COP 31: Who qualifies for loss and damage funding? Why country borders are a poor guide
The Fund for Responding to Loss and Damage is intended to support developing countries considered “particularly vulnerable” to climate change. That label matters because it can determine which countries qualify for funding and how limited money is shared. The definition is still under debate, so the eligible list has not been settled. The meaning of “particularly vulnerable” has shifted over time. The 1992 U.N. climate convention referred to places such as small islands, low-lying coasts and drought-prone areas. In 2007, governments identified least developed countries, small island states and African countries affected by drought, desertification and floods as most at risk. The fund was officially launched in 2023, but the article reports no agreed final definition. A country-only list could leave out communities facing severe harm just across a border. The authors argue that African negotiators at COP31 should push for support to reach people in need across all developing countries, with communities able to access funds directly rather than relying only on government payouts.
Who is the Loss and Damage fund intended to support, and has the list of eligible countries been settled?
The Fund for Responding to Loss and Damage is intended to support developing countries considered “particularly vulnerable” to climate change. That label matters because it can determine which countries qualify for funding and how limited money is shared. The definition is still under debate, so the eligible list has not been settled.
The meaning of “particularly vulnerable” has shifted over time. The 1992 U.N. climate convention referred to places such as small islands, low-lying coasts and drought-prone areas. In 2007, governments identified least developed countries, small island states and African countries affected by drought, desertification and floods as most at risk.
The fund was officially launched in 2023, but the article reports no agreed final definition. A country-only list could leave out communities facing severe harm just across a border. The authors argue that African negotiators at COP31 should push for support to reach people in need across all developing countries, with communities able to access funds directly rather than relying only on government payouts.
What is loss and damage funding, and what kinds of harm is it meant to help people recover from?
Loss and Damage funding is financial support for developing countries coping with harms caused by climate change. The fund was created after governments agreed at COP27 in 2022 that there should be a clear way to help countries pay for climate damage. It is intended for countries considered particularly vulnerable.
The harms can affect both people’s lives and the things they depend on. The article names destroyed homes and livelihoods, loss of life, and damage to cultural heritage. In the Horn of Africa, for example, a prolonged drought caused pastoralist families in Ethiopia and Kenya to lose cattle, their primary livelihood.
The fund is called the Fund for Responding to Loss and Damage and was officially launched in 2023. Its resources remain far below estimated needs: the article reports pledges of about $770.6 million at COP28, while annual economic costs run into the trillions. The authors say eligibility should reach vulnerable communities across developing countries, including through direct access to funds.
How much money has been pledged or set aside for the fund, compared with the estimated annual costs of climate-related loss and damage?
The gap between available funding and need is enormous. At COP28, developed country parties pledged about $770.6 million to the Fund for Responding to Loss and Damage. But only a fraction of that pledged money had been received, and just $250 million had been set aside for initial grants.
Those amounts are small beside the estimated economic costs of climate-related loss and damage, which run into the trillions of dollars a year. The fund is meant to help developing countries considered particularly vulnerable cope with harms such as destroyed homes and livelihoods, lost lives and damage to cultural heritage. The money is not close to covering those existing costs.
The article describes the fund as far too small to meet the costs of coping with climate disasters. Because resources are scarce, eligibility rules matter: narrowing the list of countries can further restrict who receives support. The definition of “particularly vulnerable” remains unsettled, and the authors urge negotiators to ensure funding reaches the communities that need it most.
What can happen to vulnerable communities if eligibility is based only on national categories such as development status?
Climate vulnerability does not neatly follow national borders or a country’s development category. If funding eligibility relies only on such labels, communities suffering similar harm may face different chances of receiving support. The article warns that a narrow definition can leave the most vulnerable communities without what it calls their fair share.
The Horn of Africa drought of 2020–2023 affected pastoralist families in Ethiopia and Kenya. Ethiopia is classified as a least developed country, while Kenya is lower-middle-income. Yet families on both sides lost cattle, their primary source of livelihood. The drought’s impact did not stop at the border, even though a system ranking countries by development status would treat the communities differently.
The fund’s eligibility definition is still under debate, and its resources are already far below estimated needs. The authors argue that support should reach people facing imminent and irreversible harm in all developing countries, including communities outside any agreed list of particularly vulnerable countries. They also recommend direct access for communities, rather than payouts only to governments.
Why did the Horn of Africa drought affect pastoralist families in Ethiopia and Kenya similarly, despite the countries having different development classifications?
The drought affected people according to their exposure and livelihoods, not according to the category assigned to their country. Ethiopia is classified as a least developed country, while Kenya is lower-middle-income. Those different labels do not mean that people facing the same climate hazard experience different kinds of harm.
In the Horn of Africa, the 2020–2023 drought affected communities in both countries. Pastoralist families on either side lost cattle, which the article describes as their primary source of livelihood. The drought’s effects did not stop at the international border, and the article says this year’s super El Niño is making its impact on both countries much worse.
A system that ranks countries by development status could nevertheless treat the affected families differently. That is why the authors say national categories are a poor guide to vulnerability and funding. They argue that definitions should allow support to reach people who need it across developing countries, rather than letting country labels determine who is eligible.
How can a country's ability to apply for and manage funds affect who actually receives climate support?
The article does not explain how a country’s administrative capacity affects its application or management of funding. It does, however, identify who controls access as important. If the fund pays out only to governments, communities seeking help must rely on government channels to reach that money.
The authors argue that communities at risk of imminent and irreversible harm need financial assistance, including when they are outside an agreed list of particularly vulnerable countries. They recommend that communities be given direct access to funds rather than having the fund pay only to governments. The article does not specify how direct access would work or what application requirements would apply.
Eligibility itself is still under debate, and the fund is far too small to meet existing costs. The authors’ proposal has two parts: broaden attention beyond country labels and make direct community access possible. That could change who is reached, but the article does not set out a process for applying, assessing capacity or managing grants.
What makes a person or community vulnerable to climate change beyond where they live or how wealthy their country is?
A person or community’s vulnerability to climate change cannot be judged simply by where they live or by their country’s gross domestic product. The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change says vulnerability varies widely both between and within regions. This matters because a national label can hide people facing serious risks inside a country that is not classified as particularly vulnerable.
The article identifies colonialism, inequality, exclusion and how people are governed as factors shaping vulnerability. The Horn of Africa example shows how people with different national classifications can share a similar exposure: pastoralist families in Ethiopia and Kenya both lost cattle during the drought. The article also points to residents of informal settlements in fast-growing African cities, smallholder farmers and displaced people.
The definition of “particularly vulnerable” has not been settled, and country-only rules could leave some communities out. The authors say eligibility should focus on people who need support across developing countries, including those outside an agreed country list. They also argue that communities should be able to access funds directly.
This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.
Read more in the JupiteX app
Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.
Or read more news on the web