were still pending when the article was written. At the same time, judges had ordered relevant records, including four Taliban arrest warrants, moved to Afghanistan II. Under ICC procedure, an appeal does not automatically suspend a decision; the appeals chamber can order suspension.
The article does not say that the closure has been suspended or predict when the appeals chamber will rule. For now, the reported decision closes the US forces and IS-K strand, while the Taliban inquiry remains open in Afghanistan II. The outcome of the pending appeals could affect that division and the handling of the records.
How could US sanctions affect the ICC’s ability to operate, including its access to US dollars?
The article links US sanctions to Washington’s longstanding objection to the ICC investigating alleged crimes by Americans. It says the US sanctioned then-prosecutor Fatou Bensouda and later members of the appeals chamber, and describes sanctions on the court and its officials. The supplied text does not explain the sanctions’ practical effects or specify restrictions on access to US dollars.
In general, US sanctions can block property under US jurisdiction and prohibit US persons from providing services or conducting transactions with designated parties. Because many international payments in US dollars are processed through US-linked banks, those banks may have to reject or freeze covered transactions. This is a general explanation, not a detail given in the article.
Such restrictions can make it harder for an institution to pay for services or conduct financial operations, depending on the exact sanctions and any authorisations. The article’s final line begins to mention Washington imposing institutional measures on 9 October, but it is cut off. It therefore does not establish which restrictions applied, how they affected the ICC, or whether dollar access was actually disrupted.
Why does the US dispute the ICC’s authority to investigate alleged crimes by people from countries that are not members of the court?
The US dispute centers on the ICC’s reach over people from countries that have not joined the court. The article says Washington demanded that states amend the Rome Statute to prevent prosecution of nationals from non-member countries, naming the US and Israel. This matters because the original Afghanistan investigation included alleged crimes by US forces.
As a general explanation, the Rome Statute is a treaty, and a country that has not joined it is not bound by the treaty in the same way as a member. ICC jurisdiction can nevertheless apply in defined circumstances, such as alleged crimes on the territory of a member state or a Security Council referral. The article does not spell out the legal arguments or jurisdictional basis in this case.
Washington’s demand was reported alongside pressure to drop investigations into Afghanistan and Palestine as a condition for lifting sanctions. The Dutch foreign ministry said there were no direct US negotiations on changing the statute or closing investigations. It said dialogue with non-member states was being explored, but such a dialogue had yet to take shape.
What is the Rome Statute, and how does it set the rules for the ICC’s authority?
The Rome Statute is the treaty that established the International Criminal Court. In general, it sets the court’s structure, the crimes it can address, and rules governing when it may exercise jurisdiction. That framework matters here because the US is not a member and disputes the court’s authority over US nationals.
The article says Washington demanded that states amend the statute to prevent prosecution of nationals from countries that are not ICC members, including the US and Israel. As general legal context, ICC jurisdiction can arise through specified routes, including alleged crimes on the territory of a member state, acceptance of jurisdiction by a non-member, or a UN Security Council referral. The article does not identify which legal route applies to each Afghanistan allegation.
The US also pressed the court to drop its Afghanistan and Palestine investigations as a condition for lifting sanctions, according to diplomats cited in the article. A Dutch spokesperson said there were no direct negotiations with the US on amending the statute. Dialogue with non-member states was being explored, but had yet to take shape.
What is the ICC’s Afghanistan II investigation, and which alleged crimes does it focus on?
Afghanistan II is the ICC situation opened by judges on 20 October for the Taliban inquiry. It matters because judges separated this inquiry from the original Afghanistan investigation, which had covered alleged crimes by several parties, including US forces and IS-K.
The inquiry focuses on alleged crimes against humanity committed by the Taliban against women and other groups while acting as Afghanistan’s de facto government. Six states—Chile, Costa Rica, Spain, France, Luxembourg and Mexico—referred allegations of crimes against women and girls since the Taliban returned to power in August 2021. They asked prosecutors to fold those allegations into the existing Afghanistan investigation. Judges ordered relevant records, including four Taliban arrest warrants, transferred to Afghanistan II.
The prosecutor has appealed the decisions to open the separate inquiry and transfer records, and those appeals were still pending according to the article. The Taliban investigation remains open, while judges closed the strand covering US forces and IS-K. The article describes allegations, not findings of guilt.
This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.
Read more in the JupiteX app
Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.
Or read more news on the web