Trump Rejected by Supreme Court in Bid to End ‘DEI’ Grants
The Supreme Court’s rejection did not resolve every legal question in the dispute. It left standing a 9th US Circuit Court of Appeals ruling that the researchers were likely to succeed in showing the grant cancellations violated the First Amendment. The case involved researchers and faculty members at the University of California. For now, the ruling requires the National Science Foundation and National Endowment for the Humanities to continue funding $59 million in grants. The appeals court said the agencies likely targeted the grants because of the viewpoints expressed in the research. The university group said the cancellations disrupted studies in science, medicine and other fields. The Supreme Court’s move leaves the appeals court’s decision in place, but it does not settle the broader dispute over how the government may choose projects to fund. The Justice Department said it would keep defending the executive branch’s authority over federal funding and grant terminations. The ruling may also be cited in other cases, according to the researchers’ lead lawyer.
What did the Supreme Court’s rejection of the administration’s appeal leave in place?
The Supreme Court’s rejection did not resolve every legal question in the dispute. It left standing a 9th US Circuit Court of Appeals ruling that the researchers were likely to succeed in showing the grant cancellations violated the First Amendment. The case involved researchers and faculty members at the University of California.
For now, the ruling requires the National Science Foundation and National Endowment for the Humanities to continue funding $59 million in grants. The appeals court said the agencies likely targeted the grants because of the viewpoints expressed in the research. The university group said the cancellations disrupted studies in science, medicine and other fields.
The Supreme Court’s move leaves the appeals court’s decision in place, but it does not settle the broader dispute over how the government may choose projects to fund. The Justice Department said it would keep defending the executive branch’s authority over federal funding and grant terminations. The ruling may also be cited in other cases, according to the researchers’ lead lawyer.
How much funding was at stake, and which federal agencies were ordered to keep funding the grants for now?
The dispute concerns $59 million in federal grants awarded to University of California researchers and faculty members. The grants support research projects, and the administration had terminated them after associating the work with topics it opposed. The funding matters because the projects covered science, medicine and other areas, and the researchers said the terminations disrupted their work.
The 9th US Circuit Court of Appeals ruling, left intact by the Supreme Court, requires the National Science Foundation and National Endowment for the Humanities to continue funding the grants for now. The appeals court concluded that the agencies probably targeted the grants because of the viewpoints it perceived in the research. The Supreme Court rejected the administration’s appeal, rather than issuing a ruling that resolved the full dispute.
So the $59 million is not described as a new award; it is funding tied to grants that had been cut off. The agencies must continue the funding under the ruling now in force. The Supreme Court’s decision leaves wider questions about the government’s control over funding programs unanswered.
What does “DEI” mean, and why did the administration target grants it associated with DEI?
DEI commonly stands for diversity, equity and inclusion; that expansion is standard usage, though the article does not define the term. The article says President Trump directed agencies to terminate grants involving DEI, as well as “gender ideology” and “environmental justice.” The administration described the targeted programs as taxpayer-funded DEI initiatives.
Researchers said agencies relied on keywords, including “diversity,” to identify grants they considered problematic. That method also caught projects whose titles used the word in other ways, such as “Leaf Diversity” and “Diversity Within the Legume Rhizobia Mutualism.” The researchers argued that cancellations based on perceived viewpoints likely violated the First Amendment.
The administration argued that the government may choose to fund projects that align with its perspective and may promote favored viewpoints through public spending. The Supreme Court rejected its appeal, leaving the 9th Circuit ruling in place for now. The dispute does not establish that every grant associated with DEI must be funded; it concerns these terminations and the appeals court’s finding about their likely basis.
What could happen to research projects when their grants are cut off?
A grant cancellation can interrupt research by removing the funding a project relies on. In this case, the University of California researchers told the Supreme Court that the wave of terminations upended cutting-edge studies in science, medicine and other areas. The article does not detail the specific work plans or costs of individual projects.
The researchers said the administration used keywords, including “diversity,” to identify grants for termination. That approach swept in projects with titles such as “Leaf Diversity” and “Diversity Within the Legume Rhizobia Mutualism.” Once grants were cut off, the researchers sought court action; the 9th Circuit ruling now requires the agencies to continue funding the grants for now.
The article does not say whether every project has resumed or how much work was permanently lost. It reports that the researchers warned the stakes were high for both them and the public that benefits from their work. With the Supreme Court declining to take up the appeal, the appeals court ruling remains in effect, while broader questions about federal grant decisions remain unresolved.
What roles do the National Science Foundation and National Endowment for the Humanities play in funding research?
The National Science Foundation and National Endowment for the Humanities are the federal agencies named in this case as providing grant funding. In general, the National Science Foundation supports scientific research, while the National Endowment for the Humanities supports work in the humanities; those broad descriptions are established background, not details explained in the article. Their grants can help researchers carry out projects.
Here, the agencies were required by the 9th Circuit ruling to continue funding $59 million in grants to University of California researchers. The appeals court said the grant terminations probably targeted research because of its perceived viewpoints. The projects included work in science, medicine and other areas, according to the researchers.
The Supreme Court rejected the administration’s appeal, leaving that requirement in place for now. The ruling does not answer every question about agency funding powers or describe how the agencies will administer each grant. It does mean that the affected funding must continue under the current appeals court order while the larger legal controversy remains unsettled.
Why might canceling grants because of researchers’ viewpoints violate the First Amendment?
The First Amendment protects freedom of speech. In this case, the 9th Circuit said the government probably crossed a constitutional line by targeting grant recipients because of the viewpoints it perceived in their research. The concern was not simply that the government declined to support a particular subject; the court said the terminations aimed to suppress views with which the government disagreed.
The appeals court pointed to a distinction made in Supreme Court decisions: the government’s choice not to fund a program at all is different from rejecting particular applicants because of their views. Researchers said agencies used keywords such as “diversity,” a method that also flagged projects with titles involving leaf diversity and legume rhizobia.
The appeals court ruled 3-0 that the terminations likely violated the First Amendment. The Supreme Court rejected the administration’s appeal, leaving that ruling in force for now, but did not settle the broader questions. The administration maintains that it has lawful authority to administer funding programs and end taxpayer-funded DEI initiatives.
How does the Constitution distinguish between the government choosing what speech to fund and punishing people for expressing certain views?
The Constitution’s First Amendment protects freedom of speech, and the appeals court applied that protection to the grant dispute. As the 9th Circuit described Supreme Court precedent, the government’s decision not to fund a program is different from refusing particular applicants because of their viewpoints. The distinction matters when public money supports work expressing ideas.
The court said the agencies’ terminations were aimed at suppressing viewpoints the government disagreed with, and therefore likely violated the First Amendment. Researchers pointed to the use of keywords such as “diversity” to screen grants. They said that process swept in projects whose titles used the word in contexts such as leaf diversity and legume rhizobia.
The administration argued that government can choose to fund projects aligned with its perspective and promote favored viewpoints through public spending. The Supreme Court rejected its appeal, leaving the 9th Circuit’s ruling intact for now. It did not resolve the wider debate over the government’s authority to select funded speech, so that broader constitutional question remains open.
This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.
Read more in the JupiteX app
Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.
Or read more news on the web