JupiteX Get the app
Politics & Governance18 Nov 2026 · about 7 min

Supreme Court seeks Centre’s response on delay in finalising judges’ appointment procedure

The brief

The Court has not yet finalized the procedure; it has asked the Centre and the top court’s Secretary General to respond. The case concerns rules for appointing judges to India’s constitutional courts and a petition alleging years of delay. A bench of Justices MM Sundresh and PB Varale issued notice on a petition by the NGO Lok Prahari. The petition says a 2015 Constitution Bench direction has not been followed. It asks the Court to direct finalisation of the amended Memorandum of Procedure within a month and to make Collegium selection minutes accessible under the RTI Act. The notice seeks the respondents’ response to those requests; it is not a final ruling on them. The petition names the Union of India and the CJI through the Secretary General. The next step described in the article is for the Centre and Secretary General to respond. The Court has not stated what it will decide after receiving their replies.

01

What response has the Supreme Court asked the Centre and its Secretary General to give?

The Court has not yet finalized the procedure; it has asked the Centre and the top court’s Secretary General to respond. The case concerns rules for appointing judges to India’s constitutional courts and a petition alleging years of delay.

A bench of Justices MM Sundresh and PB Varale issued notice on a petition by the NGO Lok Prahari. The petition says a 2015 Constitution Bench direction has not been followed. It asks the Court to direct finalisation of the amended Memorandum of Procedure within a month and to make Collegium selection minutes accessible under the RTI Act.

The notice seeks the respondents’ response to those requests; it is not a final ruling on them. The petition names the Union of India and the CJI through the Secretary General. The next step described in the article is for the Centre and Secretary General to respond. The Court has not stated what it will decide after receiving their replies.

02

What is the Memorandum of Procedure, and what aspects of judges’ careers does it govern?

The Memorandum of Procedure, or MoP, is a set of documents governing how judges are appointed, elevated and transferred. In this case, the petition concerns an amended MoP for judges of the constitutional courts: the Supreme Court and High Courts. The procedure matters because it sets out how decisions about judicial appointments and career moves are handled.

The article says the Supreme Court’s 2015 Constitution Bench revived the Collegium system after striking down the National Judicial Appointments Commission. It also directed that the MoP be finalised. A later order called for the existing MoP to be supplemented with decisions made by CJI Surya Kant, based on the unanimous view of the top court’s four senior-most judges.

The petition says the amended procedure remains unfinished and argues that the existing MoP lacks transparency and objectivity. It asks the Court to require finalisation within a month. It also seeks public access under the RTI Act to the minutes of Supreme Court and High Court Collegium meetings that select judges. The Court has sought responses, but the article reports no final decision.

03

What is the Collegium system, and what role does it play in appointing judges to India’s High Courts and Supreme Court?

The Collegium system is the process used to appoint judges to India’s Supreme Court and High Courts. The article explains that it returned after a Constitution Bench struck down the National Judicial Appointments Commission in 2015. The way the Collegium works matters because it is central to selecting judges for the country’s constitutional courts.

The article refers to the Supreme Court Collegium and the High Court Collegiums as bodies that conduct judge selection. It describes the CJI’s decisions on the amended MoP as based on the unanimous view of the top court’s four senior-most judges. The petition also seeks access to minutes from meetings of both the Supreme Court and High Court Collegiums, so the selection process can be examined publicly.

The petition argues that the current procedure lacks transparency and objectivity, and it asks for the amended MoP to be finalized. The Court has sought responses from the Centre and the top court’s Secretary General. The article does not report a ruling on the petition’s demands, so the appointment process and any changes to its transparency remain unresolved in the reported proceedings.

04

How long has the amended appointment procedure been awaiting finalisation, and what did the 2015 Constitution Bench direct?

The petition says the amended appointment procedure had been awaiting finalisation for ten years. It argues that this was more than enough time to comply with the Supreme Court’s direction. The delay matters to the petitioners because the MoP governs appointments, elevations and transfers of judges to the constitutional courts.

In 2015, a Constitution Bench struck down the National Judicial Appointments Commission and revived the Collegium system. The petition says that, as part of that decision, the Court directed the CJI to take a decision on the MoP based on the unanimous view of the Collegium. The article also refers to an order dated December 16, 2025, calling for the existing MoP to be supplemented with decisions by CJI Surya Kant based on that view.

Lok Prahari says implementation has been unduly delayed and urges the Court to require finalisation within a month. The Supreme Court has sought responses from the Centre and its Secretary General. The article does not say that a finalised procedure has been issued or that the petition’s requested deadline has been granted.

05

What information about the selection of judges does the petition want made public under the RTI Act?

The petition asks that minutes of the selection process conducted by the Supreme Court and High Court Collegiums be accessible to the public under the Right to Information Act. These records relate to how judges are selected for constitutional courts. Making them available is part of the petition’s request for greater transparency and objectivity in appointments.

The petition identifies minutes from Collegium meetings as the information it wants opened to public access. It seeks records from both the Supreme Court and High Court Collegiums, not only the top court’s selection process. The request forms part of a broader challenge to the delay in finalising an amended Memorandum of Procedure, which governs judges’ appointment, elevation and transfer.

The article reports that the Supreme Court has sought responses from the Centre and its Secretary General; it does not say the minutes have been released. The petition asks the Court to direct that they become accessible under the RTI Act and to finalize the MoP within a month. Whether either request will be granted remains undecided in the reported proceedings.

06

Why does the petition argue that transparency and objectivity in selecting judges matter to people seeking justice?

The petition argues that transparency and objectivity matter because judge selection can affect the quality and performance of constitutional court judges. It connects that quality to the right to justice promised to litigants in the Constitution’s Preamble. People seeking justice depend on courts to decide their cases, so the petition says the appointment process deserves urgency.

The petition describes the existing MoP as having serious flaws because it lacks transparency and objectivity. As a concrete remedy, it asks for the minutes of Supreme Court and High Court Collegium meetings to be accessible under the RTI Act. It also seeks finalisation of the amended procedure within a month. These are requests made by the petition, not findings already made by the Court.

The Supreme Court has sought responses from the Centre and its Secretary General. The article does not report a decision on whether the MoP will be finalized or the minutes made public. The petition’s argument is that greater openness and objectivity in selection would help protect the quality of judges and, in turn, the justice litigants receive.

07

What is judicial independence, and why does it matter how judges are appointed?

Judicial independence is the principle that judges should be able to decide cases impartially, without improper influence from outside the court. The article does not define this principle or directly discuss pressure on judges. It does describe a dispute over the rules for appointing judges and the transparency of those decisions.

As general background, appointment systems matter because they determine how judges enter the courts and can help support public confidence in the process. In the article, the petition says the existing Memorandum of Procedure lacks transparency and objectivity. It argues that this can affect the quality and performance of constitutional court judges, and ultimately the right to justice promised to litigants in the Constitution’s Preamble.

The petition seeks public access under the RTI Act to minutes of Supreme Court and High Court Collegium selection meetings, as well as finalisation of the amended MoP. The Supreme Court has sought responses from the Centre and the top court’s Secretary General. The article reports no ruling on these requests, so their outcome remains open.

This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.

Read more in the JupiteX app

Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.

Or read more news on the web