JupiteX Get the app
Environment & Climate19 Nov 2026 · about 6 min

Tropical plantations reshape biodiversity in ways species counts alone cannot reveal

The brief

Intensive rubber and oil palm monocultures had far fewer species than rainforest, but the decline did not make every community more alike. That is the study’s surprising finding: a species count can show loss while missing how species are distributed among places. An international team led by the University of Göttingen studied 32 plots in Sumatra, across landscapes ranging from lowland forest to traditional mixed rubber farms and intensively managed monocultures. They sampled 40,000 species across 24 groups, including plants, birds, bats, insects, spiders, and organisms living in soil. The average local diversity in monocultures was around 50% lower than in rainforest. The responses varied among groups and between aboveground and belowground communities. Aboveground communities in monoculture sites differed strongly because species-poor sites held subsets of species found at richer sites. The researchers conclude that conservation should consider whole landscapes and many organism groups, rather than relying only on species totals or isolated sites.

01

What did the study find about biodiversity in intensive rubber and oil palm plantations compared with rainforest?

Intensive rubber and oil palm monocultures had far fewer species than rainforest, but the decline did not make every community more alike. That is the study’s surprising finding: a species count can show loss while missing how species are distributed among places.

An international team led by the University of Göttingen studied 32 plots in Sumatra, across landscapes ranging from lowland forest to traditional mixed rubber farms and intensively managed monocultures. They sampled 40,000 species across 24 groups, including plants, birds, bats, insects, spiders, and organisms living in soil. The average local diversity in monocultures was around 50% lower than in rainforest.

The responses varied among groups and between aboveground and belowground communities. Aboveground communities in monoculture sites differed strongly because species-poor sites held subsets of species found at richer sites. The researchers conclude that conservation should consider whole landscapes and many organism groups, rather than relying only on species totals or isolated sites.

02

How much lower was species richness in monocultures locally and across the wider landscape?

The study found a large drop in species richness in intensive agriculture: around 50% lower locally and as much as 78% lower across the landscape, compared with rainforest. The bigger landscape-level figure is striking because it shows that the loss is not limited to what researchers find in a single plantation area.

The international team led by the University of Göttingen compared 32 plots in Sumatra along a land-use gradient. That ranged from lowland forests to traditional rubber farming, where rubber trees grow alongside other trees, and then to intensively managed smallholder monocultures of rubber or oil palm. Across these plots, researchers sampled 40,000 species from 24 groups of organisms.

The figures describe declines in the species diversity studied, but they do not tell the whole story. Communities can differ in which species they contain even when they have similarly low richness. The researchers therefore argue that biodiversity assessment and conservation should account for community composition, multiple organism groups, and entire landscapes, not just local species totals.

03

Which kinds of organisms and habitats did the researchers compare in Sumatra?

The researchers looked across a wide range of life, not just conspicuous animals or plants. Their 24 groups included plants, birds and bats, insects and spiders, soil organisms, and microorganisms. Sampling above and below ground helped them examine how different parts of biodiversity responded to land use.

The study covered 32 plots in the tropical lowlands of Indonesia’s Sumatra island. Those plots followed a gradient: lowland forest, traditional rubber farming with rubber trees growing alongside other trees, and intensively managed smallholder monocultures of rubber or oil palm. In total, the team sampled 40,000 species across the plots.

This broad comparison matters because the study found that organisms react differently to intensive agriculture. Species richness fell sharply, but the structure and composition of communities did not change in the same way everywhere. By including many groups and habitats, the researchers could detect patterns that a survey focused on one taxon or only aboveground life might not capture.

04

Why can species-poor plantation sites still differ from one another in the species they contain?

A site can have few species without having the same few species as another site. The study found that aboveground communities in monoculture areas differed strongly: species-poor sites contained subsets of the species present at richer ones. Their identities varied, even as the overall number of species fell.

This pattern helps explain why species richness and community composition are different measures. Richness counts how many species occur; composition concerns which species are present. In this study, intensive agriculture caused a drastic decline in richness, but the change in composition was not simply a uniform move toward identical communities. The researchers found that organisms responded differently to land use.

The practical implication is that a simple count can conceal a progressive simplification of biodiversity. Assessments need to ask which species occur in different locations and how communities are structured. The researchers therefore recommend considering whole landscapes, including varied habitats and groups of organisms, rather than treating each plantation or protected area as a complete picture.

05

What is species richness, and how is it different from the composition of a biological community?

Species richness means the number of species recorded in a place. Community composition means which species make up the community. These are related but distinct measures: two sites can each contain ten species, for example, yet have entirely different sets of species. This is a standard ecological distinction; the article focuses on both richness and composition.

In the Sumatra study, researchers compared 32 plots across forest, traditional rubber farming, and intensive rubber or oil palm monocultures. They found that average local diversity in monocultures was around 50% lower than in rainforest. Yet the sharp decline in species numbers did not automatically make communities more similar. Aboveground communities differed strongly because poorer sites held subsets of species found at richer sites.

That distinction matters for understanding what land-use change does. A richness total records how many species remain, but it cannot by itself show which species have been lost or how communities vary across places. The researchers argue that assessments should consider community composition, multiple organism groups, and whole landscapes.

06

How can replacing rainforest with a single-crop plantation change the habitats and resources available to wildlife?

The study directly shows that intensive rubber or oil palm monocultures are associated with sharply lower species diversity than rainforest. It does not report measurements of particular wildlife foods, nesting sites, or other resources. The specific resource effects should therefore not be treated as findings from this study.

As general ecological knowledge, replacing a varied forest with a single-crop plantation can simplify the vegetation structure and reduce the range of habitat features available to wildlife. Different species use different plants and places for food, shelter, or breeding, so fewer kinds of vegetation can mean fewer kinds of resources. The precise effects depend on the site and species; those details are not given in the article.

For Sumatra, the researchers compared lowland forests, traditional rubber farms with other trees, and intensive monocultures. Their results show why the whole landscape matters: local richness fell by around 50% on average, while landscape-level diversity was as much as 78% lower. The study recommends considering varied habitats and organism groups in conservation.

07

Why does protecting biodiversity require considering whole landscapes, with varied habitats and groups of organisms?

The study found that intensive agriculture reduced species richness sharply, yet did not make all communities more alike. Organisms responded differently, and aboveground monoculture communities varied in which species they contained. That means protecting one site or tracking one species count may miss important changes across a wider area.

The researchers compared 32 plots in Sumatra, from lowland forests through traditional rubber farms to rubber and oil palm monocultures. They sampled 40,000 species across 24 groups, including plants, birds, bats, insects, spiders, soil organisms, and microorganisms. Local diversity in monocultures was around 50% lower, and landscape-level diversity as much as 78% lower, than in rainforest.

The authors say conservation must consider entire landscapes, not only individual protected areas or plantations. Taking account of different habitats and groups of organisms can reveal which species occur where and how communities are structured. They argue this broad view is needed to effectively limit tropical biodiversity loss.

This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.

Read more in the JupiteX app

Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.

Or read more news on the web