JupiteX Get the app
Politics & Governance17 Nov 2026 · about 7 min

Miliband says he won't resign if government approves Rosebank oil field

The brief

Collective responsibility is the rule Miliband invoked: ministers must publicly support government decisions, even when they personally disagree. It lets a government present an agreed position rather than having ministers openly contradict an adopted decision. The rule concerns what ministers say as members of government; it does not mean they must privately agree. Rosebank makes the rule concrete. Miliband once called the project “climate vandalism” and a “colossal waste of taxpayer money”. Yet he told the BBC he would “definitely not” resign if the government approved it. He said he would abide by collective responsibility and would not second-guess the decision. That means his earlier criticism does not, by itself, require him to leave office if the project proceeds. The article says ministers must publicly support government decisions, but does not detail every practical requirement of the convention. The decision belongs to energy secretary Miatta Fahnbulleh, and Miliband says he will follow the government position once it is made.

01

What does collective responsibility require ministers to do when the government makes a decision they disagree with?

Collective responsibility is the rule Miliband invoked: ministers must publicly support government decisions, even when they personally disagree. It lets a government present an agreed position rather than having ministers openly contradict an adopted decision. The rule concerns what ministers say as members of government; it does not mean they must privately agree.

Rosebank makes the rule concrete. Miliband once called the project “climate vandalism” and a “colossal waste of taxpayer money”. Yet he told the BBC he would “definitely not” resign if the government approved it. He said he would abide by collective responsibility and would not second-guess the decision.

That means his earlier criticism does not, by itself, require him to leave office if the project proceeds. The article says ministers must publicly support government decisions, but does not detail every practical requirement of the convention. The decision belongs to energy secretary Miatta Fahnbulleh, and Miliband says he will follow the government position once it is made.

02

Why can Ed Miliband oppose Rosebank but still say he will not resign if the government approves it?

Miliband’s position separates his personal view from his role in government. While Labour was in opposition, he called Rosebank “climate vandalism” and a “colossal waste of taxpayer money”. Now he says he will obey collective responsibility, which requires ministers to publicly support government decisions even when they disagree with them.

That is why he told the BBC he would “definitely not” resign if Rosebank were approved. He also said he would not second-guess Miatta Fahnbulleh, who succeeded him as energy secretary and will make the decision. Miliband described it as a quasi-judicial decision in which she considers the evidence before reaching a conclusion.

The article does not say whether Miliband has changed his underlying opinion about Rosebank. It does show that he intends to stay in government and follow its collective position if the field gets the go-ahead. The outcome remains undecided, and the energy secretary is responsible for reaching it.

03

Who will decide Rosebank’s future, and what does it mean that the decision is described as quasi-judicial?

Miatta Fahnbulleh, who succeeded Miliband as energy secretary in July, will decide whether Rosebank gets the go-ahead. The choice matters because Rosebank is Britain’s largest untapped oil field, and approval would allow development of a project that has been contested in Parliament and in court.

Miliband described the choice as “quasi-judicial”. In his explanation, Fahnbulleh will look at all the evidence and then reach a conclusion. He said he would not second-guess her decision. The article does not give a fuller legal definition of the term, so its concrete explanation is the process Miliband described.

The decision has not yet been made. Some people in Parliament believe it could come as soon as the end of this month. Labour MPs are divided: at least 75 have signed a letter opposing Rosebank, while others support it. Once Fahnbulleh decides, Miliband says he will abide by collective responsibility.

04

Where is Rosebank, and how large is it compared with other untapped UK oil fields?

Rosebank is in the North Sea, about 80 miles (128km) north-west of Shetland. The article identifies it as Britain’s largest untapped oil field. That makes it a major proposed development, although the article does not provide measurements or rankings for other untapped UK oil fields to quantify the difference.

If approved, Rosebank is expected to produce up to 500 million barrels of oil over a 25-year lifetime, as well as some gas. Those figures describe the expected output and duration, not the field’s physical size. Its scale is part of why the decision has drawn strong views from Labour MPs, environmental campaigners and Conservatives.

The field’s future is still under consideration. Energy secretary Miatta Fahnbulleh will make the new decision, after an earlier approval was ruled unlawful. Some people in Parliament think a decision could come as soon as the end of this month. Approval would not guarantee lower UK energy bills, since prices are set by international markets.

05

Why does the government have to make a new decision after Rosebank’s original approval was challenged in court?

Rosebank was first granted a licence by the Conservative UK government in 2023. That approval was challenged in court, so the project’s future did not rest on the original decision alone. The legal challenge brought the approval process back into question and left the current government to decide whether to give the project a go-ahead.

The Court of Session in Edinburgh ruled last year that the government had made the approval unlawfully. The article does not provide further detail about the court’s legal reasoning. It says the ruling left the current Labour government responsible for making a new decision, rather than treating the 2023 approval as still valid.

Miatta Fahnbulleh, who succeeded Miliband as energy secretary, will now consider Rosebank’s future. Miliband describes her decision as quasi-judicial: she will look at all the evidence and reach a conclusion. Some people in Parliament believe the decision could come as soon as the end of this month, but no outcome is stated.

06

If Rosebank produces more oil, why might that not make energy bills cheaper in the UK?

The key point is that more oil produced from a UK field does not directly set the price households pay. The article says oil prices are determined by international markets. That link matters because a larger supply from Rosebank would not, on its own, ensure that prices fall for people in Britain.

Rosebank is expected to produce up to 500 million barrels over its 25-year lifetime if approved. But the article explicitly says there is no guarantee that this extra supply would result in cheaper UK energy bills. It does not give a forecast for prices or say how much of the oil would be used in Britain.

This uncertainty is part of the wider argument over the field. Supporters point to investment and skilled North Sea work, while environmental campaigners say Rosebank would not meaningfully improve UK energy security or bills. The government’s decision is still pending, and approval alone would not settle the question of what consumers pay.

07

How does burning oil and gas contribute to climate change, and what does the UK’s net-zero target require?

Oil and gas are fossil fuels. As general climate science, burning them releases carbon dioxide, a greenhouse gas that traps heat in the atmosphere; the article links Rosebank’s production to planet-warming greenhouse gases. This is why approval is part of a wider debate about climate change, not only energy supply.

The article says environmental campaigners believe Rosebank would hamper efforts to tackle climate change and produce far more planet-warming greenhouse gases than Jackdaw. It also says the UK wants to limit global warming to no more than 1.5C above the pre-industrial period. The article does not detail the emissions from burning each barrel of oil.

The UK is committed to reaching net zero by 2050. The article defines this as cutting carbon emissions until the country removes as much as it produces. Miliband argues for a transition to wind, solar and nuclear power, describing these as homegrown clean energy. Rosebank’s approval decision is still pending.

This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.

Read more in the JupiteX app

Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.

Or read more news on the web