COP31 carbon capture target raises fears of prolonged fossil fuel dependence
The draft COP31 agreement proposes a global carbon capture target for 2035. It calls on countries to contribute to efforts to reach at least 500 million tonnes of carbon dioxide captured annually, reflecting current policies. It also calls for work toward a much higher annual capacity: between 1.3 billion and 2.5 billion tonnes. These figures appear in paragraph 60 of the draft Cover Decision, which outlines expected political outcomes from the negotiations. The proposal concerns Carbon Capture, Utilisation and Storage, or CCUS. In the process described by the article, carbon dioxide is captured at industrial facilities before it enters the atmosphere. It can then be transported and stored underground or used in industrial processes. The proposed capacity figures measure carbon dioxide captured per year, not emissions eliminated through reduced fossil fuel use. Climate advocates called the target unrealistic and warned it could let fossil fuel producers avoid reducing production. Oil Change International’s Romain Ioualalen said the higher target would require a 20- to 40-fold increase from existing capacity. The target is proposed, not an agreed outcome; it has not yet been adopted as the conference’s final decision.
What carbon capture target is proposed in the draft COP31 agreement for 2035?
The draft COP31 agreement proposes a global carbon capture target for 2035. It calls on countries to contribute to efforts to reach at least 500 million tonnes of carbon dioxide captured annually, reflecting current policies. It also calls for work toward a much higher annual capacity: between 1.3 billion and 2.5 billion tonnes. These figures appear in paragraph 60 of the draft Cover Decision, which outlines expected political outcomes from the negotiations.
The proposal concerns Carbon Capture, Utilisation and Storage, or CCUS. In the process described by the article, carbon dioxide is captured at industrial facilities before it enters the atmosphere. It can then be transported and stored underground or used in industrial processes. The proposed capacity figures measure carbon dioxide captured per year, not emissions eliminated through reduced fossil fuel use.
Climate advocates called the target unrealistic and warned it could let fossil fuel producers avoid reducing production. Oil Change International’s Romain Ioualalen said the higher target would require a 20- to 40-fold increase from existing capacity. The target is proposed, not an agreed outcome; it has not yet been adopted as the conference’s final decision.
What is Carbon Capture, Utilisation and Storage (CCUS), and how does it keep carbon dioxide from reaching the atmosphere?
Carbon Capture, Utilisation and Storage, or CCUS, is a set of technologies intended to capture carbon dioxide from facilities such as power plants, petrochemical plants and fertiliser factories. Its purpose is to stop some of those emissions from entering the atmosphere. The proposed COP31 target would accelerate deployment of these technologies, although advocates warn that they should not replace emissions cuts.
The process works in stages. Carbon dioxide is captured at an industrial site before it escapes into the air. It is then transported, usually by pipeline or ship, to underground storage or to industrial processes where it is used. For example, a power plant could capture carbon dioxide from its emissions and send the gas elsewhere for storage.
The article reports concerns that operational projects remain limited and that actual capture rates often fall below the 90 to 95 per cent levels proponents promise. CIEL campaigner Rachel Kennerley also said more than 80 per cent of captured carbon was still being used to extract additional oil and gas. Advocates argue that CCUS cannot solve the underlying problem of continued fossil fuel production and consumption.
How large is the proposed expansion: how does the 2035 target compare with today’s carbon capture capacity?
The proposed scale is far beyond current carbon capture capacity, according to Romain Ioualalen of Oil Change International. He said reaching the draft’s proposed annual capacity of 1.3 billion to 2.5 billion tonnes by 2035 could mean a 20- to 40-fold increase from existing capacity within the next decade. The draft also calls for at least 500 million tonnes captured annually by 2035, reflecting current policies.
The mechanism behind the target is an expansion of facilities and systems that capture carbon dioxide, move it, and store or use it. For example, captured gas from a power plant could be carried by pipeline or ship to storage or industrial use. The figures describe the proposed scale of carbon capture, not a reduction in fossil fuel production.
Ioualalen argued that the industry’s performance does not support the proposed expansion and that the figures lacked required scientific and political scrutiny. He said the technology had struggled to scale despite decades of investment. The target remains in a draft, but advocates warn that adopting it could encourage governments to keep fossil fuel infrastructure operating in the expectation that emissions can be captured later.
