ECI Says It Has Objections To INDIA Bloc Plea In Supreme Court To Serve Interrogatories Over SIR Decisions
The INDIA Bloc leaders, including Leader of Opposition Rahul Gandhi, asked the Supreme Court for permission to serve 48 interrogatories on the Election Commission of India. They want information about how the Commission made and recorded decisions linked to the Special Intensive Revision, or SIR, and related electoral-roll matters. The answers could clarify what records exist and how decisions were reached. For example, the application asks whether the affidavit of Deputy Election Commissioner Bhanu Prakash Yeturu was approved by all three Election Commission members, and whether approval came at a meeting, through a circulated file or electronically. It also seeks information on objections, Form 6 applications and voter-roll exclusions. The ECI, represented by Senior Advocate Harish Salve, told the Court it had serious reservations and warned of “very serious prejudice.” The Court did not decide whether the leaders may serve the questions. The matter was posted to December 9, when the Court said it would hear the issue and then decide what to do.
What did the INDIA Bloc leaders ask the Supreme Court to allow them to do, and what objection did the ECI raise?
The INDIA Bloc leaders, including Leader of Opposition Rahul Gandhi, asked the Supreme Court for permission to serve 48 interrogatories on the Election Commission of India. They want information about how the Commission made and recorded decisions linked to the Special Intensive Revision, or SIR, and related electoral-roll matters. The answers could clarify what records exist and how decisions were reached.
For example, the application asks whether the affidavit of Deputy Election Commissioner Bhanu Prakash Yeturu was approved by all three Election Commission members, and whether approval came at a meeting, through a circulated file or electronically. It also seeks information on objections, Form 6 applications and voter-roll exclusions.
The ECI, represented by Senior Advocate Harish Salve, told the Court it had serious reservations and warned of “very serious prejudice.” The Court did not decide whether the leaders may serve the questions. The matter was posted to December 9, when the Court said it would hear the issue and then decide what to do.
What are interrogatories in a court case?
Interrogatories are written questions that one party in a legal case asks another party to answer. They are meant to obtain relevant information in a clear, organized form, rather than leave important factual issues vague. The article uses the term but does not define it or describe the rules that would govern these questions in this case.
In general, a party might ask who approved a decision, when approval was given and what records document it. Here, the INDIA Bloc leaders want to ask the Election Commission about its decisions and records. They have requested the Supreme Court’s permission to serve 48 questions; they have not yet been allowed to do so.
The Court has not decided whether the application should be granted or how the ECI would have to respond. Senior Advocate Harish Salve told the bench that the Commission had serious reservations and would face “very serious prejudice.” The Court said it would hear the issue and then take a call. The matter was posted to December 9.
How many interrogatories did the leaders seek to serve, and what main topics do they cover?
The INDIA Bloc leaders asked to serve 48 interrogatories on the Election Commission of India. The questions seek details about how decisions were approved, what records support them and whether any Commission member objected or expressed reservations. Such details matter because the ECI’s court filing described certain decisions as unanimous.
One example concerns Deputy Election Commissioner Bhanu Prakash Yeturu’s affidavit: the leaders ask whether the three Election Commission members approved it at a meeting, through file circulation or electronically. Other questions concern SIR orders, ECINET, appeals, the Form 6 declaration, applications left pending or rejected, and people absent from electoral rolls. They also seek information about Form 7 objections.
The application asks for dates, file numbers, records and state-wise or Union Territory-wise information in several areas. It seeks to establish whether decisions were unanimous or by majority and whether objections were recorded. These are requests for information, not findings by the Court. The ECI has raised serious reservations, and the Court has yet to decide whether the questions may be served.
What did the Supreme Court do at this hearing, and what remains undecided?
The Supreme Court did not resolve the interrogatories application at this hearing. The bench, comprising Chief Justice of India Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V Mohana, adjourned the matter to December 9 while hearing another part-heard matter. The delay leaves the proposed questions and the ECI’s objections before the Court.
Senior Advocate Kapil Sibal asked the bench to issue notice to the ECI on the application. Senior Advocate Harish Salve, appearing for the ECI, said the Commission had serious reservations and warned of “very serious prejudice.” The Chief Justice said the Court would hear the issue of interrogatories and then take a call.
So far, the Court has neither allowed nor rejected the request to serve 48 questions. It has also not directed the ECI to answer them. The next listed date is December 9; the article does not report what decision the Court will make then. The underlying questions concern ECI approvals, SIR decisions and electoral-roll matters.
What is a Special Intensive Revision (SIR), and how can it change electoral rolls?
SIR stands for Special Intensive Revision. In general usage, it is an intensive exercise to check and update electoral rolls, rather than simply make routine changes. The article discusses SIR decisions but does not explain the process or set out the rules for carrying it out. The basic purpose of an electoral-roll revision is to keep voter lists accurate.
A revision may identify people who should be added, entries that need correction, or names that may need removal—for example, because a person has died, moved or is ineligible. The article says the leaders seek state-wise and Union Territory-wise data about exclusions, with reasons such as death, shifting, absence, duplication or ineligibility. Those are questions in their application, not conclusions established by the Court.
The leaders also ask about the dates and records for three SIR orders, and about a statement that the Commission had decided to begin SIR “in the entire country.” The article reports an apparent conflict with an RTI appeal order, but does not resolve it. The Court has not ruled on these questions; the matter is posted to December 9.
How can Election Commission members record approval, disagreement, or reservations about a decision?
The article describes three possible ways members may have approved a decision: at a meeting, through circulation of a file, or by electronic communication. It does not set out a general rule for how Election Commission members must record every approval or disagreement. The leaders want the underlying records so they can test the ECI’s statement that decisions were unanimous.
For example, they ask whether the affidavit filed by Deputy Election Commissioner Bhanu Prakash Yeturu was approved by Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar and Election Commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi. They seek the approval dates, the method used and records showing whether anyone suggested changes or expressed reservations.
The application also asks how many times members recorded written objections, dissents or reservations about SIR decisions, ECINET, Form 6 and appeals between 19.02.2025 and 26.10.2026. These are requests for evidence, not proof that a disagreement occurred. The ECI has objected to the application, and the Court has not yet decided whether the questions can be served.
How are voter names added to or removed from electoral rolls, and what safeguards govern those changes?
Electoral rolls are official lists of voters. In general, eligible people can apply to be added, and objections or requests for deletion or correction can be considered through the prescribed process. In India, Electoral Registration Officers have a role in deciding changes. The article itself does not explain all application steps or safeguards, so those details are general context rather than reported findings.
The article mentions Form 6 applications, which the leaders ask about in connection with a declaration added to an online application page. They also seek information about Form 7 objections, including who filed them and what action was taken. The application asks whether any roll entry was added, deleted or modified without an order of an Electoral Registration Officer, including by bulk or system-level means.
As a general safeguard, electoral-roll changes are subject to official rules and procedures, which can include checking claims and objections and giving affected people a chance to respond. The article does not establish that any safeguard was breached. It reports that the leaders want records and data, while the ECI has objected to their proposed questions. The Court has yet to decide whether they may be served.
This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.
Read more in the JupiteX app
Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.
Or read more news on the web