JupiteX Get the app
Politics & Governance17 Nov 2026 · about 7 min

Nepali Prime Minister Balen Shah Continues to Test the Limits of Executive Power

The brief

The article describes a pattern of decisions that critics saw as Shah stretching executive authority and bypassing due process. This matters because government action can lose public confidence when it ignores established procedures, even when leaders say they are trying to clean up the state. At the start of his tenure, Shah’s government arrested former Prime Minister KP Sharma Oli and Home Minister Ramesh Lekhak over alleged efforts to suppress the Gen Z uprising. It then moved to clear riverside squatters in Kathmandu. Courts deemed both decisions questionable and overturned them. Later examples included sending senior bureaucrats into early retirement, bypassing seniority in appointing a Supreme Court chief justice, detaining journalists, and firing police chief Dan Bahadur Karki. The criticism extends beyond any single decision. The article says repeated overstepping has weakened public confidence and alienated RSP chair Rabi Lamichhane. The government’s approach has also raised concerns about press freedom and institutional decay. Shah’s mandate was large, but the article argues that urgency does not remove the need for consultation or due process.

01

Which decisions by Prime Minister Balen Shah have been criticized as overstepping executive power?

The article describes a pattern of decisions that critics saw as Shah stretching executive authority and bypassing due process. This matters because government action can lose public confidence when it ignores established procedures, even when leaders say they are trying to clean up the state.

At the start of his tenure, Shah’s government arrested former Prime Minister KP Sharma Oli and Home Minister Ramesh Lekhak over alleged efforts to suppress the Gen Z uprising. It then moved to clear riverside squatters in Kathmandu. Courts deemed both decisions questionable and overturned them. Later examples included sending senior bureaucrats into early retirement, bypassing seniority in appointing a Supreme Court chief justice, detaining journalists, and firing police chief Dan Bahadur Karki.

The criticism extends beyond any single decision. The article says repeated overstepping has weakened public confidence and alienated RSP chair Rabi Lamichhane. The government’s approach has also raised concerns about press freedom and institutional decay. Shah’s mandate was large, but the article argues that urgency does not remove the need for consultation or due process.

02

What does executive power mean, and what does it allow a prime minister to do?

The article does not define executive power. In general constitutional usage, it means the authority to administer government and carry out laws. A prime minister typically leads the executive branch, directing government policy and coordinating ministers and public agencies. This authority matters because it lets a government respond to public needs and put its plans into action.

That authority is not a personal license to act without limits. A prime minister’s decisions must operate within the country’s laws and constitutional arrangements, and may be checked by parliament or courts. The article gives examples of actions under Shah’s government: arrests, a move to clear riverside squatters, and changes involving officials and public institutions. It reports that courts overturned the arrests and the squatters’ removal.

The article portrays Shah as testing the limits of executive authority while acting quickly in the name of cleaning up government. It also describes risks: judicial reversals, officials afraid to decide, and weakened institutions. In a parliamentary system, consultation and cooperation matter too. Respecting legal limits, the article argues, can strengthen rather than obstruct effective government.

03

How many people were reported killed during the Gen Z uprising that preceded Shah’s government?

The reported death toll was at least 76 people. The article links those deaths to the September 2025 Gen Z uprising, which took place before Balendra Shah became prime minister. That figure gives a sense of the uprising’s human cost and helps explain why efforts to suppress it became a major issue in the transition that followed.

At the start of Shah’s tenure, his government arrested former Prime Minister KP Sharma Oli and Home Minister Ramesh Lekhak. They were accused of trying to suppress the uprising. The article does not say that the arrests established their guilt. It reports that courts deemed the arrests questionable and overturned them, making the legal process part of the political dispute.

The uprising also forms part of the article’s account of Shah’s mandate. It says mistrust of the old political forces culminated tragically in the uprising, after which the old guard was thrown out. Shah’s government won an overwhelming mandate in the March 2026 elections. The article warns that missteps could waste that mandate, but does not give a further death toll or details about individual victims.

