JupiteX Get the app
International Relations19 Nov 2026 · about 7 min

Genocide: The difficulty of proving the crime of crimes

The brief

The International Court of Justice (ICJ) is being asked to decide whether Myanmar’s acts against the Rohingya amount to genocide under the 1948 Genocide Convention. The case was brought by Gambia, which complains of ethnic cleansing against the Muslim minority. The question matters because the ICJ hears disputes between states, and its ruling may shape how the Convention is applied. The key legal test is not simply whether terrible acts occurred. Genocide requires intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a protected national, ethnic, racial or religious group. The Convention’s definition is stricter than the concept developed by Raphael Lemkin, and later legal decisions have made convictions harder to secure. The ICJ plans to announce its ruling on November 19. If it finds the acts amount to genocide, that decision could influence South Africa’s separate case accusing Israel of genocide in Gaza. The Israel case has not yet been scheduled for a ruling.

01

What is the International Court of Justice being asked to decide in Gambia’s case against Myanmar?

The International Court of Justice (ICJ) is being asked to decide whether Myanmar’s acts against the Rohingya amount to genocide under the 1948 Genocide Convention. The case was brought by Gambia, which complains of ethnic cleansing against the Muslim minority. The question matters because the ICJ hears disputes between states, and its ruling may shape how the Convention is applied.

The key legal test is not simply whether terrible acts occurred. Genocide requires intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a protected national, ethnic, racial or religious group. The Convention’s definition is stricter than the concept developed by Raphael Lemkin, and later legal decisions have made convictions harder to secure.

The ICJ plans to announce its ruling on November 19. If it finds the acts amount to genocide, that decision could influence South Africa’s separate case accusing Israel of genocide in Gaza. The Israel case has not yet been scheduled for a ruling.

02

Who are the Rohingya, and what crimes does Gambia allege were committed against them?

The Rohingya are a Muslim minority, according to the article. They are the group at the centre of Gambia’s complaint against Myanmar. Their identity matters legally because the Genocide Convention protects national, ethnic, racial and religious groups from acts committed with intent to destroy them, in whole or in part.

The article characterizes Gambia’s complaint as concerning the ethnic cleansing of the Rohingya and says the ICJ is considering whether the acts amount to genocide. It does not describe particular incidents or list the acts alleged in the case. The central mechanism is the Convention’s intent requirement: the court must consider whether the evidence supports an intention to destroy the protected group, rather than merely establish that grave harm occurred.

The ICJ plans to announce its ruling on November 19. A finding that the acts amount to genocide could create legal precedent relevant to South Africa’s case accusing Israel of genocide in Gaza. That later case has not been scheduled for a ruling.

03

How many states have ratified the Genocide Convention, and has any state ever been convicted of genocide?

The 1948 Genocide Convention has been ratified by 153 states, including Israel. Yet the article says no state has ever been convicted of genocide. The contrast shows how difficult it has been to establish responsibility for this crime in international justice, even as the Convention sets a legal standard for protecting groups.

Individuals have been found guilty by international tribunals, including those for Rwanda and the former Yugoslavia, as well as by national courts using universal jurisdiction. The first person legally deemed a génocidaire was Jean-Paul Akayesu, a Rwandan mayor, convicted in 1998. Among the massacres during the former Yugoslav wars, only Srebrenica was judged to be genocide; 8,000 Bosnian Muslim men and boys were killed there in 1995.

The ICJ’s upcoming decision concerns Gambia’s case against Myanmar, not a criminal trial of individuals. If the court finds that the acts amount to genocide, the ruling could contribute to legal precedent. The article says that precedent may affect South Africa’s case against Israel.

04

How could the ruling affect South Africa’s case accusing Israel of genocide in Gaza?

The ICJ’s decision on Myanmar could influence how it considers South Africa’s separate complaint accusing Israel of genocide in Gaza. The connection is legal precedent: a ruling on whether acts against the Rohingya meet the Convention’s definition could inform the court’s reasoning in another state-to-state case.

The article reports that the ICJ ordered Israel in 2024 to halt its offensive because of Gaza’s “catastrophic humanitarian situation” and to allow investigation of the genocide allegation. It also says the government of Benjamin Netanyahu did neither. These interim orders are distinct from a final ruling on whether genocide occurred.

The Myanmar decision is planned for November 19, while the Israel case has not yet been scheduled for a ruling. A jurist familiar with the process described himself as “moderately optimistic” and acknowledged the possible influence on the Israel case. The article presents that influence as a potential consequence, not a guaranteed outcome.

05

What does the 1948 Genocide Convention mean by genocide?

The 1948 Genocide Convention defines genocide through both intent and a protected group. The perpetrator must intend to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnic, racial or religious group, as such. This definition matters because it sets a legal boundary around the crime, rather than treating every large-scale killing as genocide.

The Convention lists acts committed with that intent. The article quotes killing members of the group and begins to quote causing serious bodily harm, though the supplied text cuts off during that list. It also explains that the Convention’s definition emerged from lengthy negotiations after World War II and was narrower than Raphael Lemkin’s original concept.

That narrower definition, together with later international jurisprudence, has made convictions difficult. The Convention has been ratified by 153 states, but no state has ever been convicted of genocide. The ICJ’s coming decision on Myanmar will test how the definition applies to a state’s alleged treatment of the Rohingya.

06

Why is it difficult to prove an intent to destroy a group, and how might the same acts instead be treated as war crimes or crimes against humanity?

Genocide is difficult to prove because the Convention requires more than showing that a group suffered grave harm. The prosecution must establish intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnic, racial or religious group. The article says the Convention’s definition is stricter than Lemkin’s original concept and that later jurisprudence has made convictions even harder.

The article gives examples of how rarely courts have applied the label: among massacres in the former Yugoslav wars, only Srebrenica was judged genocide. As general legal context not detailed in the article, the same conduct can also be assessed under other crimes, but each has its own legal elements. Crimes against humanity concern crimes against individuals in a wider attack; war crimes concern serious violations of the laws of armed conflict.

A court could therefore find grave crimes without finding the specific intent required for genocide. The ICJ’s Myanmar ruling will address whether the acts against the Rohingya meet that demanding standard, with potential implications for South Africa’s case against Israel.

07

How does genocide differ from crimes against humanity, which focus on crimes against individuals?

Genocide and crimes against humanity address different kinds of harm. In the article’s account, genocide punishes the destruction of a collectivity, while crimes against humanity punish the murder of individuals. The distinction matters because violence against people can be immense without automatically satisfying genocide’s group-destruction requirement.

The article links the ideas to two jurists who studied in Lviv: Raphael Lemkin coined “genocide” to define Nazi crimes, while Hersch Lauterpacht coined the concept of crimes against humanity. Lemkin’s concern extended beyond physical murder to the destruction of a group’s economic foundations. The Convention later adopted a narrower definition centred on intent to destroy protected groups.

This distinction is part of why genocide cases are difficult to prove. The Convention has led to very few findings: the article notes no state has ever been convicted, and Srebrenica was the only former Yugoslav war massacre judged genocide. The ICJ’s Myanmar decision will test the definition in a case concerning the Rohingya.

This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.

Read more in the JupiteX app

Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.

Or read more news on the web