Glut of paddy, but India imports pulses: Here's why farmers aren't switching crops
India can have surplus rice and still import pulses because farmers respond to the returns and incentives attached to crops. The mismatch matters: high rice stocks do not automatically lead farmers to plant more pulses. Gulati said agricultural policy needs a rethink if farmers are to diversify and earn better returns. He said India imports five to six million tonnes of pulses each year, even though it is the world’s largest rice producer and exporter. In his view, policies have favoured rice and sugarcane, while a large share of fertiliser subsidies goes to those crops. Pulses need less fertiliser support, he noted. Gulati proposed an incentive of Rs 35,000 per hectare for farmers growing pulses. He said this could save power and fertiliser subsidy spending and help India become self-reliant in pulses within three years. That outcome depends on policy giving farmers a reason to change, not merely on the existence of surplus rice.
Why does India import pulses even though it has surplus rice?
India can have surplus rice and still import pulses because farmers respond to the returns and incentives attached to crops. The mismatch matters: high rice stocks do not automatically lead farmers to plant more pulses. Gulati said agricultural policy needs a rethink if farmers are to diversify and earn better returns.
He said India imports five to six million tonnes of pulses each year, even though it is the world’s largest rice producer and exporter. In his view, policies have favoured rice and sugarcane, while a large share of fertiliser subsidies goes to those crops. Pulses need less fertiliser support, he noted.
Gulati proposed an incentive of Rs 35,000 per hectare for farmers growing pulses. He said this could save power and fertiliser subsidy spending and help India become self-reliant in pulses within three years. That outcome depends on policy giving farmers a reason to change, not merely on the existence of surplus rice.
How many tonnes of pulses does India import each year?
India imports five to six million tonnes of pulses every year, according to agricultural economist Ashok Gulati. The figure stands out because India also has surplus rice stocks. It illustrates that producing plenty of one crop does not necessarily meet demand for another, or prompt farmers to switch what they grow.
Gulati raised the contrast at the Kisan Tak Bharat Agriculture Conference. He said India is the world’s largest rice producer and exporter, yet continues to import pulses. His explanation focused on incentives: agricultural policies favour rice and sugarcane, and a large share of fertiliser subsidies goes to those crops. Pulses require less fertiliser support.
Gulati suggested paying farmers Rs 35,000 per hectare to grow pulses. He said the incentive could reduce power and fertiliser subsidy spending and help India become self-reliant in pulses within three years. The import figure is the current scale he highlighted; the article does not report a later change in imports.
What policies and subsidies make rice and sugarcane more attractive to farmers than pulses?
Farmers’ crop choices are shaped partly by the policy incentives behind each crop. Gulati argued that India’s agricultural policies favour rice and sugarcane, while a large share of fertiliser subsidies goes to these crops. This matters because farmers compare the likely returns and costs of familiar choices with the support available for alternatives.
Pulses offer a contrast: Gulati described them as nitrogen-fixing crops that require less fertiliser support. Yet India imports five to six million tonnes of pulses a year despite surplus rice stocks. Gulati proposed an incentive of Rs 35,000 per hectare for pulse growers, linking the proposal to savings in power and fertiliser subsidies.
The article does not provide subsidy amounts for rice or sugarcane, or a breakdown between them. It also does not say that farmers receive a particular payment for either crop. Its central point is that the existing incentive structure can tilt choices; changing support could help make pulses more attractive and improve self-reliance.
How might paying farmers to grow pulses affect imports and spending on fertiliser and power subsidies?
Gulati’s proposal links a direct incentive for pulse growers with two possible gains: fewer pulse imports and lower spending on power and fertiliser subsidies. It matters because India imports pulses despite surplus rice stocks, while existing policies favour rice and sugarcane. Farmers need a practical economic reason to shift crops.
He suggested paying farmers Rs 35,000 per hectare to grow pulses. Gulati said pulses need less fertiliser support because they fix nitrogen. He argued that encouraging their cultivation could save on power and fertiliser subsidies and help the country become self-reliant in pulses within three years.
These are Gulati’s proposed effects, not reported outcomes. The article gives no later figures showing that the payment was adopted or that imports or subsidy costs fell. Its broader implication is that policy incentives can influence crop choices: if support makes pulses worthwhile, production could rise and reliance on imported pulses could decline.
What are pulses, and what does it mean that they fix nitrogen?
Pulses are the edible seeds of legume crops, including lentils, chickpeas and beans. The article does not define the term or list examples, but it does identify pulses as nitrogen-fixing crops. That quality matters in Gulati’s argument because pulses require less fertiliser support than crops favoured by current policy.
In general, nitrogen fixation means converting nitrogen from the air into forms plants can use. Legume roots commonly work with soil bacteria to do this. The article does not explain the biological process; it uses the point to contrast pulses’ fertiliser needs with the support given to rice and sugarcane.
Gulati proposed an incentive of Rs 35,000 per hectare for farmers who grow pulses. He said this could save power and fertiliser subsidies and help India become self-reliant in pulses within three years. The proposal reflects the article’s wider point: crop choices depend on whether policy makes an alternative worthwhile for farmers.
Why might a farmer hesitate to switch from a familiar crop even when the country needs more pulses?
Switching crops is not just a matter of responding to what the country needs. Farmers make decisions within familiar practices and an economic system of incentives and returns. The article’s central point is that appeals to diversify may not be enough unless farmers have a clear reason to leave a known crop.
Modi said farmers often follow their neighbours, even matching how many bags of fertiliser they use. He argued they accept a new practice only after seeing its benefits with their own eyes. Gulati described a related economic barrier: policies favour rice and sugarcane, while a large share of fertiliser subsidies goes to those crops. Pulses, by comparison, need less fertiliser support.
The article presents both demonstration and policy change as parts of the challenge. Modi called on progressive farmers to help encourage natural farming. Gulati proposed Rs 35,000 per hectare for growing pulses. Together, their remarks suggest farmers need visible results and incentives that make a shift practical, not just advice to change.
How do prices, subsidies, and market risks shape which crops farmers grow?
Prices, subsidies and market risks shape whether a crop looks worth growing. Gulati argued that policies favour rice and sugarcane, with a large share of fertiliser subsidies going to them. Such support can make those crops more attractive than pulses, even when India imports pulses and has surplus rice. This matters because national production needs and individual farm incentives can point in different directions.
Market prices add another risk. Gulati said that when tomatoes are in surplus, prices crash. He also noted that vegetable growers often receive only a small share of what consumers pay, unlike dairy farmers who benefit from cooperatives such as Amul. These examples show that producing more does not guarantee farmers higher incomes.
Gulati proposed Rs 35,000 per hectare for pulses, saying it could save power and fertiliser subsidies and support self-reliance. The article does not quantify crop-specific market risks or promise that this payment would improve earnings. It argues that policy and value chains both matter when farmers choose what to grow.
This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.
Read more in the JupiteX app
Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.
Or read more news on the web