JupiteX Get the app
Politics & Governance17 Nov 2026 · about 7 min

Proposed NSW laws to allow coalmine to increase production pose ‘serious corruption risk’

The brief

The bill would allow MACH Energy to increase production at the Mount Pleasant mine in Muswellbrook. It would also give the resources minister unusually broad powers to change how state laws apply to the development. That combination matters because critics say it could concentrate significant power in one minister’s hands. The proposed production limit would rise by 32%, to 16.5 million tonnes a year. The government introduced the bill after the High Court ruled that the mine’s expansion had been invalidly approved. The government says legislation is needed to prevent 400 job losses at the site before Christmas. Parliament is expected to debate the bill in the lower house and then the upper house this week. The government hopes to pass it during what is likely to be the final sitting week before the March 2027 election. Critics are pressing to remove or restrict the ministerial power, while the government says it has taken advice and believes the clause is sound.

01

What would the proposed bill allow at the Mount Pleasant mine, and why does the government say it is needed?

The bill would allow MACH Energy to increase production at the Mount Pleasant mine in Muswellbrook. It would also give the resources minister unusually broad powers to change how state laws apply to the development. That combination matters because critics say it could concentrate significant power in one minister’s hands.

The proposed production limit would rise by 32%, to 16.5 million tonnes a year. The government introduced the bill after the High Court ruled that the mine’s expansion had been invalidly approved. The government says legislation is needed to prevent 400 job losses at the site before Christmas.

Parliament is expected to debate the bill in the lower house and then the upper house this week. The government hopes to pass it during what is likely to be the final sitting week before the March 2027 election. Critics are pressing to remove or restrict the ministerial power, while the government says it has taken advice and believes the clause is sound.

02

How much more coal could the mine produce each year if the bill passes?

The bill would raise Mount Pleasant’s annual production limit by 32%, bringing it to 16.5 million tonnes. That is the clearest measure of the proposed increase and the scale of the change being debated in parliament.

The article does not state the current limit or the extra tonnage as a separate figure. Using the stated increase and new limit, the current limit is about 12.5 million tonnes a year, so the added production would be about 4 million tonnes annually. This is a calculation from the rounded percentage and total, rather than a separate figure quoted in the article.

The proposed increase is for MACH Energy’s mine in Muswellbrook. It is part of legislation the Minns government introduced after the High Court ruled the expansion had been invalidly approved. The government says the bill is needed to prevent 400 job losses before Christmas. Parliament is due to consider the bill this week, but the article does not say whether it will pass.

03

What is a Henry VIII clause, and what power would this one give the resources minister?

A Henry VIII clause is a provision that lets a minister make regulations that modify laws passed by the state parliament. The name refers to King Henry VIII and his style of governing by royal proclamation. Parliaments sometimes use these provisions, but critics say this one gives unusually broad power.

Clause 17 would let the resources minister make regulations to modify state laws as they apply to the Mount Pleasant development. Geoffrey Watson’s legal analysis says it could put power to make new laws, or repeal or modify existing ones, in the hands of one minister for one mine owner. Elaine Johnson also described the power as unfettered.

The government says it has taken advice and believes the clause is sound. The Greens want the clause removed or its scope limited, and some crossbench members have raised concerns. Parliament’s legislation review committee was expected to report on the bill on Tuesday. The article does not give the committee’s findings or detail specific limits on the minister’s power.

04

What laws affecting the mine could the minister potentially change, and why do critics say concentrating that power creates a corruption risk?

The proposed clause could affect laws that apply to Mount Pleasant, rather than only one narrow rule. That matters because such laws can protect workers and communities. Critics say concentrating broad law-changing powers in a single minister can create opportunities for decisions that do not serve the public interest.

Elaine Johnson said the minister could potentially change laws regulating noise and dust or worker safety. Geoffrey Watson said clause 17 would let the minister make new laws or repeal or modify existing ones for a single coalmine owner. He described the concentration of power as a serious corruption risk, while stressing that corruption can include undue influence, not only money changing hands.

The government says it has taken advice on the clause and believes it is sound. Watson said he imputed no bad faith to the current minister, but pointed to past experience with ministers acting for improper motives. The Greens plan to seek removal of the clause or limits on its scope. The article does not specify which laws would actually be changed.

05

What did the High Court rule about the mine’s expansion, and how did that lead to the proposed bill?

The High Court ruled that an expansion of Mount Pleasant mine was invalidly approved. The ruling left the proposed expansion unable to proceed under that approval, creating the immediate background for the government’s bill. The article does not give further details about the court’s legal reasoning.

The Minns government announced legislation after the ruling. It would let MACH Energy increase production at the mine in Muswellbrook by 32%, to 16.5 million tonnes per year. The bill also includes clause 17, which would allow the resources minister to make regulations modifying state laws as they apply to the development.

The government says the legislation is necessary to prevent 400 job losses at the site before Christmas. Critics, including Geoffrey Watson, the Greens and some crossbench members, have raised concerns about the minister’s broad powers. Parliament is expected to debate the bill in both houses this week. The government hopes to pass it in the likely final sitting week before the March 2027 election.

06

What checks does the government say would apply to regulations made under the bill?

The article does not spell out what checks would apply to regulations made under clause 17. That omission matters because the clause is described as giving the minister broad power to change how state laws apply to one mine. The information provided concerns advice and review of the bill, not a stated process for scrutinising each regulation.

The resources minister’s spokesperson said the bill’s purpose was to protect permanent workers at Mount Pleasant. Yasmin Catley said the government had taken advice on the Henry VIII clause and believed it was sound. The Coalition said it would follow advice from parliament’s legislation review committee, whose report was expected on Tuesday.

The article does not report the committee’s findings or say whether it proposed safeguards. Nor does it describe requirements for parliamentary approval, public consultation or other oversight of regulations. The Greens said they would seek to remove the clause or limit its scope. So the checks described in the account relate to advice and scrutiny of the bill, rather than confirmed controls over future ministerial regulations.

07

How does giving ministers power to make or change rules differ from Parliament passing laws, and why do democratic systems place checks on that power?

In general, a parliament debates and passes statutes, while ministers may be authorised to make regulations that fill in details or implement a law. Regulations are not the same as a fresh act passed by parliament. Democratic systems place checks on delegated powers so elected lawmakers can scrutinise how authority is used and ministers remain accountable. This is general background; the article does not describe a particular checking system for this bill.

Here, clause 17 would let the resources minister make regulations modifying state laws as they apply to Mount Pleasant. Geoffrey Watson says it could put the power to make new laws or change existing ones in one person’s hands, for one mine owner. Elaine Johnson says it could potentially affect laws covering noise, dust and worker safety.

The government says it has taken advice and believes the clause is sound. The legislation review committee was expected to advise parliament on the bill, but the article gives no findings or specific safeguards for regulations. The Greens want the provision removed or its scope narrowed. The debate is therefore about both the bill’s purpose and the reach of its delegated power.

This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.

Read more in the JupiteX app

Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.

Or read more news on the web