Cass report author tells BBC draft conversion practices bill is not workable
Baroness Cass said she does not support the current draft bill banning conversion practices. She told a parliamentary committee that banning the practices is desirable, but that there is not yet, in her view, a workable bill. Her central concern is that the wording could lead to serious unintended consequences for people it is not meant to target. Cass focused on how the bill defines harm and distress. She said a young person might feel upset after a suitable therapeutic conversation about sensitive issues. Under the draft wording, she worried, that reaction could lead to a complaint against a therapist, even if the interaction was appropriate. She also raised a family example: stopping a child’s money to prevent buying a breast binder or hormones might fall within the bill’s scope. Cass said polarisation around gender could encourage people to use the law in unintended ways. She had earlier praised the bill’s clearer definition, but said she had not read its details before giving that press-release quote. She still calls conversion practices abhorrent and wants protection without accidental entrapment. The government says it will consider the committee’s evidence; hearings continue.
What did Baroness Cass say about the current draft bill, and what was her main concern?
Baroness Cass said she does not support the current draft bill banning conversion practices. She told a parliamentary committee that banning the practices is desirable, but that there is not yet, in her view, a workable bill. Her central concern is that the wording could lead to serious unintended consequences for people it is not meant to target.
Cass focused on how the bill defines harm and distress. She said a young person might feel upset after a suitable therapeutic conversation about sensitive issues. Under the draft wording, she worried, that reaction could lead to a complaint against a therapist, even if the interaction was appropriate. She also raised a family example: stopping a child’s money to prevent buying a breast binder or hormones might fall within the bill’s scope.
Cass said polarisation around gender could encourage people to use the law in unintended ways. She had earlier praised the bill’s clearer definition, but said she had not read its details before giving that press-release quote. She still calls conversion practices abhorrent and wants protection without accidental entrapment. The government says it will consider the committee’s evidence; hearings continue.
What are conversion practices, and who are they intended to change or suppress?
Conversion practices are generally described as interventions, treatments or activities designed to change or suppress a person’s sexual orientation or gender identity. The aim, by that definition, is to alter or limit who someone is attracted to, or their gender identity. The article says such practices can be very distressing for the person at their centre.
The article gives no single method as a complete definition. It says these practices can happen in religious or family settings, and discusses proposed legislation intended to ban them. Cass raised a hypothetical family situation: a parent might stop a child’s money because they fear the child will buy a breast binder or hormones. She said that could potentially fall within the bill’s scope.
Campaigns to outlaw conversion practices have been running in the UK for a long time. Labour promised a bill in its 2024 manifesto, and the government says the draft would protect LGBT people in England and Wales. Cass says no LGBT person should be subjected to conversion practices. The bill is still under parliamentary committee scrutiny, where its definitions and possible effects are being examined.
What level of harm or distress does the draft bill say must be caused for an offence to apply?
The draft bill’s wording requires the victim to suffer either serious harm to their physical or mental health, or serious alarm or distress. For the latter, the distress must have a substantial adverse effect on the person’s usual day-to-day activities. These are the thresholds described in the article for an offence to apply.
Cass questioned how the wording might work in practice, especially in therapy. Sensitive conversations can leave a young person upset, angry or distressed, she said, even when the intervention was appropriate. Her concern is that this reaction could be judged as poor professional practice or lead to a complaint. She also warned that complaints could affect professionals even when they do not result in prosecution.
The draft bill is undergoing pre-legislative scrutiny, and committee hearings continue. Cass told the committee she was concerned that the wording left room for vexatious complaints. The government welcomed her comments and said it would take evidence from the committee seriously. The article does not report a final version of the bill or say whether the threshold will change.
Why does Cass think the wording could put therapists or parents at risk of complaints or prosecution?
Cass’s concern is that the draft bill’s harm and distress wording may be applied to situations that are not abusive conversion practices. She said therapeutic conversations about sensitive issues can be upsetting. A young person may leave feeling distressed or angry after an appropriate intervention, yet the interaction could still be viewed as poor professional practice. She worried this could expose therapists to complaints or prosecution.
For example, Cass said a parent who stopped a child’s money because they thought the child might buy a breast binder or hormones could potentially fall within the bill’s scope. She did not say that prosecution would automatically follow. Rather, she warned that the possibility of a complaint or investigation could itself affect families and professionals.
Cass said therapists at new NHS Gender Dysphoria Clinics were concerned about this chilling effect, even where complaints did not lead to prosecution. She also linked the risk to polarisation in debates about gender. The committee is examining the draft, and the government says it will take the evidence seriously as it works on the ban.
Who and which parts of the UK would the proposed ban cover?
The government has said the draft bill would protect LGBT people in England and Wales. The article describes the proposed ban as targeting conversion practices, which are generally defined as interventions, treatments or activities intended to change or suppress someone’s sexual orientation or gender identity. It does not state that the bill would cover other parts of the UK.
The government introduced the draft legislation for pre-legislative scrutiny. That process has brought the bill before a parliamentary committee, which is hearing evidence about its wording and possible effects. Cass has questioned whether the current draft is workable, while saying she supports action to end abusive conversion practices. Several LGBT charities and the British Association for Counselling and Psychotherapy support the bill.
The committee hearings are continuing, and the government says it will take the evidence seriously. It says it wants to get the ban right and end what it calls almost a decade of delay for LGBT+ people. The article does not give a final timetable for the bill becoming law or describe any settled changes to its scope.
What is pre-legislative scrutiny, and how can a parliamentary committee's review shape a draft bill?
Pre-legislative scrutiny is a parliamentary review of draft legislation before it becomes law. In general, a committee examines the proposed wording, hears evidence and considers how the bill might work in practice. This explanation uses established parliamentary practice; the article itself says the draft bill has been put forward for this scrutiny.
In this case, a parliamentary committee is scrutinising the Draft Conversion Practices Bill and hearing concerns, including Cass’s warning about therapists and families. Her example of a parent withholding money shows how committee evidence can test the consequences of particular wording. A review can identify unclear definitions or risks that may not be obvious from the bill’s aims alone.
A committee does not itself make a draft bill law. Its evidence and recommendations can inform the government’s decisions about whether to revise the draft before it proceeds. The government says it will take all evidence put forward by the committee seriously. The hearings are continuing, so the article reports scrutiny in progress, not a final outcome or any agreed amendment.
Why can laws against harmful practices be difficult to draft without also restricting legitimate therapy or family decisions?
A law against harmful practices needs to identify the conduct it is meant to stop. But everyday interactions can involve sensitive topics, disagreement or distress without being abusive. This creates a drafting challenge: wording must be clear enough to protect people from harmful attempts to change or suppress their identity, while avoiding unintended restrictions on appropriate care or family decisions.
Cass illustrated the difficulty with therapy. A young person might feel upset after a suitable conversation about gender, she said. She also suggested a parent withholding money to prevent a child buying a breast binder or hormones might fall within the draft bill’s scope. Those examples show why the wording’s reach matters, although the article does not say either situation would automatically be an offence.
Cass fears that possible complaints or prosecution could discourage professionals from working with young people experiencing gender distress. She wants a bill that protects those it is meant to protect without accidentally entrapping others. The committee continues to scrutinise the draft, and the government says it will consider the evidence before moving forward.
This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.
Read more in the JupiteX app
Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.
Or read more news on the web