04

What happened when courts reviewed the arrests of former officials and the removal of riverside squatters?

The courts reversed two prominent early decisions by Shah’s government: the arrests of former Prime Minister KP Sharma Oli and Home Minister Ramesh Lekhak, and the move to clear riverside squatters in Kathmandu. The reversals matter because they show that executive action can be challenged and stopped through legal review, rather than simply standing because a government ordered it.

The officials had been accused of trying to suppress the September 2025 Gen Z uprising, in which at least 76 people died. The article does not describe the detailed legal reasoning behind the rulings. It does say both decisions were deemed questionable and overturned in court, so it would be inaccurate to claim the court findings proved the officials innocent or settled every issue surrounding the actions.

The rulings did not end Shah’s efforts to test executive limits. His government later made contentious decisions on senior bureaucrats, judicial appointments, journalists, and the police chief. The article says repeated overstepping risks more judicial reversals and weakens public confidence. It argues that consultation and due process are necessary if the government is to use its mandate effectively.

05

Why are a prime minister’s responsibilities different from a mayor’s in Nepal?

The article draws a sharp distinction between the two jobs. A mayor is expected to develop a local jurisdiction independently and enjoys a high level of autonomy. A prime minister, by contrast, is answerable to the parliament that elects him. The difference matters because a national government must coordinate across many actors, and its leader faces more scrutiny and higher accountability standards.

Shah’s record as Kathmandu’s mayor helps explain why he may have carried the same governing style into the prime minister’s office. As mayor, he used bulldozers against squatter settlements and dumped garbage in front of the central secretariat to show displeasure with the federal government. The article says he often communicated through brief social media posts rather than interviews. Those actions illustrate a unilateral style, but do not remove the different demands of national leadership.

As prime minister, Shah needs cooperation from ministers, public agencies, parliament, and his party. The article says the PMO cannot function without coordination with a wide set of actors. It warns that bypassing them can lead to weak cooperation, institutional decay, and lost public confidence. Consultation and due process, it argues, are part of effective governing, not merely obstacles to it.

06

In a parliamentary system, why does a prime minister need support from parliament and their political party to govern?

A parliamentary prime minister depends on political support to keep government functioning. The article says Nepal’s system makes it difficult for a prime minister to govern effectively without strong backing from the party that brought him to office. Support matters not just for political legitimacy, but also for coordination among ministers and the wider government.

The article describes a rift between Shah and Rabi Lamichhane, chair of the ruling Rastriya Swatantra Party. Lamichhane’s view is that Shah has bypassed the party and even his ministers on important decisions. Shah, who is described as naturally reclusive, leads through a coterie of advisers. The article connects this approach to decisions made with little consultation, including sending senior bureaucrats into early retirement.

The government’s functioning has caused disquiet within the RSP, while public confidence has eroded. The article warns that a prime minister cannot rely only on an election mandate or a personal governing style. Without party and ministerial cooperation, decisions may face resistance and institutions may weaken. Consultation could help Shah preserve the mandate won in the March 2026 elections.

07

How do due process and independent courts help limit the power of a government?

The article does not give a formal definition of due process or explain court independence in detail. In general, due process means following fair legal procedures before the government acts against people or their rights. Independent courts can review whether government decisions follow the law. These safeguards matter because they give people a way to challenge state action and help keep executive authority within legal limits.

The article’s clearest examples are the arrests of former Prime Minister KP Sharma Oli and Home Minister Ramesh Lekhak, and the move to clear riverside squatters in Kathmandu. Courts deemed both decisions questionable and overturned them. The article does not describe the legal reasoning, but the outcomes demonstrate that government orders can be reviewed rather than treated as final simply because officials issued them.

The article also warns that rushed decisions can bring judicial reversals, make officials afraid to act, and contribute to institutional decay. It says Shah’s government has faced criticism over detaining journalists and other actions that bypassed consultation. Respecting due process does not mean abandoning urgency, the article argues; it means using legal and institutional checks so that action can endure and earn public confidence.

This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.

Read more in the JupiteX app

Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.

Or read more news on the web