Astronomers discover rare black holes that formed when stars failed to go supernova
A striking clue is that black holes near 10 times the Sun’s mass formed a clear peak in the data, while black holes between 12 and 16 solar masses were scarce. Researchers say this pattern may reveal a group born when massive stars collapsed without a supernova explosion. Katerina Chatziioannou’s team examined gravitational-wave observations of 257 black hole mergers detected by LIGO, Virgo and KAGRA over the past 10 years. About 75% of the sample was represented by the peak of 10-solar-mass black holes. The team also examined black hole spins, which can preserve clues about how the objects formed. The mass peak and a distinct range of spin speeds suggest these black holes may share an origin. The researchers say their results are consistent with many binary black holes forming through failed supernovas. However, failed supernovas have not been directly confirmed, and the team says more research is needed.
What did astronomers find that suggests some black holes formed when massive stars failed to explode?
A striking clue is that black holes near 10 times the Sun’s mass formed a clear peak in the data, while black holes between 12 and 16 solar masses were scarce. Researchers say this pattern may reveal a group born when massive stars collapsed without a supernova explosion.
Katerina Chatziioannou’s team examined gravitational-wave observations of 257 black hole mergers detected by LIGO, Virgo and KAGRA over the past 10 years. About 75% of the sample was represented by the peak of 10-solar-mass black holes. The team also examined black hole spins, which can preserve clues about how the objects formed.
The mass peak and a distinct range of spin speeds suggest these black holes may share an origin. The researchers say their results are consistent with many binary black holes forming through failed supernovas. However, failed supernovas have not been directly confirmed, and the team says more research is needed.
What is a failed supernova, and how can a star that does not explode still form a black hole?
A failed supernova is a proposed way for a massive star to die without the dramatic explosion usually associated with a collapsing star. Instead of its outer layers being blown outward, the star implodes. The collapsed core can become a black hole, even though the star never produces a supernova.
In the usual account, a massive star runs out of fuel for nuclear fusion and its core collapses. Shockwaves from that collapse strike the star’s outer layers and trigger a supernova. In the failed version, the star’s collapse does not lead to that explosion; it goes out with a whimper and forms a black hole directly.
Scientists have no hard evidence of failed supernovas yet, but their existence is well supported theoretically. The study found mass and spin patterns in merging black holes that are consistent with this route. The researchers stress that more work is needed before the idea is confirmed.
How many black hole mergers did the team analyze, and what share involved black holes near 10 times the Sun’s mass?
The team studied 257 black hole mergers detected by the LIGO–Virgo–KAGRA network over the past 10 years. These events were identified through gravitational waves, ripples in space from distant collisions. The researchers compared the masses of the black holes involved in the mergers.
They found a strong peak around 10 times the Sun’s mass. Black holes in this peak represented 75% of the entire sample. That concentration matters because it suggests that many of these black holes may have formed through a shared process, rather than through many unrelated routes.
The team also found fewer black holes with masses from 12 to 16 times the Sun’s mass than expected. The article does not give a separate percentage for black holes near 10 solar masses; it reports that the peak represented 75% of the sample. The mass pattern, along with spin results, supports a possible failed-supernova origin, but further research is needed.
What patterns in black holes’ masses and spins pointed to a shared way of forming?
The researchers found two patterns that may connect some merging black holes to the same kind of stellar death. Their mass analysis showed a peak around 10 solar masses and a lack of black holes between 12 and 16 solar masses. The team says this unusual distribution may point to a special process that makes many 10-solar-mass black holes.
The researchers also studied the black holes’ spin rates. Spin can provide a clue to how a black hole formed. The 10-solar-mass black holes appeared to occupy a distinct range of spin speeds, which adds another sign that they may share an origin.
Taken together, the mass and spin patterns are consistent with massive stars collapsing without exploding as supernovas. The researchers propose that these failed supernovas may produce many binary black holes. But the patterns are clues, not direct observations of stars failing to explode, so the interpretation still needs further research.
What could this finding change about scientists’ picture of how black holes are born?
The finding could broaden the standard account of how black holes are born. In that account, a massive star runs out of fuel, its core collapses, and a supernova explosion accompanies the formation of a black hole. The study suggests that some massive stars may instead collapse without exploding and still leave behind black holes.
The evidence comes from black hole masses and spins measured through gravitational-wave observations. The team found a peak around 10 solar masses, few black holes from 12 to 16 solar masses, and a distinct spin range for the 10-solar-mass group. These patterns suggest that some black holes in merging pairs may share a failed-supernova origin.
This is not yet a confirmed change to the picture: scientists have no hard evidence of failed supernovas. The researchers say the gravitational-wave data are consistent with many binary black holes forming this way, but more research is needed. Future analysis can test whether this proposed route explains the observed patterns.
What are gravitational waves, and how do merging black holes produce them?
Gravitational waves are ripples in space, as the article describes them. In established physics, they are disturbances in spacetime that travel outward from accelerating massive objects. They matter because detectors can use these passing ripples to study distant events that may otherwise be difficult to observe directly.
When two black holes orbit one another, their motion changes over time as they draw together. Their changing motion produces gravitational waves, which carry energy away. The black holes eventually merge, and the waves from the event travel across space. LIGO, Virgo and KAGRA are detectors that have registered these signals from black hole collisions.
The article reports more than 300 black hole collisions detected by the network since it first observed ripples from such distant events in 2015. The researchers analyzed 257 mergers to study black hole masses and spins. Those measurements offer clues to how the black holes formed, including whether some came from failed supernovas.
What happens inside a massive star when it runs out of fuel, and how can its collapsing core lead to a supernova or a black hole?
A massive star’s core is powered by nuclear fusion. When the star runs out of fuel for fusion, the core collapses. In the standard account described in the article, the star’s outer layers expand outward as this happens. The collapsing core and its aftermath can lead either to an explosion or, in some cases, a black hole.
In the usual sequence, shockwaves from the collapsing core strike the star’s outer layers and trigger a supernova. The collapsed core creates a black hole. The article’s proposed alternative is that some massive stars implode rather than explode. In that case, the star does not produce a supernova, but its core can still collapse directly into a black hole.
Scientists think many massive stars may follow this quieter route, but failed supernovas have not been directly confirmed. The gravitational-wave team found mass and spin patterns consistent with the idea that some black holes formed this way. Those results offer clues, while more research is needed to establish the process.
This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.
Read more in the JupiteX app
Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.
Or read more news on the web