‘They want silence’: how the film NAZA is shaking Israel
NAZA is a documentary produced by the Guardian, featuring anonymous interviews with 24 Israeli army intelligence officers. The officers discuss the killing of Palestinian civilians in Gaza and secret military approval systems. Its significance lies in presenting accounts from people who say they were tasked with carrying out military commands, rather than relying only on outside observers. The interviews were filmed on rooftops across Tel Aviv. A central subject is “nezek agavi,” the expected number of civilians who may be killed in a military attack. The film describes this as part of a secret signoff system in which human life is approved as collateral damage. It builds on reporting published from 2023 to 2025 by +972, Local Call and the Guardian. The film has not been screened in Israel, despite offers to distributors and cinemas, and has faced a severe backlash. More than 1.5 million people have seen it in cinemas, and it will stream free on the Guardian’s website in early December. Its Israeli directors have received prestigious awards.
What is NAZA, and what do the former Israeli intelligence officers describe in it?
NAZA is a documentary produced by the Guardian, featuring anonymous interviews with 24 Israeli army intelligence officers. The officers discuss the killing of Palestinian civilians in Gaza and secret military approval systems. Its significance lies in presenting accounts from people who say they were tasked with carrying out military commands, rather than relying only on outside observers.
The interviews were filmed on rooftops across Tel Aviv. A central subject is “nezek agavi,” the expected number of civilians who may be killed in a military attack. The film describes this as part of a secret signoff system in which human life is approved as collateral damage. It builds on reporting published from 2023 to 2025 by +972, Local Call and the Guardian.
The film has not been screened in Israel, despite offers to distributors and cinemas, and has faced a severe backlash. More than 1.5 million people have seen it in cinemas, and it will stream free on the Guardian’s website in early December. Its Israeli directors have received prestigious awards.
How many officers are interviewed in the film, and how many people have seen it?
NAZA interviews 24 former or serving Israeli army intelligence officers anonymously. They discuss the killing of Palestinian civilians in Gaza and the military systems used to approve attacks. Their accounts matter because they come from officers the film describes as tasked with implementing commands, offering first-hand testimony rather than only reporting the consequences of attacks.
The film-makers interviewed the officers on rooftops across Tel Aviv. The accounts address “nezek agavi,” the expected number of civilians killed in an attack, and a secret signoff system. The film develops revelations first published by +972, Local Call and the Guardian between 2023 and 2025. The article does not give a separate count of how many officers were former versus serving.
More than 1.5 million people have seen NAZA in cinemas. It premiered at the Venice film festival, where it received a 25-minute standing ovation, and has won prestigious awards. Yet it has not been screened in Israel, despite offers to distributors and cinemas. The Guardian plans to stream it free on its website in early December.
Why has the film sparked discussion in Israel even though it has not been screened there?
NAZA sparked discussion in Israel even though it had not been screened there. Nadav Weiman noticed its reach around Yom Kippur: during the holiday, people he met in his Tel Aviv neighbourhood were talking about the film. He says the reaction was almost universally hostile, including among liberal acquaintances, but the fact that people were discussing it mattered.
The film is in Hebrew, was made by Israelis, and presents testimony from Israeli intelligence officers. Weiman says many Israelis do not consume international media in English. The officers served in prestigious, mostly desk-based units and live in Tel Aviv, making their accounts particularly striking to some viewers. The film describes military systems that approve expected civilian deaths.
The discussion unfolded amid national election campaigns and a severe backlash. Weiman says attacks on directors Yuval Abraham and Rachel Szor can reinforce a right-wing “everyone-is-out-to-get-us” narrative. NAZA had premiered at Venice and reached audiences abroad, but it had not been screened in Israel. The Guardian planned a free online stream in early December, potentially extending the debate.
What consequences have the filmmakers faced, and how have Israeli officials responded to the film?
