Press Council guidelines say no UAPA for journalists in conflict zone, chief disagrees
The Press Council of India’s conflict-reporting guidelines urged governments not to use harsh laws against journalists for their reports. Instead, they recommended handling complaints through the council or under laws related to media. The distinction matters because reporting or disagreement with government decisions should not automatically be treated as treason or a threat to national security. For example, the guidelines said the PCI should be informed as soon as possible when a journalist is arrested. They named laws such as the National Security Act and the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act as laws that should not be used in place of a media-related process. The council’s recommendation was advisory, not a binding order. Justice Ranjana Prakash Desai dissented from the recommendation about referring complaints to the PCI. She said the council could not require state governments to send complaints to it or decide whether a complaint should be filed. The guidelines and her dissent were adopted on September 27, 2024, and included in the PCI’s 2026 norms.
What did the Press Council of India recommend governments do instead of using harsh laws against journalists for their reporting?
The Press Council of India’s conflict-reporting guidelines urged governments not to use harsh laws against journalists for their reports. Instead, they recommended handling complaints through the council or under laws related to media. The distinction matters because reporting or disagreement with government decisions should not automatically be treated as treason or a threat to national security.
For example, the guidelines said the PCI should be informed as soon as possible when a journalist is arrested. They named laws such as the National Security Act and the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act as laws that should not be used in place of a media-related process. The council’s recommendation was advisory, not a binding order.
Justice Ranjana Prakash Desai dissented from the recommendation about referring complaints to the PCI. She said the council could not require state governments to send complaints to it or decide whether a complaint should be filed. The guidelines and her dissent were adopted on September 27, 2024, and included in the PCI’s 2026 norms.
Why did chairperson Justice Ranjana Prakash Desai disagree with the recommendation about referring complaints to the Press Council?
Justice Ranjana Prakash Desai disagreed with the guideline asking governments to refer complaints about journalists to the Press Council of India. Her objection was about the council’s authority and the route for making a complaint. The council, she argued, could not direct state governments to send complaints to it.
Desai also said the PCI could not decide whether a particular complaint should be filed. In her view, the complainant had to approach the investigating agency directly. She did not reject the need for care when journalists are arrested: her dissent called for strong, compelling and prima facie unimpeachable grounds for such arrests. She also stressed that disagreement with government does not itself amount to treason or a threat to national security.
The guidelines and Desai’s dissent were adopted by the council on September 27, 2024, and included in the 2026 Norms of Journalistic Conduct. The PCI’s guidelines are advisory, and its reach extends only to print news publishers. The disagreement therefore records a different view within the council, rather than creating a binding complaint procedure.
How broad is the Press Council of India’s reach: does it regulate all news media or only print news publishers?
The Press Council of India’s reach is limited: the source describes its prerogative as extending only to print news publishers. It does not have authority over every form of news media. This matters when interpreting its conflict-zone guidelines, because their advice should not be mistaken for rules that bind every journalist or media organisation.
The article describes the guidelines as advisory in nature. They recommend that governments avoid harsh laws against journalists for their reporting and suggest media-related processes for complaints. But the PCI cannot make those recommendations binding across all media. Its chairperson, Justice Ranjana Prakash Desai, also objected that the council could not require state governments to refer complaints to it.
The guidelines and Desai’s dissent were adopted on September 27, 2024, and incorporated into the PCI’s 2026 Norms of Journalistic Conduct. The document was released on October 16. The article does not describe any expanded jurisdiction or new enforcement power; the stated limit remains print news publishers, with the guidelines serving as advice.
What is the UAPA, and how does it differ from ordinary laws used to handle disputes about news reporting?
UAPA stands for the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act. As general legal background, it is an Indian law concerning unlawful activities and terrorism. The article groups it with the National Security Act and sedition as harsh laws that should not be invoked against journalists simply for their reports. It does not set out the Act’s detailed provisions.
The contrast in the guidelines is between using such national-security or criminal laws and handling complaints through the PCI or laws related to media. The PCI advised governments to use those alternatives rather than book journalists under UAPA and similar laws for reporting. It also said disagreement with a government decision should not by itself be treated as treason or a national-security threat.
The recommendation is advisory, not a binding ban on using UAPA. Desai disagreed with requiring governments to bring complaints to the PCI, saying complainants should approach investigating agencies directly. She called instead for strong, compelling and prima facie unimpeachable grounds for arrests. The article does not detail how UAPA cases differ procedurally from media-related cases.
What practical consequences can a journalist face when authorities use a national-security law rather than a media-related process?
The practical concern is that a journalist could be treated as a national-security or criminal suspect rather than having a reporting-related complaint handled through a media process. The PCI’s guidelines named UAPA and the National Security Act among harsh laws and advised governments not to invoke them against journalists for their reports. The article does not describe any particular journalist’s case or outcome.
In general, use of a national-security law can expose someone to arrest, investigation and legal proceedings under that law. Those are possible consequences, not outcomes established for any case in this article. The PCI’s proposed alternative was to lodge complaints with it or take action under laws related to media. Its recommendation is advisory.
Desai objected to requiring governments to send complaints to the PCI. She said complaints should go directly to investigating agencies, while arrests should be made with due care and strong, compelling and prima facie unimpeachable grounds. She also said disagreement with government does not automatically amount to treason or a threat to national security. The article does not say what consequences follow in specific cases.
What limits on free speech does Article 19(2) of India’s Constitution allow, and why might they matter when officials seek a journalist’s source?
Article 19(2) of India’s Constitution allows reasonable restrictions on speech on specified grounds. As general legal background, these include the sovereignty and integrity of India, security of the state, friendly relations with foreign states, public order, decency or morality, contempt of court, defamation and incitement to an offence. The article does not list those grounds, but refers to the restrictions in Article 19(2).
The PCI guidelines opposed unnecessarily pressuring journalists to reveal their news sources and called for respect for the Supreme Court’s views. Desai found that recommendation too vague. Her alternative said journalists should not be unnecessarily compelled to disclose a source, but that cases attracting Article 19(2) restrictions may require different treatment and a source may have to be disclosed.
That distinction matters because the recommendation is not an absolute promise of confidentiality. It recognizes that source protection may be weighed differently in cases involving constitutional restrictions. The article does not specify which particular cases would require disclosure, or how officials should decide them. It records Desai’s suggested wording as a dissent, alongside the council’s adopted guidelines.
Why is protecting confidential news sources important to journalism, and how can it help the public learn about matters of concern?
Protecting confidential sources can help journalism bring information to light when people with relevant knowledge fear speaking openly. As general background, source protection can support reporting on matters of public concern by helping journalists hear from people who might otherwise stay silent. The article itself focuses on whether journalists should be pressured to identify those sources.
The PCI guidelines opposed unnecessarily pressuring journalists to reveal a news source and called for respect for the Supreme Court’s views. Desai said that recommendation was too vague. Her proposed wording said journalists should not be unnecessarily compelled to disclose sources, but that cases involving reasonable restrictions under Article 19(2) may call for different treatment.
Desai’s note said a source may have to be disclosed in such cases. The article does not describe a specific journalist, source or public-interest investigation, and it does not spell out a test for deciding when disclosure is required. The guidelines and dissent were adopted on September 27, 2024, and included in the PCI’s 2026 norms. The council’s guidelines remain advisory.
This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.
Read more in the JupiteX app
Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.
Or read more news on the web