Early black holes may have grown through productive chaos
Chaotic accretion is a way for an early black hole to grow without starting unusually massive or exceeding the Eddington limit. The “chaos” describes gas arriving from changing directions, rather than a change to the basic speed limit on accretion. In the proposed model, gas falls into a slowly rotating dark matter halo from essentially random directions. Each stream makes a small disk tilted relative to the black hole’s spin. It feeds the black hole briefly, then another differently tilted disk follows. Some episodes spin the black hole up; counter-rotating disks spin it down. Spin-down is rarer, but more efficient per unit of mass, so the black hole tends to stay slowly spinning. That low spin matters because the black hole radiates only about 6 to 7.5% of the swallowed mass, rather than about 10%. The authors find that this can explain known high-redshift mass estimates with a small seed, provided feeding is nearly continuous. The model works, but does not rule out other explanations.
What does “chaotic accretion” mean in this explanation of early black-hole growth?
Chaotic accretion is a way for an early black hole to grow without starting unusually massive or exceeding the Eddington limit. The “chaos” describes gas arriving from changing directions, rather than a change to the basic speed limit on accretion.
In the proposed model, gas falls into a slowly rotating dark matter halo from essentially random directions. Each stream makes a small disk tilted relative to the black hole’s spin. It feeds the black hole briefly, then another differently tilted disk follows. Some episodes spin the black hole up; counter-rotating disks spin it down. Spin-down is rarer, but more efficient per unit of mass, so the black hole tends to stay slowly spinning.
That low spin matters because the black hole radiates only about 6 to 7.5% of the swallowed mass, rather than about 10%. The authors find that this can explain known high-redshift mass estimates with a small seed, provided feeding is nearly continuous. The model works, but does not rule out other explanations.
How massive was the black hole powering J0313-1806, and how early in the universe did it already reach that size?
The black hole powering the quasar J0313-1806 had grown to about 3 billion times the sun’s mass when the universe was less than 700 million years old. That makes it one of the most extreme examples of a long-standing puzzle: how supermassive black holes became so large so soon.
The article explains the challenge using the Eddington limit. With the usual assumption that about 10% of infalling mass becomes radiation, a black hole’s mass increases by a factor of about 2.7 every 45 million years. Starting from a stellar-mass black hole of about 100 solar masses would take roughly 17 such growth steps, or about 770 million years, to reach 3 billion solar masses.
That is longer than the available time once the formation of the stellar black hole is counted; the universe had less than 600 million years available. The proposed chaotic-accretion model shortens the needed growth time to about 550 million years, but requires sustained feeding.
How can gas arriving from randomly changing directions keep a black hole spinning slowly?
In this explanation, gas reaches the black hole in a changing sequence of directions. The model assumes the surrounding dark matter halo rotates slowly, so incoming gas has no single consistent direction. This matters because each gas stream forms its own small disk, tilted relative to the black hole’s spin.
The disks feed the black hole briefly before another, differently tilted disk arrives. Some episodes spin the black hole up. When a disk counter-rotates, it spins the black hole down. Such spin-down episodes are rarer, but they are more efficient per unit of mass than spin-up episodes. Across many episodes, that greater efficiency helps keep the black hole’s spin low.
The low spin is important to the growth proposal because a slowly spinning black hole radiates away a smaller share of the swallowed mass. The model therefore connects randomly directed gas supply to faster mass growth. It is a proposed scenario, not proof that all early black holes grew this way; the authors compare it with mass estimates and suggest tests using future observations.
Why can a slowly spinning black hole grow faster by turning less of the swallowed matter into light?
Gas falling toward a black hole heats up and shines. That light pushes against gas still arriving, setting a growth limit called the Eddington limit. How much of the infalling mass becomes radiation matters: energy radiated away is not retained as black-hole mass.
In the chaotic-accretion model, differently oriented gas disks tend to keep the black hole spinning slowly. The article says a slowly spinning black hole radiates away only about 6 to 7.5% of the mass it swallows, compared with the usual assumption of about 10%. With less mass converted into light, more of the swallowed material contributes to the black hole’s growth.
The difference shortens the growth timescale from 45 million years to roughly 27–32 million years. For J0313-1806, the estimated time to grow falls from about 770 million years to about 550 million years. The gas supply on large scales can exceed the Eddington rate, while the amount reaching the event horizon stays near that rate and most excess material is removed along the way.
How does chaotic accretion differ from growing a black hole from a massive seed or feeding it above the Eddington limit?
The article describes three ways to explain very massive early black holes. A heavy-seed model begins with at least 10,000 solar masses, formed through direct collapse of enormous gas clouds. A second option is super-Eddington growth, in which energy from infalling gas is removed in ways other than radiation so the black hole can grow faster than the usual limit.
Chaotic accretion takes a different route. It starts with a seed of about 100 solar masses or smaller. Gas arrives from changing directions, keeping the black hole’s spin low. The lower radiation efficiency then shortens the time needed for growth, without requiring the material reaching the event horizon to exceed the Eddington rate.
Each alternative has uncertainties. Direct collapse needs a rare combination of conditions, and it is uncertain whether real accretion flows can remain super-Eddington for hundreds of millions of years. The chaotic model fits the most reliable mass estimates discussed in the article, but the authors stress that this shows it can work, not that the other explanations fail.
What future observations could show whether chaotic accretion is right, or rule it out?
The proposed model makes predictions that differ from the alternatives. Chaotic accretion predicts slow spins for the most massive early black holes. Sustained super-Eddington growth, by contrast, should leave them spinning rapidly. Spin can be measured from the shape of X-ray emission lines, but existing measurements are at lower redshifts and remain ambiguous.
The article identifies ESA’s planned NewAthena observatory as best suited to measuring these spins. It is not expected to launch until at least 2037. Another prediction concerns the largest black-hole masses: they should rise rapidly until redshift 7.5, then nearly plateau.
Current data hint at that pattern, but cover too little volume to settle the question. Several distant black holes also lack robust mass estimates and could be useful observation targets. Together, clearer spin measurements and broader samples of early black holes could strengthen or challenge the chaotic-accretion scenario; the article presents these as future tests, not results already in hand.
What is the Eddington limit, and how does the push of radiation against gravity set a black hole’s growth rate?
The Eddington limit is the point at which radiation pressure from hot, infalling gas balances gravity. As gas falls toward a black hole, it heats up and shines. The radiation pushes on gas that is still arriving, opposing the black hole’s pull. At the balance point, infall cannot speed up further.
This sets a pace for growth, but the black hole’s mass still increases exponentially because the limit scales with its mass. With the usual assumption that about 10% of infalling mass is converted into radiation, the black hole grows by a factor of e, or about 2.7, every 45 million years.
That pace creates a problem for early supermassive black holes. A seed of about 100 solar masses needs roughly 770 million years to reach 3 billion solar masses at that rate, while less than 600 million years was available after accounting for seed formation. The chaotic-accretion proposal keeps growth near the limit but lowers radiation efficiency, shortening the required time.
This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.
Read more in the JupiteX app
Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.
Or read more news on the web