JupiteX Get the app
Space16 Nov 2026 · about 6 min

What Makes Up the Cosmos? A 20-Year Survey Hints That Something Is Missing.

The brief

The full Dark Energy Survey (DES) dataset, read alongside results from DESI, suggests the standard model of cosmology is incomplete. The surprising point is not that scientists have solved the mismatch, but that observations now indicate cracks in a framework that had seemed stable for about 20 years. DES gathered data on thousands of supernovas and hundreds of millions of galaxies across billions of years of cosmic history. Those observations help test the model against the universe’s expansion and contents. DESI is a separate project whose data were combined with DES findings. Cosmologists cannot yet say what fails or what new ingredient might be needed. Simone Ferraro of Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory said something does not fit. The result reopens basic questions about the cosmos, rather than replacing the standard model with a settled alternative. More measurements will be needed to work out what the discrepancy means.

01

What did the Dark Energy Survey and DESI results suggest about the standard model of cosmology?

The full Dark Energy Survey (DES) dataset, read alongside results from DESI, suggests the standard model of cosmology is incomplete. The surprising point is not that scientists have solved the mismatch, but that observations now indicate cracks in a framework that had seemed stable for about 20 years.

DES gathered data on thousands of supernovas and hundreds of millions of galaxies across billions of years of cosmic history. Those observations help test the model against the universe’s expansion and contents. DESI is a separate project whose data were combined with DES findings.

Cosmologists cannot yet say what fails or what new ingredient might be needed. Simone Ferraro of Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory said something does not fit. The result reopens basic questions about the cosmos, rather than replacing the standard model with a settled alternative. More measurements will be needed to work out what the discrepancy means.

02

In the standard picture, roughly how much of the universe is dark energy, and how much is matter?

Dark energy makes up roughly two-thirds of the universe in the standard picture described here. Matter—both visible and dark—makes up the remainder, about one-third. This division was a major shift from the older idea that matter alone accounted for the cosmos.

Visible matter includes the bright galaxies astronomers see. Dark matter is invisible, but astronomers inferred its presence from how fast galaxies spin: the galaxies seemed to need extra matter around them to hold together. The article groups both forms of matter together when describing the universe’s contents.

These are approximate shares, not a complete explanation of what dark energy is. The standard model treats it as a major part of the cosmic accounting, but new DES results combined with DESI findings suggest the model may be incomplete. Cosmologists have not yet identified what might resolve the mismatch, so the familiar two-thirds-and-remainder picture remains a broad outline rather than a final answer.

03

What is dark energy, and what effect does it have on the universe’s expansion?

Dark energy is the name cosmologists gave to an unidentified, invisible influence that appears to be present throughout the universe. The article describes it as seeming embedded in space itself. It matters because it offers an explanation for an unexpected observation: the universe’s expansion is speeding up rather than steadily slowing.

In 1998, two research teams reported that supernovas seemed to be racing away from Earth under the influence of an unknown repellent force. Their observations suggested that this force was pushing galaxies apart. The researchers did not identify its underlying nature; “dark energy” named the proposed ingredient in their explanation.

Dark energy became part of the standard picture of the cosmos and was estimated to account for roughly two-thirds of it. But DES findings combined with DESI data now suggest that picture may have cracks. Cosmologists still cannot say what dark energy is, or what exactly does not fit, so further observations will be needed to clarify the expansion story.

04

Why would evidence that the universe’s expansion is speeding up challenge a model in which matter’s gravity slows it down?

If matter were the only important influence, its gravity would pull on the universe and slow its expansion. That is the expectation described in the article: there seemed to be enough visible and dark matter to keep slowing expansion, though not enough to halt it completely.

The surprise came in 1998, when observations of supernovas suggested that expansion was not slowing at all. Instead, it was speeding up. The supernovas appeared to be moving away under the influence of an unidentified, repellent force. This conflicted with the expected effect of matter’s gravitational pull and led scientists to propose dark energy.

The conflict matters because a model must account for observations, not only for the expected behavior of matter. Dark energy became part of the standard model to explain the acceleration. Now DES and DESI findings suggest that model may still be incomplete. Scientists have not yet identified what else, if anything, is needed to make the evidence fit.

05

How did observations of supernovas lead scientists to propose dark energy in the 1990s?

In the 1990s, cosmologists were trying to explain signs that their account of the universe did not quite work. The key surprise arrived in 1998: two research teams announced observations suggesting that the universe’s expansion was speeding up, not slowing under gravity. Their findings pointed toward an unknown influence.

The teams studied exploding stars called supernovas. These appeared to be racing away from Earth under the effect of an unidentified, omnipresent repellent force. The observations implied the existence of the kind of missing energy that Joshua Frieman and colleagues had been considering. By the end of 1998, the proposed influence had a name: dark energy.

The supernova results changed the conversation quickly. Frieman recalled that a workshop on the topic, initially attracting only a few dozen sign-ups, suddenly drew broad interest after the announcements. Scientists still do not know the nature of dark energy. Later, DES set out to measure it by observing how it influences the visible universe.

06

How can measurements of distant supernovas and galaxies reveal how the universe expanded over time?

Looking far into space also lets cosmologists look back in time: light takes time to travel, so observations from different distances provide snapshots of the universe at different moments. Comparing those snapshots helps researchers build a history of how the universe changed and expanded.

In 1998, cosmologists had a blurry image of the early universe called the cosmic microwave background, several million observed galaxies, and dozens of supernovas. These gave them views of the universe over the past few billion years. The supernova observations helped reveal that expansion was speeding up, rather than slowing as expected.

To work out when that growth spurt began and how quickly it was happening, researchers needed more data. DES was designed to provide a more comprehensive view. Its final dataset includes thousands of supernovas and hundreds of millions of galaxies across billions of years of cosmic history. Combined with DESI data, those observations now suggest the standard model may be incomplete.

07

How does gravity affect the expansion of the universe, and why would matter alone be expected to slow it?

Gravity affects expansion by tugging matter toward other matter. In the picture cosmologists once considered, the universe held enough visible and dark matter for this gravitational pull to keep slowing expansion. It did not seem to hold enough matter to stop expansion altogether.

Astronomers inferred dark matter because galaxies spun so fast that visible matter alone seemed insufficient to hold them together. Adding dark matter helped explain that motion and increased the matter available to exert gravity. Even with both kinds of matter, the expectation was a gradual slowdown, not a complete halt.

The 1998 supernova findings challenged that expectation by indicating that expansion was speeding up. Cosmologists proposed dark energy as an unknown influence driving the acceleration. The standard model then included dark energy alongside matter. New DES findings, combined with DESI data, suggest this account may not fully fit the evidence, though scientists have not yet identified the missing piece.

This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.

Read more in the JupiteX app

Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.

Or read more news on the web