The article describes a severe backlash around NAZA, but does not specify particular legal, professional or personal penalties faced by directors Yuval Abraham and Rachel Szor. It does report that they have won prestigious awards. The film has been offered to Israeli distributors and cinemas but has not screened in Israel.
Nadav Weiman says right-wing figures find it politically useful to attack the directors. In his view, those attacks feed an “everyone-is-out-to-get-us” narrative. During Yom Kippur, people in his neighbourhood were talking about the film, although he says almost all the reactions he heard were hardline or hostile. These are Weiman’s observations, not a list of official actions.
The article does not describe any response by Israeli government officials to the film. It also does not report an official ban or explain why Israeli cinemas have not shown it. It says the film has faced a severe backlash, and that it will be available free on the Guardian’s website in early December. Beyond those details, the article provides no further account of official responses or consequences for the film-makers.
What does “nezek agavi” mean, and how does the film say expected civilian deaths are approved in military attacks?
“Nezek agavi” is the film’s namesake acronym for the number of civilians expected to be killed in a military attack. NAZA presents the concept as part of a secret approval system used by Israel’s military. It matters because it describes civilian deaths being considered in advance, rather than only counted after an attack.
The documentary features anonymous testimony from 24 intelligence officers who discuss systems for approving military actions. It describes a secret signoff process in which expected civilian deaths are approved as collateral damage. The film connects this material to reporting published by +972, Local Call and the Guardian between 2023 and 2025. The article does not spell out the exact approval chain, thresholds or decision-makers.
Weiman says the film details systems that have left tens of thousands of civilians dead and millions homeless, displaced or injured in Gaza. The film has not been screened in Israel, despite offers to distributors and cinemas, but it has reached more than 1.5 million cinema viewers elsewhere. Its planned free Guardian website stream in early December may bring the testimony to a wider audience.
How can limited Israeli media coverage and access to Gaza affect what the Israeli public knows about the war?
Nadav Weiman says Israeli media have largely ignored testimony from soldiers and failed, or refused, to cover events inside Gaza. He describes an “iron wall” between Gaza and the rest of Israel. This matters because limited access to reporting and first-hand accounts can shape what the public hears about civilian harm and military conduct.
Weiman says Israeli television features IDF spokespeople and military correspondents who act as “mini IDF spokespeople.” He also says mainstream audiences do not hear complex views or information about collateral damage. Breaking the Silence has gathered more than 1,000 testimonies, and hundreds of soldiers have come forward in the last three years, but Israeli publications and TV channels mostly declined to platform or report them.
Weiman argues that this leaves Israelis less informed about Gaza than some people abroad; he says a teenager in Manchester knows more than an Israeli watching TV news all day. That comparison is his assessment. The article also notes that NAZA’s Hebrew-language, Israeli-made testimonies prompted discussion despite hostile reactions. Wider access could expose more Israelis to soldiers’ accounts, though the article does not establish how public opinion will change.
What rules of war are meant to limit civilian harm, and what do distinction and proportionality require?
The article does not explain the rules of war or assess whether any attack described in NAZA complied with them. As general background, international humanitarian law requires parties to distinguish civilians and civilian objects from combatants and military objectives. That principle means attacks must not deliberately target civilians or civilian objects.
Proportionality is a separate rule: an attack is prohibited if the expected incidental civilian harm would be excessive in relation to the concrete and direct military advantage anticipated. The rules also require feasible precautions to reduce civilian harm. These are general legal principles, not details supplied by the article, and applying them to a particular attack depends on its circumstances.
NAZA, as described in the article, focuses on “nezek agavi,” the expected number of civilians killed in an attack, and a secret military signoff system. That description alone does not establish whether an attack was lawful. The article provides no attack-by-attack evidence, military advantage assessments or legal findings. It reports the film’s testimony and Weiman’s account of limited Israeli media coverage, not a legal ruling.
This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.
Read more in the JupiteX app
Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.
Or read more news on the web