Bilkis Bano moves out of Gujarat after bail to 2 convicts, says her uncle
Her uncle, Abdul Razaq Mansuri, said the family left Gujarat around November 2 or 3. Their departure followed a Supreme Court order granting bail to two men convicted in Bilkis Bano’s case. The timing matters because Bano said the ruling had brought back fear for her family. Mansuri told HT by phone that Bano had lived in the Kapdi Vistaar area of Devgadh Baria until about one-and-a-half years earlier, then moved elsewhere in Gujarat. He said she had now left the state, but declined to share details about where she planned to go or why the family chose its destination. The report does not give a new location or say how long the family intends to stay away. Bano separately said she was scared again after the ruling and would fight it. Her statement makes clear that the order affected her sense of safety, while her uncle’s account confirms the family’s move.
What did Bilkis Bano’s uncle say about when her family left Gujarat?
Her uncle, Abdul Razaq Mansuri, said the family left Gujarat around November 2 or 3. Their departure followed a Supreme Court order granting bail to two men convicted in Bilkis Bano’s case. The timing matters because Bano said the ruling had brought back fear for her family.
Mansuri told HT by phone that Bano had lived in the Kapdi Vistaar area of Devgadh Baria until about one-and-a-half years earlier, then moved elsewhere in Gujarat. He said she had now left the state, but declined to share details about where she planned to go or why the family chose its destination.
The report does not give a new location or say how long the family intends to stay away. Bano separately said she was scared again after the ruling and would fight it. Her statement makes clear that the order affected her sense of safety, while her uncle’s account confirms the family’s move.
How many of the 11 convicted men were granted bail, and how long had they been in prison?
Two of the 11 men convicted in the 2002 gang rape case were granted bail by the Supreme Court. The court suspended the life sentences of Bipinchand Kanaiyalal Joshi and Pradip Ramanlal Modhiya, citing their 17 years of incarceration. Bail did not mean that all 11 men were released.
The order came on October 28 from a bench of justices MM Sundresh and PB Varale. The Gujarat government opposed the two men’s release during the proceedings, but the court granted bail. The article identifies the length of time they had been incarcerated as the reason cited for suspending their sentences.
The order drew a strong response from Bilkis Bano, who said she had not been informed or heard and would fight it. The article does not describe any further legal steps after her statement. The immediate reality reported is that two men received bail, while the convictions of the 11 men were not described as overturned.
What does bail mean when a court suspends a prison sentence, and does it erase a conviction?
Bail is a court-authorized release from custody, often subject to conditions. When a court suspends a prison sentence, it temporarily pauses the sentence’s enforcement. These are separate from cancelling a conviction: bail or a sentence suspension does not, by itself, mean the person has been found innocent. This is the general meaning of the legal terms.
In this case, the Supreme Court suspended the life sentences of Bipinchand Kanaiyalal Joshi and Pradip Ramanlal Modhiya and granted them bail. The article says the court cited their 17 years of incarceration. It does not say that the court overturned their convictions or that the 11 men’s convictions were erased.
The distinction matters because the ruling changed the two men’s custody and sentence status, while Bano described the order as a painful setback and said she would fight it. The article reports no later decision changing the convictions. On the facts provided, the two men were granted bail after their sentences were suspended, not declared innocent.
What consequences did Bilkis Bano say the bail ruling had for her and her family?
Bilkis Bano said the Supreme Court’s bail order had brought back fears for her and her family. She described herself as “scared once again” and said she feared for herself, her family and her children. She also said she was afraid of losing faith in justice again. The ruling’s impact, in her words, was personal as well as legal.
Bano said she learned of the order through press reports and had not been called or heard in court. She asked why the sentences of the men who attacked her had been suspended without her being informed or given a voice. Her uncle also said the family left Gujarat around November 2 or 3, days after the order.
Bano said she would fight the ruling, explaining that she wanted to protect her children from living with these fears and scars. She also invoked the memory of her three-year-old daughter, Saleha, who was killed. The article gives no details of the next legal step, but records Bano’s stated determination to challenge the order.
What happened to Bilkis Bano and her family during the 2002 Gujarat riots?
During the Gujarat riots, Bilkis Bano and her family tried to flee to safety. On March 3, 2002, Bano, then 19 and five months pregnant, was gang-raped by the men later convicted in the case. The attack devastated her family: the 11 convicts also killed seven of her family members, including her three-year-old daughter.
The article describes the violence as the background to Bano’s long fight for justice. In her later statement, she recalled losing her baby daughter, family, home and trust in humanity. She said she had continued seeking justice for herself and women, and credited support from many people with helping her find courage.
The case remained consequential years later. The Supreme Court had granted bail to two of the 11 convicts, suspending their life sentences after they had spent 17 years incarcerated. Bano said the ruling revived her fears and that she would fight it. The article also reports that her family left Gujarat days after the order, according to her uncle.
Why did the Supreme Court say Gujarat could not decide whether to reduce the convicts’ sentences?
Remission is a decision to reduce a person’s sentence. In its 2024 ruling, the Supreme Court said Gujarat did not have the authority to decide whether to reduce the convicts’ sentences because the trial had moved to Mumbai. The court said that this made Maharashtra responsible for the decision. The issue was which state government had the authority to consider remission.
The ruling also addressed Gujarat’s earlier decision to release the 11 men serving life sentences. The Supreme Court quashed that decision in August 2022. It said an earlier order directing Gujarat to consider remission had been obtained fraudulently and through the suppression of material facts. These findings formed part of the court’s explanation for rejecting Gujarat’s role in the remission decision.
Later, the Supreme Court granted bail to two of the men and suspended their life sentences, citing their 17 years of incarceration. The Gujarat government opposed their release. Bano said she would fight the new order, but the article does not report what legal action followed or whether the remission ruling changed.
How does transferring a criminal trial to another state affect which government can consider remission?
Remission means reducing a sentence. The article describes the Supreme Court’s view that the state responsible for considering remission in this case depended on where the trial had moved. Since the Bilkis Bano trial was transferred to Mumbai, the court said Maharashtra, rather than Gujarat, was responsible for the remission decision.
The court applied that reasoning when it reviewed Gujarat’s decision to release the 11 men serving life sentences. In August 2022, the Supreme Court quashed that decision. It said Gujarat lacked authority because the trial had moved to Mumbai, and it also said an earlier order asking Gujarat to consider remission had been obtained fraudulently by suppressing material facts.
This explains why the transfer mattered: it shaped which government could consider reducing the sentences. The article also reports a later, separate order granting bail to two convicts and suspending their sentences after 17 years in prison. It does not say that this bail order changed the court’s finding about Maharashtra’s responsibility for remission.
This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.
Read more in the JupiteX app
Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.
Or read more news on the web