Mandatory detention arrives at the Supreme Court – though not all at once
At issue is which detention statute governs noncitizens who entered without inspection and were later arrested inside the United States. In Rhoney v. Barbosa da Cunha, the Supreme Court agreed to answer that statutory question; a separate constitutional question is still awaiting the right case. The answer matters because the two statutes offer different paths to release. Under Section 1226(a), ICE may release a detainee on bond, subject to immigration-judge review, unless specified criminal- or terrorism-related rules apply. The administration instead uses Section 1225(b)(2)(A), which it says requires detention through removal proceedings and gives immigration judges no power to grant bond. The legal hinge is whether a long-term resident is not only deemed an “applicant for admission,” but also “seeking admission.” The Supreme Court’s statutory ruling will address this dispute over which law applies. It will not, by itself, resolve the separate constitutional question described in the article. Together, the statutory and constitutional answers will determine whether long-term residents can ask a judge for release while contesting deportation.
What question has the Supreme Court agreed to decide in Rhoney v. Barbosa da Cunha?
At issue is which detention statute governs noncitizens who entered without inspection and were later arrested inside the United States. In Rhoney v. Barbosa da Cunha, the Supreme Court agreed to answer that statutory question; a separate constitutional question is still awaiting the right case. The answer matters because the two statutes offer different paths to release.
Under Section 1226(a), ICE may release a detainee on bond, subject to immigration-judge review, unless specified criminal- or terrorism-related rules apply. The administration instead uses Section 1225(b)(2)(A), which it says requires detention through removal proceedings and gives immigration judges no power to grant bond. The legal hinge is whether a long-term resident is not only deemed an “applicant for admission,” but also “seeking admission.”
The Supreme Court’s statutory ruling will address this dispute over which law applies. It will not, by itself, resolve the separate constitutional question described in the article. Together, the statutory and constitutional answers will determine whether long-term residents can ask a judge for release while contesting deportation.
If the government’s interpretation wins, what could happen to long-term residents while they fight deportation?
If the government’s interpretation prevails, long-term residents arrested inside the country could be detained for the full length of their removal proceedings, without an immigration judge deciding whether bond could secure their release. That could affect people who have lived in the United States for years or even decades while they fight deportation.
The mechanism is Section 1225(b)(2)(A), which the government says covers people deemed applicants for admission. Unlike Section 1226(a), that provision does not let immigration judges grant them bond. Under the policy, a person’s only route out before proceedings end is discretionary, case-by-case parole, available only for urgent humanitarian reasons or significant public benefit.
This is the administration’s policy, adopted by ICE in July 2025 and accepted by the Board of Immigration Appeals two months later. The Supreme Court has agreed to decide the statutory dispute. Its ruling will help determine whether this no-bond approach can continue, though the article notes that a separate constitutional question remains unresolved.
How many federal appeals courts have ruled on this dispute, and how many side with each interpretation?
Eleven of the 12 federal courts of appeals have answered which detention law applies to people arrested inside the country after entering without inspection. Nine say Section 1226 governs; two agree with the government that Section 1225(b)(2)(A) applies. The remaining court, the D.C. Circuit, had not ruled when the article was written.
The nine-circuit majority includes the 1st, 2nd, 3rd, 4th, 6th, 7th, 9th, 10th and 11th Circuits. The 5th and 8th Circuits take the government’s position. The majority says “seeking admission” means seeking lawful entry, so a person who entered years earlier is not seeking entry now.
The split is one reason the Supreme Court has agreed to decide the statutory question. The justices’ ruling will resolve the disagreement over which statute covers these interior arrests. The article also describes a separate constitutional issue, but says it is still waiting for the right case.
What is an immigration bond hearing, and how can it allow someone to leave detention?
An immigration bond hearing is a chance for a detained noncitizen to ask an immigration judge to allow release on bond while removal proceedings continue. In the article, the key point is that Section 1226(a) allows ICE to release a detainee on bond, subject to an immigration judge’s review. This gives the person a possible route out of detention before the case ends.
For example, a person arrested in the interior after entering without inspection may be held under Section 1226(a), unless Section 1226(c)’s criminal- or terrorism-related provisions apply. Under that framework, bond is possible and a judge can review it. Under Section 1225(b)(2)(A), as the government interprets it, immigration judges have no power to grant bond.
The dispute over which section applies therefore determines whether a bond hearing can help someone leave detention. Under the July 2025 policy, ICE placed these long-term residents under Section 1225 instead. The Supreme Court has agreed to decide the statutory issue, which will affect whether the bond route remains available to them.
Why does the dispute turn on whether someone deemed an “applicant for admission” is also “seeking admission”?
Section 1225(a)(1) deems a noncitizen who is present in the United States but has not been admitted to be an “applicant for admission.” The detention rule in Section 1225(b)(2)(A), however, refers to an applicant who is also “seeking admission.” The courts disagree about whether the legal label automatically satisfies that second condition.
The distinction matters for someone who entered without inspection years ago and was later arrested inside the country. Most appeals courts say “seeking admission” means seeking lawful entry, and that a person who already entered is no longer seeking entry. The 5th and 8th Circuits read the words differently: the 5th Circuit reasoned that someone who applies for something is seeking it.
If the person falls under Section 1225(b)(2)(A), the government says detention is required and a judge cannot grant bond. If Section 1226(a) applies, bond may be available subject to judicial review. The Supreme Court has agreed to settle this statutory disagreement.
How did the detention policy change in July 2025 compared with the way administrations had applied the law before?
Before July 2025, every administration had detained noncitizens who entered without inspection and were later arrested in the interior under Section 1226(a). That law lets ICE release a detainee on bond, subject to review by an immigration judge, except when Section 1226(c)’s criminal- or terrorism-related provisions apply.
In July 2025, ICE began requiring that anyone who entered without inspection, whether recently or decades earlier, instead be detained under Section 1225(b)(2)(A) throughout removal proceedings. Under that section, immigration judges have no power to grant bond. The Board of Immigration Appeals agreed with ICE in Matter of Yajure Hurtado two months later.
The change prompted a dispute over whether the statute supports the new approach. Eleven federal appeals courts have ruled, with nine favoring Section 1226 and two agreeing with the government. The Supreme Court has taken up the statutory question, while a separate constitutional question remains awaiting the right case.
What is the difference between a right created by a statute and a right protected by the Constitution?
In general, a statutory right or rule comes from legislation enacted by Congress. A constitutional right or limit comes from the Constitution, which governs what the government may do. The article does not define those terms, but it distinguishes the two kinds of questions in this detention dispute.
The statutory question is about how Congress’s detention laws apply. Section 1226(a) allows bond release subject to immigration-judge review, while Section 1225(b)(2)(A), under the government’s reading, requires detention without bond. The Supreme Court has agreed to decide which law governs long-term residents arrested in the interior after entering without inspection.
A separate constitutional question about detention is still waiting for the right case to reach the court. The article does not specify what constitutional rule would apply or predict how that issue will be resolved. It says the statutory and constitutional answers together will determine whether long-term residents can ask a judge to release them while they fight deportation.
This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.
Read more in the JupiteX app
Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.
Or read more news on the web