Global Biodiversity Framework at risk of becoming an empty promise
The Global Biodiversity Framework is a landmark agreement reached in 2022 to confront global biodiversity loss. It sets an international direction for action on nature, including ambitions to protect it. The agreement matters because biodiversity loss is a global problem, and countries need ways to judge whether their efforts are producing real change. The key distinction is between making a promise and achieving recovery. Carolyn Hogg and colleagues argue that reliable, independently tested measures are needed to determine whether nature is genuinely recovering. Without them, progress toward the framework’s ambitions cannot be assessed consistently, and targets may remain statements on paper rather than evidence of change. The authors recommend State of Nature metrics developed by the Nature Positive Initiative as a shared way to track change. They also say these measures should be tested across different settings and used beyond business and finance. Their concern is that, without consistent evidence, the framework’s important goals could go unrealized while biodiversity continues to decline.
What is the Global Biodiversity Framework, and what is it meant to address?
The Global Biodiversity Framework is a landmark agreement reached in 2022 to confront global biodiversity loss. It sets an international direction for action on nature, including ambitions to protect it. The agreement matters because biodiversity loss is a global problem, and countries need ways to judge whether their efforts are producing real change.
The key distinction is between making a promise and achieving recovery. Carolyn Hogg and colleagues argue that reliable, independently tested measures are needed to determine whether nature is genuinely recovering. Without them, progress toward the framework’s ambitions cannot be assessed consistently, and targets may remain statements on paper rather than evidence of change.
The authors recommend State of Nature metrics developed by the Nature Positive Initiative as a shared way to track change. They also say these measures should be tested across different settings and used beyond business and finance. Their concern is that, without consistent evidence, the framework’s important goals could go unrealized while biodiversity continues to decline.
What are the State of Nature metrics, and what changes in nature are they designed to track?
The State of Nature metrics are a globally consistent, minimal framework for tracking changes in nature. Developed by the Nature Positive Initiative, they are intended to provide a simple common language that can be used across countries and sectors. Consistency matters because governments, businesses and investors need to compare progress and assess whether nature is genuinely recovering.
The article describes the metrics broadly: they are designed to track changes in nature, rather than naming a particular species count or indicator. The authors recommend using them as a common basis for assessment. They also stress that the metrics need empirical testing, so their usefulness can be examined in real settings and across varied contexts.
In May 2025, the authors launched the Universitas 21 Nature Positive Coalition with the Nature Positive Initiative to address challenges around the metrics. The coalition is working toward a “matrix beyond the metrics,” a dashboard that adds financial, legal, social and ecological factors. The authors say measures should apply across different landscapes, seascapes, biomes and socioeconomic and governance contexts.
How many pilot sites are being used now, and how many does the coalition hope to cover?
The coalition is currently using two pilot project sites: one in Scotland and the other in New Zealand. These pilots let the researchers begin asking the questions raised in their Comment about the State of Nature metrics. Testing in actual locations matters because the authors want to understand how measures work in different settings, rather than rely only on agreement in principle.
The planned expansion is to 10 global locations. The coalition is seeking funding to make that possible. The proposed sites would span different bioregions and financial and legal systems, which would allow the team to examine the metrics across more than one kind of context.
The article does not say that the expansion is already funded or underway. It describes two current pilots and a goal of reaching 10 locations. The broader aim is to test and refine an approach that can work across diverse landscapes, seascapes, biomes, and socioeconomic and governance contexts. That range matters because the authors argue the metrics should be used well beyond finance and business.
Who needs reliable measures of nature’s recovery, and how could investors use them?
The authors say governments, businesses and investors need reliable measures to determine whether nature is genuinely recovering. The measures should also be independently tested. This matters because agreeing to protect nature is not the same as delivering that protection; decision-makers need credible evidence of progress, not just stated ambitions.
Investors could use the proposed “matrix beyond the metrics,” a dashboard that accounts for financial, legal, social and ecological factors. The article presents this as a way to help ensure the measures work for investors as well as ecosystems, nature stewards and decision-makers. The dashboard would go beyond a single nature metric by bringing several relevant factors together.
The coalition is developing this work alongside the Nature Positive Initiative and has begun testing questions at pilot sites in Scotland and New Zealand. The article does not describe a finished dashboard or a specific investment decision made with it. The authors’ goal is to build and test a useful tool, then apply the metrics across different contexts and beyond finance and business.
What can happen if governments and businesses make biodiversity commitments without consistent ways to measure progress?
The authors warn that biodiversity commitments can become empty promises if progress is not measured consistently. The Global Biodiversity Framework was agreed upon in 2022, but an agreement to protect nature does not itself show that nature is recovering. Credible measures matter because they let governments, businesses and investors assess whether actions are making a difference.
The mechanism is a lack of comparable, reliable evidence. If different actors cannot use consistent and independently tested ways to track change, they may struggle to determine whether progress is real. The authors say this can leave ambitious targets on paper, with no dependable basis for judging outcomes. Their proposed State of Nature metrics aim to supply a common framework for tracking changes.
The researchers argue that empirical testing is needed to address challenges with the metrics. The Universitas 21 Nature Positive Coalition has started examining these questions at pilot sites in Scotland and New Zealand. If the work develops, the authors hope the measures will be applied across more places and sectors. Their warning is that, without this kind of measurement, biodiversity may continue to decline despite stated commitments.
How could a shared dashboard account for differences in ecosystems, laws, finances, and local communities?
The authors propose a “matrix beyond the metrics”: a dashboard that accounts for financial, legal, social and ecological factors. The idea is to help ensure that the State of Nature metrics work for ecosystems, nature stewards, decision-makers and investors. This matters because a single shared measure may need to be understood and used by people working in very different circumstances.
The coalition has begun asking questions raised by the authors at pilot sites in Scotland and New Zealand. It is also seeking funding to expand the project to 10 global locations across different bioregions and financial and legal systems. Those examples show how the team plans to test the approach in varied settings, rather than assume one context is representative of all others.
The article does not describe a finished dashboard or specify exactly how each factor will be combined. It presents the matrix as a goal for the coalition’s work. The authors also argue that the metrics should be used beyond finance and business, across diverse landscapes, seascapes, biomes, and socioeconomic and governance contexts.
What is biodiversity, and why does measuring it involve more than counting species?
Biodiversity is commonly understood as the variety of life, including diversity within species, between species and among ecosystems. This is established scientific usage; the article itself does not give a formal definition. The topic matters here because the authors are concerned with global biodiversity loss and whether nature is genuinely recovering, not simply whether one isolated count changes.
The article describes State of Nature metrics as a way to track changes in nature across countries and sectors. It does not list the metrics’ specific indicators or explain a counting method. It does, however, argue that measures need to work across diverse ecosystems and contexts. That broad scope means the goal is to assess changes in nature in a consistent way, not to treat a species count as the whole picture.
The authors call for empirical testing and wider use of the metrics across landscapes, seascapes, biomes and different social and governance settings. Their proposed dashboard would also account for financial, legal, social and ecological factors. These plans reflect the article’s emphasis on context and nature’s condition, while details of exactly what gets measured remain outside the information provided.
This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.
Read more in the JupiteX app
Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.
Or read more news on the web