Orissa HC orders ₹15 lakh compensation to family of undertrial prisoner who died in jail
The Orissa High Court directed the state government to provide ₹15 lakh in compensation to the family of Charan Behera, an undertrial prisoner who died in jail. It also ordered a government job for his wife. The ruling matters because it holds the state accountable for failing to protect someone in its custody. The court relied on a judicial inquiry into Behera’s death at Bhanjanagar Special Sub-Jail in July 2023. The inquiry found that he died from injuries inside the jail before being taken to hospital. It also concluded that his life could have been saved if jail staff had followed their duties under the Odisha Jail Manual. The judgment directs ₹10 lakh to Behera’s wife and ₹5 lakh into a six-year fixed deposit for their minor daughter. The court rejected the state’s argument that compensation should be limited to ₹3 lakh. Its decision reaffirmed that prisoners retain their fundamental rights and that the state must protect them.
What did the Orissa High Court order the state to provide to the prisoner’s family?
The Orissa High Court directed the state government to provide ₹15 lakh in compensation to the family of Charan Behera, an undertrial prisoner who died in jail. It also ordered a government job for his wife. The ruling matters because it holds the state accountable for failing to protect someone in its custody.
The court relied on a judicial inquiry into Behera’s death at Bhanjanagar Special Sub-Jail in July 2023. The inquiry found that he died from injuries inside the jail before being taken to hospital. It also concluded that his life could have been saved if jail staff had followed their duties under the Odisha Jail Manual.
The judgment directs ₹10 lakh to Behera’s wife and ₹5 lakh into a six-year fixed deposit for their minor daughter. The court rejected the state’s argument that compensation should be limited to ₹3 lakh. Its decision reaffirmed that prisoners retain their fundamental rights and that the state must protect them.
What did the judicial inquiry find about how the prisoner died and the role of jail staff?
A judicial inquiry concluded that Charan Behera died a homicidal death inside Bhanjanagar Special Sub-Jail before he was moved to hospital. The findings matter because they contradicted the jail superintendent’s claim that Behera had died of cardiac arrest and pointed to violence and possible failures by staff.
The inquiry attributed Behera’s injuries to an alleged assault by Ajay Naik, a life convict-cum-watcher, using a plastic pipe. Three undertrial prisoners from the same quarantine ward said Naik had severely assaulted him. Their accounts were supported by the jail medical officer and post-mortem findings of multiple injuries. The medical officer said Behera had multiple injuries and no palpable pulse before being taken to hospital.
The inquiry expressed serious doubts about jail officials’ conduct and recorded that staff appeared reluctant to disclose what happened. It also noted allegations of an attempt to influence a witness. The inquiry concluded that Behera could have been saved if staff had performed their duties under the Odisha Jail Manual; the High Court held jail-authority negligence led to his death.
How is the ₹15 lakh compensation divided between the prisoner’s wife and daughter?
The High Court divided the ₹15 lakh compensation between Behera’s wife and their minor daughter. The arrangement provides money directly to his wife while setting aside a separate amount for the child. The court made this allocation as part of its order following his death in jail.
Under the judgment, ₹10 lakh is to be paid to the wife. The remaining ₹5 lakh is to be placed in a fixed deposit in the name of their minor daughter for six years. The source does not give further terms for the deposit or explain when the family will receive the payment.
The order followed the family’s petition seeking ₹15 lakh in compensation and a government job for the widow. The state had argued that the family was entitled to only ₹3 lakh in a custodial-death case. The court instead relied on judicial precedents and the inquiry findings, holding that the petitioners were entitled to the compensation sought. The separate deposit preserves the child’s allocated share for the specified period.
What immediate support will the compensation and government job provide for the family?
Behera’s death left his wife, three minor children and aged parents without the family’s primary source of livelihood, according to his wife. The court’s order combines compensation with a government job for her. Together, these measures are intended to address both immediate financial needs and the loss of an earning member, although the judgment’s practical timing is not reported.
The court ordered ₹10 lakh paid to the wife and directed that ₹5 lakh be kept in a six-year fixed deposit for their minor daughter. It also ordered a government job for the widow. The article does not specify the position, salary, start date or when the compensation will be disbursed, so those details cannot be assumed.
The family had sought ₹15 lakh with interest and a government job. The High Court granted the compensation sought and ordered the job, rejecting the state’s position that only ₹3 lakh was payable. The order provides a defined financial allocation and employment support, while the daughter’s share is held for six years. The judgment also places responsibility on the state to protect prisoners in custody.
What is an undertrial prisoner, and how is that different from someone who has been convicted?
An undertrial prisoner is generally a person held in custody while a criminal case is pending and before a final determination of guilt. That differs from a convicted person, whose guilt has been established by a court. This is the standard meaning of the term; the article does not set out a legal definition.
The article identifies Charan Behera as an undertrial after his arrest on July 11, 2023, in connection with a theft case. He was remanded to judicial custody and lodged at Bhanjanagar Special Sub-Jail. It separately describes Ajay Naik, whom the inquiry identified as the alleged assailant, as a life convict-cum-watcher.
The distinction matters because being held before trial does not mean a person has lost fundamental rights. The High Court emphasized that undertrial prisoners retain the right to life and dignity under Article 21 while in custody. In Behera’s case, the court held the state accountable for his death and ordered compensation. The article does not report the outcome of the theft case against him.
What does Article 21 protect for people in prison, including their right to life and dignity?
Article 21 of the Constitution protects the right to life and personal liberty. In this case, the High Court specifically emphasized that prisoners retain fundamental rights, including basic human rights and the right to life and dignity. Its point was that custody does not remove those protections.
The court applied that principle to Charan Behera, who was held as an undertrial at Bhanjanagar Special Sub-Jail. A judicial inquiry found that he died from injuries inflicted inside the jail and said his life could have been saved if jail authorities had done their duties properly. The court rejected the idea that the state could avoid responsibility by invoking immunity for sovereign acts.
The judgment ordered ₹15 lakh in compensation and a government job for Behera’s wife. It also stated that the state has a strict obligation to ensure prisoners’ safety and security. The ruling therefore links the constitutional right to life and dignity with the state’s responsibility when people are in its custody. It confirms that detention does not make a person’s basic rights disappear.
Why does holding someone in custody give the state a special duty to protect their safety?
When the state holds someone in custody, it is responsible for that person’s safety and security, the High Court said. The duty matters because prisoners depend on jail authorities and staff while confined. The court also stressed that a prisoner’s fundamental rights continue to apply during custody.
In Behera’s case, a judicial inquiry concluded that he died from injuries inside Bhanjanagar Special Sub-Jail before he was taken to hospital. It found that jail staff appeared reluctant to disclose how he died and said his life could have been saved if they had discharged their duties under the Odisha Jail Manual. The High Court treated the inquiry findings as grounds for holding the authorities accountable.
The court ordered the state to pay ₹15 lakh to the family and provide Behera’s wife with a government job. It stated that the state is accountable for violations of prisoners’ fundamental rights in custody. The ruling makes clear that the state cannot rely on an old immunity defence to defeat those rights. The article reports this judgment, but does not describe any further steps by jail authorities.
This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.
Read more in the JupiteX app
Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.
Or read more news on the web