JupiteX Get the app
Environment & Climate18 Nov 2026 · about 7 min

COP31: Six billion tonnes of emissions from burning wood may be missing from climate reports – Report

The brief

At least six billion tonnes of carbon dioxide from burning wood and other biomass for heat and power have been recorded as zero in countries’ energy accounts since 1990. The figure comes from an RSPB report released at the UN climate summit in Antalya. It matters because a zero in an energy account can leave a large source of emissions out of that sector’s reported total. Independent analyst Matt Williams examined countries’ greenhouse gas reports submitted to the UN climate body. Some countries missed reporting years, and some left parts of their reports blank. The RSPB says the six-billion-tonne estimate is therefore probably an underestimate, not a complete tally. The accounting gap follows guidance that assigns carbon from harvested wood to the forest sector where trees are cut. The country that burns the wood can then report zero in its energy sector. The RSPB wants the guidance changed so emissions are counted where biomass is burned. The issue is before ministers at the summit.

01

How much CO₂ from burning wood and other biomass has been recorded as zero in energy accounts, and since when?

At least six billion tonnes of carbon dioxide from burning wood and other biomass for heat and power have been recorded as zero in countries’ energy accounts since 1990. The figure comes from an RSPB report released at the UN climate summit in Antalya. It matters because a zero in an energy account can leave a large source of emissions out of that sector’s reported total.

Independent analyst Matt Williams examined countries’ greenhouse gas reports submitted to the UN climate body. Some countries missed reporting years, and some left parts of their reports blank. The RSPB says the six-billion-tonne estimate is therefore probably an underestimate, not a complete tally.

The accounting gap follows guidance that assigns carbon from harvested wood to the forest sector where trees are cut. The country that burns the wood can then report zero in its energy sector. The RSPB wants the guidance changed so emissions are counted where biomass is burned. The issue is before ministers at the summit.

02

How does that amount compare with the United States’ annual emissions?

The RSPB report puts the amount of carbon dioxide from burning wood and other biomass recorded as zero at at least six billion tonnes since 1990. The charity says that total is about equal to the annual emissions of the United States. This comparison helps show the size of the emissions involved, even though the figure covers many years of reporting rather than one year.

The estimate concerns biomass burned for heat and power. Under the accounting guidance described in the report, carbon from harvested wood is assigned to the forest sector of the country where trees are cut. The country that burns the wood records zero for those emissions in its energy sector, creating the reporting gap.

The comparison is approximate, and the RSPB warns that the total may be an underestimate because of missing data in country reports. It wants emissions counted where biomass is burned. That proposal is part of the debate at the UN climate summit, where ministers are due to adopt a decision on Friday, 20 November.

03

How do current reporting rules split the carbon from harvested wood between a country’s forest and energy accounts?

The reporting rules divide responsibility for carbon from harvested wood between two sectors. The forest sector is assigned the carbon in the country where the trees are cut. The energy sector in the country that burns the wood records those emissions as zero. The RSPB says this split can leave the burning country’s energy accounts without the emissions from its biomass use.

For example, wood can be cut in one country and burned in another. Under the guidance described in the report, the forest-sector accounting follows the country where the trees were felled, while the country using the wood for energy records zero in its energy sector. The burning country often has no information on whether the felled trees are replaced.

The guidance dates from the 1990s, when most biomass was burned in the country where it was grown. Wood pellets are now traded internationally, making that old approach less suited to the supply chain. The RSPB wants the panel to change its guidelines so emissions are counted where biomass is burned.

04

What is bioenergy, and what kinds of materials can be used to make it?

Bioenergy means energy made from organic material. The RSPB names trees, crops and food waste as examples of materials that can be used to make it. The report focuses on biomass burned for heat and power, and examines how the carbon dioxide from that burning appears in national energy accounts.

Wood is one example: it can be burned directly or traded as wood pellets for use elsewhere. Under the reporting guidance described in the report, carbon from harvested wood is assigned to the forest sector in the country where the trees are cut. The country burning that wood records zero emissions in its energy sector.

The issue matters more as wood pellets move through international trade, unlike the mostly domestic biomass use the guidance was designed around in the 1990s. The RSPB wants emissions counted where biomass is burned. The debate also reaches the summit’s draft decision, which includes both bioenergy and carbon-removal technologies; the charity wants bioenergy excluded from Turkey’s electrification target.

05

Why has international trade in wood pellets made reporting rules written in the 1990s harder to apply?

The reporting guidance dates from the 1990s, when most biomass was burned in the country where it was grown. That approach assigns harvested wood’s carbon to the forest sector where trees are cut, while the country burning the wood records zero in its energy sector. The old assumption becomes harder to apply when the fuel crosses borders.

Wood pellets are now traded internationally. If trees are cut in one country and pellets are burned for energy in another, the forest-sector accounting and the energy use occur in different places. The report says the country burning the wood often has no information on whether the felled trees are replaced, adding to the uncertainty about what the zero represents.

The RSPB wants the panel to change its guidelines so emissions are counted where biomass is burned. Williams also found gaps in countries’ reports, so the six-billion-tonne total is probably an underestimate. Five major economies spent nearly $250 billion subsidising bioenergy between 2002 and 2024, according to research cited by Williams.

06

How can counting wood burned in household stoves differently from wood burned in power stations affect carbon-credit claims?

The article describes different treatment for wood burned in household stoves and wood burned in power stations. Janaina Uemura of the Global Forest Coalition said household fuelwood in poorer countries is counted as emissions that can be turned into carbon credits. By contrast, wood burned in power stations in richer countries is counted as zero under the accounting rules described.

A carbon credit represents one tonne of emissions avoided, which a buyer can count against its own emissions. Nigeria authorised stove maker BURN to sell 5.2 million such credits internationally in March. A second approval, for close to four million credits, went to Uganda-based developer UpEnergy.

The contrast matters because the accounting can make household fuelwood part of a credit claim while biomass burned for power in richer countries is omitted from energy accounts. The article notes that 62 per cent of Nigerian households cook with wood, and that wood fuel is the country’s leading cause of forest degradation. It does not assess the validity of the approved credits.

07

What happens to the carbon stored in a tree when it is burned, and why does regrowth matter when judging whether bioenergy is low-carbon?

A tree stores carbon as it grows. When wood is burned, that carbon is released into the air, including as carbon dioxide; this is basic combustion science, not a mechanism detailed in the article. Whether new trees grow matters when judging the climate effect, because regrowth can take carbon back up over time. That possibility does not mean emissions from burning disappear immediately.

The article’s key accounting point is that harvested wood’s carbon is assigned to the forest sector of the country where trees are cut. The country that burns the wood records zero in its energy sector. It often has no information on whether the felled trees are replaced, leaving a gap in the information needed to assess regrowth.

The RSPB says the guidance dates from the 1990s and wants emissions counted where biomass is burned. The article gives no estimate of how quickly trees regrow or how much carbon they absorb. It does report that Nigeria burns about 34.7 million tonnes more wood each year than its forests can sustainably supply, underscoring why replacement matters.

This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.

Read more in the JupiteX app

Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.

Or read more news on the web