JupiteX Get the app
Politics & Governance17 Nov 2026 · about 7 min

‘Can’t appeal, can’t vote’: The forgotten voters of Bengal SIR

The brief

“Under adjudication” means a voter’s case remains unresolved: a judicial officer has not completed its disposal. The article describes cases where a decision and e-signing are still pending. It is not the same as a completed finding that the person is ineligible, but affected voters say they cannot vote while the status remains unresolved. Md Salauddin Sheikh and his family last had a hearing on January 30 at the Dhulian Municipality office. He says he submitted documents, including school papers, but nothing happened afterward. In another case, BLO Abul Kalam Azad says his wife and seven other relatives attended a hearing, yet their names remain under adjudication. The Additional CEO asked district election officers to reactivate judicial officers’ login IDs to dispose of pending cases and report progress by November 3. A senior CEO office official said only judicial officers could act under court orders. The unresolved status therefore leaves people waiting without a clear decision or route to appeal.

01

What does it mean for a voter’s name to be “under adjudication” in West Bengal’s SIR?

“Under adjudication” means a voter’s case remains unresolved: a judicial officer has not completed its disposal. The article describes cases where a decision and e-signing are still pending. It is not the same as a completed finding that the person is ineligible, but affected voters say they cannot vote while the status remains unresolved.

Md Salauddin Sheikh and his family last had a hearing on January 30 at the Dhulian Municipality office. He says he submitted documents, including school papers, but nothing happened afterward. In another case, BLO Abul Kalam Azad says his wife and seven other relatives attended a hearing, yet their names remain under adjudication.

The Additional CEO asked district election officers to reactivate judicial officers’ login IDs to dispose of pending cases and report progress by November 3. A senior CEO office official said only judicial officers could act under court orders. The unresolved status therefore leaves people waiting without a clear decision or route to appeal.

02

Why can voters whose cases are still under adjudication neither vote nor appeal to the tribunals?

The article draws a distinction between a pending case and a deletion. Voters marked “under adjudication” say they cannot vote, but they also cannot appeal to the tribunals because their cases have not reached that stage. Those tribunals are hearing cases involving voters marked for “logical discrepancies.”

Md Salauddin Sheikh explains the gap directly: if his name had been deleted, he says, he would have appealed to a tribunal. Instead, he says, he is left in limbo. A senior official in the CEO’s office says these pending cases were not properly disposed of by judicial officers and that court orders prevent election officials from taking action themselves.

The Additional CEO also said only the court could decide what to do with the cases. The article reports an October 29 letter seeking reactivation of judicial officers’ login IDs to complete pending decisions, with a progress report due November 3. Until a decision is completed, affected voters describe having no appeal route and no vote.

03

How many voters are caught in this unresolved status, and how large a share of some local voter rolls do they represent?

Sources put the number of voters under adjudication at over 25,000. They are spread across the minority-dominated constituencies of Murshidabad, Malda, Nadia and Howrah. Poll officials acknowledged that they were not sure of the exact total, so the figure is an estimate rather than a confirmed count.

The share is striking in the local examples. At Booth No. 44 in Samserganj, 590 of 949 voters—62%—were still under adjudication after names marked dead or displaced were removed. In Farakka, BLO Abul Kalam Azad said 799 of 1,372 voters, nearly 60%, remained in that status.

These examples show how a statewide administrative backlog can affect a large part of a local roll. The Additional CEO asked district election officers to report progress on pending cases by November 3. But a senior official said election authorities could not resolve them under court orders; only judicial officers could act. The article gives no final count or resolution.

04

How is being “under adjudication” different from having a name deleted from the voter roll?

The article describes two separate situations. Some names were deleted from the rolls, while other voters remain under adjudication because their cases have not been properly disposed of by judicial officers. The latter status is unresolved; it is not described as a final ruling on eligibility.

The distinction matters for what happens next. Md Salauddin Sheikh says that if he had been deleted, he could have appealed to a tribunal. Because his case remains under adjudication, he says he cannot appeal or vote. The tribunals are hearing cases involving voters marked for “logical discrepancies,” while the under-adjudication cases have not reached them.

The article does not explain every step in the deletion process or set out a complete appeal procedure. It does report that judicial officers must act on the pending cases under court orders, and election officials say they cannot decide them. The Additional CEO requested that judicial officers’ login IDs be reactivated so pending decisions could be completed.

05

What roles do judicial officers, the Election Commission, and appellate tribunals play in deciding whether someone can vote?

Judicial officers are responsible for completing decisions on the cases still under adjudication. A senior official in the West Bengal CEO’s office said those cases were not properly disposed of and that, under court orders, election officials could not take action in their place. The Additional CEO likewise said only the court could take a call on them.

The Election Commission’s role includes the SIR process and the tribunal system. The article says the CEO’s office informed both the Calcutta High Court and the ECI about the unresolved cases. It also says 17 tribunals are handling cases of voters marked for “logical discrepancies.” The article does not detail how each tribunal reaches its decision.

The distinction between these tracks is important: the under-adjudication cases have not reached tribunal stage, according to the report, while the tribunals continue hearing other cases. The CEO’s October 29 letter asked district officers to seek reactivation of judicial officers’ login IDs and report disposal progress by November 3. The report gives no final outcome.

06

How does a Special Intensive Revision check voter lists, and what steps can people take if their eligibility is questioned?

The article says the SIR process removed names marked Absent, Shifted, Deceased or Duplicate, then marked around 60 lakh voters who made it onto the rolls for “logical discrepancies.” It does not give a complete explanation of how SIR checks each record. In general, a Special Intensive Revision is a focused review of electoral rolls; that broader description is established background, not detail supplied in the article.

For people whose eligibility is questioned, the report gives examples of attending hearings and submitting documents. Salauddin says he provided school papers to a judicial officer. He says a deleted voter could appeal to a tribunal, but those whose cases remain under adjudication have not reached that stage.

The practical route depends on the case’s status. The article says judicial officers must complete pending decisions under court orders, and election officials cannot substitute for them. It does not provide a complete list of documents, deadlines or appeal instructions. People should therefore use official election channels for case-specific guidance rather than assume the same next step applies to every status.

07

Why does accurate voter registration matter in a representative democracy?

Accurate voter registration matters because it helps ensure that eligible people can take part in choosing representatives, while election rolls reflect who is entitled to vote. This is a general democratic principle; the article focuses on what happens when registration cases remain unresolved rather than explaining the principle itself.

In West Bengal, people marked under adjudication say they cannot vote while their cases await decisions. At Booth No. 44 in Samserganj, 590 of 949 voters were in that status. Salauddin says he submitted school papers at a hearing but has received no decision. The report also describes families with several members caught in the same uncertainty.

The article reports that more than 25,000 people may be affected, though officials do not know the exact total. A senior official said only judicial officers could act on the pending cases under court orders. The Additional CEO sought reactivation of judicial officers’ login IDs to move cases forward. Until decisions are completed, the report shows how unresolved registration can leave people without a vote or a clear appeal route.

This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.

Read more in the JupiteX app

Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.

Or read more news on the web