‘Phantom forests’ in Australia’s arid outback used to create carbon credits meant to offset emissions, report claims
“Phantom forests” is the researchers’ term for outback areas they say are being treated as forest-regeneration sites despite having little or no real forest growth. The issue matters because credits from these projects can let polluting companies count offsets as emissions cuts. The researchers examined 50 regeneration projects, including areas north-west of Bourke. They reported only a small increase in forest and tree-crown cover over five years, despite wet conditions. Prof David Eldridge said some areas had never grown forests and would never do so. Prof Andrew Macintosh said the projects were largely not regenerating forest. These conclusions are disputed. Project manager Green Collar said the projects were closely examined and working, while the Clean Energy Regulator said it had confidence in the method. The regulator said projects must show increasing canopy cover every five years and that it had rejected areas that could have received 6.7m credits. The report’s findings are claims, not an agreed verdict.
What does the report mean by “phantom forests,” and why do researchers say these areas should not earn forest-regrowth credits?
“Phantom forests” is the researchers’ term for outback areas they say are being treated as forest-regeneration sites despite having little or no real forest growth. The issue matters because credits from these projects can let polluting companies count offsets as emissions cuts.
The researchers examined 50 regeneration projects, including areas north-west of Bourke. They reported only a small increase in forest and tree-crown cover over five years, despite wet conditions. Prof David Eldridge said some areas had never grown forests and would never do so. Prof Andrew Macintosh said the projects were largely not regenerating forest.
These conclusions are disputed. Project manager Green Collar said the projects were closely examined and working, while the Clean Energy Regulator said it had confidence in the method. The regulator said projects must show increasing canopy cover every five years and that it had rejected areas that could have received 6.7m credits. The report’s findings are claims, not an agreed verdict.
How can human-induced regeneration projects turn changes in vegetation into carbon credits?
Human-induced regeneration projects are intended to turn forest regrowth into credited emissions reductions. The core idea is that vegetation stores carbon, so a project that increases tree cover may be credited for carbon removed from, or prevented from entering, the atmosphere. Each credit is described as representing one tonne.
In the method described in the article, project areas must demonstrate that canopy cover is increasing every five years. Researchers examined 50 projects and said they found only a small increase in forest and tree-crown cover over five years, even with wet conditions. The report argues that credits have been generated despite limited regrowth. The article does not detail the scheme’s precise formula for converting measured growth into credits.
The Clean Energy Regulator said it had confidence in the method and had rejected non-complying areas that could have received 6.7m credits. Developers say canopy images do not capture all stored carbon. The disagreement matters because the credits can be used by companies to count toward their emissions obligations.
How many regeneration projects are there in Australia, how much land do they cover, and how many credits did the researchers say the projects generated?
Australia has had more than 430 human-induced regeneration projects since 2013. Together, they cover 38m hectares, an area larger than Japan. The scale matters because credits from these projects can be used by industrial polluters to count toward their emissions obligations.
The report’s lead researcher, Prof Andrew Macintosh, said the projects were by and large not regenerating forest, yet had created more than 60m carbon credits worth up to $2bn. Separately, the researchers examined 50 projects and reported only a small increase in forest and tree-crown cover over five years. The 50-project study is not the same figure as the national total.
Project developers and the Clean Energy Regulator reject the criticism. The regulator said it had confidence in the method and had rejected non-complying areas. The federal government is reviewing the safeguard policy, as required by legislation. The scale of the projects makes questions about credit quality important to that debate.
What does one carbon credit represent, and how can a company use it under Australia’s safeguard mechanism?
A carbon credit is said to represent one tonne of emissions removed from, or prevented from being released to, the atmosphere. It is an offset: rather than making an equivalent cut at its own site, a company can use a credit to claim a reduction elsewhere. Whether the credit represents a real reduction is therefore central to the policy debate.
Under the federal safeguard mechanism, industrial-polluting companies required to cut emissions are allowed to buy an unlimited number of credits and count them as their own cuts. The article says this lets them continue to pollute while using credits to meet the policy’s requirements. Researchers and the Australian Conservation Foundation argue that poor-quality forest credits weaken the mechanism.
Scientists cited in the article warn that limiting climate change requires rapid, direct emissions cuts and that offsets should be used sparingly. The government is reviewing the safeguard policy. If credits do not represent genuine reductions, critics say companies may pay for offsets instead of cutting their own pollution.
Why do researchers and project developers disagree about whether satellite images show that these projects are storing carbon?
The disagreement is partly about what satellite images can show. Researchers used satellite pictures to assess changes in forest and tree-crown cover across projects. They said the areas showed only a small increase in cover over five years, even though conditions were wet. For them, little visible regrowth supports doubts about whether the projects merit credits.
Green Collar challenged that interpretation. Its spokesperson said carbon is stored in stems, branches, leaves, roots and dead timber, while satellite canopy products see leaves from above. The company argued that these images do not measure wood and roots, where it said most of the carbon sits. It also said researchers judged projects using satellite images and one field visit.
Climate Friendly said the projects faced extensive scientific and regulatory scrutiny. The Clean Energy Regulator also said it had confidence in the regeneration method. The dispute matters because credits are meant to represent emissions removed or prevented, while the article describes disagreement over both visible growth and how much carbon can be measured from above.
What happens to emissions when a company buys credits instead of making direct cuts to its pollution?
When a company buys an offset, it can count the credit toward its emissions obligations without making the same reduction at its own operations. The article says companies under Australia’s safeguard mechanism can buy unlimited credits while continuing to pollute. The credit is supposed to represent a tonne removed from, or prevented from entering, the atmosphere.
The researchers argue that many forest-regeneration projects are producing little real regrowth. If a credit does not reflect a genuine reduction, a company may still release pollution while claiming an offset in its place. The report says a flood of cheap, low-integrity credits can make it cheaper for big polluters to buy offsets than to cut emissions directly.
Scientists warn that the climate crisis requires rapid direct cuts and that offsets should be used sparingly. The Australian Conservation Foundation says coal and gas companies should be banned from claiming offsets as their own cuts. The government is reviewing the safeguard policy, but the article does not say what changes will follow.
How do plants and soils take carbon dioxide out of the atmosphere, and what affects how long that carbon stays stored?
The article does not explain how plants and soils remove carbon dioxide, so this answer uses established scientific knowledge. Plants take in carbon dioxide during photosynthesis and use its carbon to build sugars and other materials. Some carbon becomes part of stems, branches and leaves; some moves into roots and, later, into soil as plant matter decays.
Soils can store carbon in organic material, including decomposing roots and leaves. The article notes that project developers regard stems, branches, leaves, roots and dead timber as carbon stores. It also reports that Green Collar argues satellite canopy images do not measure wood and roots, where it says most project carbon sits.
Storage can last for different lengths of time. It depends on how quickly plant material decomposes and whether carbon stores are disturbed or released through events such as fire, land clearing or harvesting. The article does not assess these factors for the projects. Its central dispute is whether the projects are regenerating forest and whether the credits reflect carbon stored.
This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.
Read more in the JupiteX app
Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.
Or read more news on the web