India: Online censorship grows after 'Cockroach' protests
Restrictions have affected several kinds of expression in India, not just posts directly showing protests. Examples include videos discussing the ruling BJP and the Hindu nationalist RSS, footage of alleged police brutality, a satirical cartoon about Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s government, and accounts belonging to independent news outlets. The range matters because it touches political commentary, reporting and satire. Content creator CitySavitri’s video about the RSS and the BJP’s 2014 election victory was restricted within an hour of posting. Journalist Sadhika Tiwari said her video of a frightened girl describing alleged police brutality drew around 10 million views before it was restricted. Cartoonist Satish Acharya’s Instagram profile was blocked twice recently. The article reports that some creators and journalists received no notice or explanation, and some could not tell whether the government or a platform acted. Meta pointed to an appeals process for content and account restrictions. The examples raise questions about transparency and how restrictions on political expression are decided.
What kinds of posts and accounts were restricted in India after the CJP protests?
Restrictions have affected several kinds of expression in India, not just posts directly showing protests. Examples include videos discussing the ruling BJP and the Hindu nationalist RSS, footage of alleged police brutality, a satirical cartoon about Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s government, and accounts belonging to independent news outlets. The range matters because it touches political commentary, reporting and satire.
Content creator CitySavitri’s video about the RSS and the BJP’s 2014 election victory was restricted within an hour of posting. Journalist Sadhika Tiwari said her video of a frightened girl describing alleged police brutality drew around 10 million views before it was restricted. Cartoonist Satish Acharya’s Instagram profile was blocked twice recently.
The article reports that some creators and journalists received no notice or explanation, and some could not tell whether the government or a platform acted. Meta pointed to an appeals process for content and account restrictions. The examples raise questions about transparency and how restrictions on political expression are decided.
How many views did journalist Sadhika Tiwari's video of a girl describing alleged police brutality receive before it was restricted?
The video received around 10 million views within hours, according to independent journalist Sadhika Tiwari. It showed a frightened young girl crying and speaking about alleged police brutality during the youth-led Cockroach Janata Party protests. The view count highlights how quickly footage from a protest can reach a large audience before access is restricted.
Tiwari was covering a CJP protest in New Delhi on July 20. Police used batons and tear gas against demonstrators, and she recorded the girl’s account. Tiwari said the video was restricted in India after it gained its audience. The article does not say exactly when the restriction began or identify who specifically requested it.
Her experience sits within a wider pattern described by journalists and creators, some of whom received no prior notice or explanation. Some were unsure whether the government had requested restrictions or whether platforms acted on their own. The article gives no further view-count breakdown or details about how long Tiwari’s video remained restricted.
Who can trigger a takedown under the system described, and what role do social media platforms play?
Under the system described, a valid court order or a reasoned government notice can require intermediaries, including social media platforms, to remove or disable access to specified unlawful content. The February 2026 amendments also allow authorized police officials to notify intermediaries about content they consider unlawful, without necessarily filing a formal complaint or starting other legal proceedings. This makes both the source and process of a restriction important.
Platforms have a role beyond receiving notices. Meta said it uses automated tools to detect and review content that may violate its community standards. It also automatically restricts access to certain content in India to comply with legal requirements. The article says some users could not tell whether a restriction followed a government request or a platform’s own action.
After receiving a valid order or reasoned notice, platforms must act within three hours under the amended rules. Failure can put their liability protection at risk. The article also reports concerns about limited public information on government takedown requests, making it difficult to judge the scale of restrictions.
What can happen to a platform if it does not remove specified unlawful content within the required deadline?
The consequence named in the article is the possible loss of an intermediary’s liability protection. Section 79 of India’s IT Act protects social media platforms and other intermediaries from liability for content posted by third parties, but only if they meet legal conditions. One condition is responding to specified unlawful-content notices within the required time.
The February 2026 amendments set a three-hour deadline after a valid court order or reasoned government notice. If an intermediary does not remove the content or disable access within that period, it can lose the protection. The article describes this as a possible consequence, not an automatic penalty in every case.
Losing the protection matters because platforms may then face liability relating to users’ posts, rather than relying on Section 79’s shield. The tight deadline and risk of losing that shield can encourage rapid compliance. The article also raises concerns that this pressure, alongside automated takedowns and limited transparency, may make it harder to ensure restrictions are justified and fairly handled.
How did the 2026 change to India's takedown deadline compare with the previous rule?
India’s February 2026 amendments shortened the time intermediaries have to act on specified unlawful content. The new deadline is three hours after a platform receives a valid court order or a reasoned government notice. The earlier deadline was 36 hours. That is a substantial reduction in the time available to assess and respond to a notice.
The deadline applies to removing the specified content or disabling access to it. Section 79 of the IT Act provides intermediaries with protection from liability for third-party content when they meet legal conditions, and failure to comply can result in losing that protection. The article also says authorized police officials may notify platforms about content they consider unlawful without first filing a formal complaint.
The shorter time limit is part of a wider debate about online censorship and due process. Creators and journalists described restrictions without prior notice or explanation, while a technology policy adviser and a digital rights group raised concerns about transparency. The article does not describe any further changes to the deadline or explain how each notice is reviewed.
What ways do users have to challenge a content or account restriction?
The article identifies an appeal as a way to challenge a restriction, but gives limited detail. When DW asked Meta for comment, the company pointed to a website statement noting that users can appeal restrictions on content and accounts. It does not specify the steps, deadlines, or how an appeal is decided.
The article gives examples of restrictions affecting Instagram content and profiles, as well as an X account. Maktoob Media’s account was withheld in India in May 2025 while it reported on the India-Pakistan conflict; the outlet said it contacted officials and X but received no response. Access returned a few days later without an explanation. The article does not say what appeal route, if any, Maktoob used.
Several creators and journalists said they received no advance notification or explanation. Some were unsure whether government requests or platforms had caused restrictions. The account therefore points to Meta’s stated appeal option, while leaving open how users can challenge restrictions elsewhere and whether appeals provide a clear remedy.
What is 'safe-harbor' protection for online platforms, and why can losing it affect how they handle users' posts?
In this article, the relevant protection is Section 79 of India’s IT Act. It shields social media platforms and other intermediaries from liability for content posted by third parties, provided they meet certain legal conditions. This protection matters because platforms host posts made by users, and the rules connect their legal position to how they respond to specified notices.
One condition in the February 2026 amendments is to remove or disable access to specified unlawful content within three hours of receiving a valid court order or reasoned government notice. The previous deadline was 36 hours. If a platform fails to comply, it can lose its liability protection. The article also says authorized police officials can notify intermediaries about content they consider unlawful.
The risk of losing protection gives platforms a reason to act quickly on qualifying notices. The article describes criticism that automated takedowns and limited transparency may weaken due process. It does not explain what liability would follow in any particular case, but it reports concerns about how the system affects users’ posts and independent journalism.
This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.
Read more in the JupiteX app
Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.
Or read more news on the web