JupiteX Get the app
Environment & Climate18 Nov 2026 · about 7 min

COP31: How to make carbon markets more effective

The brief

Carbon markets let countries or companies that emit greenhouse gases buy credits that help pay for projects reducing emissions elsewhere. A credit is tied to a stated amount of carbon dioxide reduced or stored. Farm and forest projects may plant or protect trees or change farming practices. Each credit represents one ton of carbon dioxide cut or stored; buyers pay for credits, sending project finance toward those activities. The idea matters because it links demand for credits with funding for climate work, including in developing countries. But the link works only if projects deliver real results and measuring them does not consume too much money. The article notes concerns about whether projects truly caused cuts, costly monitoring, and small returns for farmers. In 2024, buyers used about 70 million farm and forest credits, less than 1% of their potential annual contribution. More finance alone is not enough: credits need credible measurement, and projects must let farmers benefit.

01

What is a carbon market, and how does a carbon credit help pay for a project?

Carbon markets let countries or companies that emit greenhouse gases buy credits that help pay for projects reducing emissions elsewhere. A credit is tied to a stated amount of carbon dioxide reduced or stored.

Farm and forest projects may plant or protect trees or change farming practices. Each credit represents one ton of carbon dioxide cut or stored; buyers pay for credits, sending project finance toward those activities. The idea matters because it links demand for credits with funding for climate work, including in developing countries.

But the link works only if projects deliver real results and measuring them does not consume too much money. The article notes concerns about whether projects truly caused cuts, costly monitoring, and small returns for farmers. In 2024, buyers used about 70 million farm and forest credits, less than 1% of their potential annual contribution. More finance alone is not enough: credits need credible measurement, and projects must let farmers benefit.

02

How much adaptation funding do developing countries need each year, and how much international support did they receive in 2024?

Developing countries need about US$305 billion each year to adapt to climate change, around ten times the US$28 billion in international support they received in 2024.

Adaptation means preparing for harms such as droughts, floods, rising seas, and wildfires as warming continues. The gap matters because countries have little choice but to adapt, while farms and forests are central places for many of the needed changes. Some adaptation practices, such as improving soils and planting trees, resemble activities carbon markets already support.

At COP31 in Antalya, countries are discussing ways to raise more money. They called for efforts to at least triple adaptation finance by 2035 and agreed on 59 indicators to track progress, 11 connected to food production and ecosystems. Turkey's environment minister says carbon markets could provide more than US$50 billion a year in extra finance by 2030, though barriers remain.

03

What changes could make carbon projects cheaper to run and help more money reach farmers?

Carbon projects can lose money before they earn anything. They must find buyers, negotiate contracts, receive government approval, and hire independent auditors. Those costs can shrink the funds available to farmers, making projects harder for smallholders to join and benefit from.

The article recommends keeping measurement simple and local. In field experiments in Vietnam, villagers rarely cheated when monitoring their own work, suggesting communities can help check results. Simpler local monitoring could reduce reliance on costly measurement, while making sure funds reach farmers addresses who benefits from project finance.

The article also says governments and international organizations can help lower implementation costs, although the source text ends before explaining how. These changes matter because measuring carbon in soils and trees is expensive, and the article describes only slight household income gains from a community project in Mozambique. Lower costs and better access to funds could help projects include more farmers, but they do not remove the need to show genuine climate benefits.

04

What happens to trust in carbon credits when a project cannot show that it caused real emissions cuts?

A carbon credit is meant to represent emissions reduced or carbon stored because of a project. To support that claim, project managers must show the project made a real difference, rather than crediting something that would have happened anyway.

For example, a project might protect a forest, but the key question is whether the forest would have been conserved without the project. The article reports that a large study found fewer than one in six credits reflected genuine emission cuts. If cause and effect cannot be demonstrated, buyers and others cannot rely on the credit as evidence of a real reduction.

That weakens the credibility of the market's central promise: that buying a credit supports climate action. The article identifies proving impact as a recurring barrier to growth. Better evidence could make credits more dependable, but measuring results can be costly, and carbon projects must balance credible checks with returns for farmers and communities.

05

Why can high project costs and insecure land rights make it harder for small farmers to benefit?

Small farmers may have difficulty benefiting from carbon projects when joining and measuring them costs too much. The article notes that low carbon prices and the high cost of signing up many small farms can make it hard for smallholders to gain. Costs for measuring carbon in soils and trees also reduce the money left for farmers.

Land rights create another barrier. In Africa, the researchers found as early as 2008 that insecure land rights discouraged new investment. Farmers without formal titles were also among those the author and colleagues warned could be left out of projects. If land claims are uncertain, it may be harder to arrange contracts or ensure who can benefit.

These barriers can reinforce one another: costly projects may favor places that are easiest to run, while farmers with insecure rights may be overlooked. The article says more than three-quarters of projects under the U.N.'s original carbon credit scheme were in China, India, and Brazil. It argues that funds must reach farmers and implementation costs must fall.

06

Why is it harder to measure success in adapting to climate change than to count tons of carbon reduced or stored?

Carbon projects measure success in a common unit: tons of carbon dioxide cut or stored. That amount can be turned into credits and sold. Adaptation is different because it aims to limit harm from climate impacts, and success can take many forms rather than one shared measure.

For example, a flood-adaptation project might succeed by reducing damage, while a farming effort might help harvests survive drought. These outcomes are not the same thing, and they may take years to become clear. The article says benefits can be hard to measure, making it difficult to compare projects or track progress in one consistent way.

This matters as developing countries need about US$305 billion a year to adapt and countries have agreed on 59 indicators to track progress. Eleven indicators relate to food production and ecosystems. The article says adaptation projects will face the measurement and implementation barriers found in carbon projects, plus the challenge of lacking a single common measure.

07

What is carbon sequestration, and how can trees and soils store carbon dioxide?

Carbon sequestration is the capture and storage of carbon dioxide, rather than its release into the atmosphere. The article describes carbon projects as measuring carbon dioxide cut or stored, including in trees and soils. The term's basic meaning is standard scientific usage; the article does not explain the biological processes in detail.

In general, trees take in carbon dioxide as they grow and store carbon in their wood, roots, and leaves. Some carbon from dead plant material can also become part of soil organic matter. Planting or protecting trees and improving soils can therefore help store carbon, though the amount depends on the project and its conditions.

The article says these practices appear in both carbon-market projects and adaptation efforts. But storing carbon is not enough to prove that a project caused a real change. Measuring carbon in trees and soils is costly, and projects must show that the storage would not have happened anyway. Those hurdles can reduce the money farmers receive and make credits harder to verify.

This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.

Read more in the JupiteX app

Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.

Or read more news on the web