What could happen if governments treat carbon capture as a substitute for reducing fossil fuel use?
Carbon capture is intended to manage some emissions, but advocates fear governments could use it as a reason not to reduce fossil fuel use. That distinction matters because capturing carbon at a facility does not stop the production or consumption of fossil fuels. The draft target has therefore raised concern that a technology proposal could weaken efforts to phase out fossil fuels and cut emissions.
For example, a government might continue operating gas infrastructure while expecting carbon dioxide from its emissions to be captured and stored. Romain Ioualalen said such reliance could undermine electrification, which seeks to increase electricity use in sectors now dependent on fossil fuels. Advocates also warn that investment in capture could be diverted from renewable energy and other climate measures.
The article reports that operational projects remain limited and that capture rates often fall below the 90 to 95 per cent levels promised by proponents. Ioualalen argued that the proposed expansion was not supported by current industry performance. He said the serious route to preventing carbon dioxide from entering the atmosphere is getting out of fossil fuels and deploying renewable energy at scale.
How is capturing emissions from a factory different from removing carbon dioxide already in the atmosphere?
Capturing emissions from a factory and removing carbon dioxide from the atmosphere are different processes. Factory capture intercepts carbon dioxide at an industrial source, such as a power plant, petrochemical facility or fertiliser factory, before it enters the air. Carbon dioxide removal, or CDR, refers to technologies designed to remove carbon dioxide that is already in the atmosphere. The distinction matters because the two approaches address different points in the emissions pathway.
In the factory example, captured gas is transported, usually by pipeline or ship, for underground storage or use in industrial processes. This may prevent that particular carbon dioxide from reaching the atmosphere. It does not, by itself, remove carbon dioxide that has already accumulated in the air. Kennerley said capture could prevent emissions hitting the atmosphere but could not remove emissions.
Advocates also question whether factory capture performs as promised. Kennerley said actual capture rates often fall below the 90 to 95 per cent levels promoted by proponents, and noted that much captured carbon is used to extract more oil and gas. The article therefore cautions against treating capture as equivalent to removing atmospheric carbon or as a substitute for emissions cuts.
Where can captured carbon dioxide go, and why can using it to extract more oil or gas be a concern?
After carbon dioxide is captured at an industrial facility, it does not automatically stay at that site. The article says it is usually transported by pipeline or ship, then sent for underground storage or use in industrial processes. Where the gas goes matters because some uses may support continued fossil fuel production rather than reduce dependence on it.
Rachel Kennerley said more than 80 per cent of captured carbon was still being used to extract additional oil and gas. In this example, the carbon dioxide is put to use in a process that obtains more fossil fuels. That raises a concern: a technology promoted as a climate measure could also help keep oil and gas production going. The article does not give a breakdown of the uses or identify particular projects.
Kennerley argued that capturing emissions cannot address the underlying problem of continued fossil fuel production and consumption. Advocates say governments should not rely on capture as an alternative to deep emissions cuts. They also warn that investment directed to capture could be diverted from renewable energy and other measures needed to tackle climate change.
Why does burning fossil fuels warm the planet, and how do emissions cuts and renewable energy address that problem?
The article focuses on emissions cuts and renewable energy rather than explaining why fossil fuels warm the planet. Established climate science explains that burning coal, oil and gas releases greenhouse gases, including carbon dioxide, which trap heat in the atmosphere. More of these gases adds to warming. That makes the amount of carbon dioxide released from energy and industry central to climate action.
Emissions cuts address the problem at its source by reducing greenhouse gases released into the air. Renewable energy can provide electricity without relying on fossil fuels, while electrification can shift sectors that depend on fossil fuels toward electricity. The article describes electrification as a wider COP31 discussion and says it seeks to increase electricity use across those sectors.
The advocates argue that carbon capture should not be treated as a replacement for these changes. Ioualalen said the serious way to prevent carbon dioxide from entering the atmosphere is to get out of fossil fuels and deploy renewable energy at scale. He warned that continued reliance on gas and other fossil fuels, with capture as a fallback, could undermine electrification efforts.
This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.
Read more in the JupiteX app
Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.
Or read more news on the web