JupiteX Get the app
Politics & Governance19 Nov 2026 · about 7 min

Road safety no licence for arbitrary highway demolitions: Supreme Court

The brief

The Supreme Court clarified that its April 13, 2026 directions to remove unauthorised structures along national highways did not decide the legal status of every property identified by authorities. The order was issued for road safety, but it did not establish that particular buildings were encroachments or settle their owners’ rights. That distinction matters where an owner disputes the highway’s right-of-way boundary. Some applicants presented sale deeds, revenue records, acquisition papers or official permissions. Others challenged NHAI’s measurements. The court said a general direction to remove encroachments cannot substitute for deciding whether a specific property is one. Affected owners must take their challenges to the relevant high courts, which must independently examine the disputes. Existing interim protection continues until those cases are decided. Where no protection had been granted, the Supreme Court also barred demolition or other coercive action under the disputed notices. Authorities still have statutory powers, but must follow the applicable legal process.

01

What did the Supreme Court clarify about its April order to remove unauthorised structures along national highways?

The Supreme Court clarified that its April 13, 2026 directions to remove unauthorised structures along national highways did not decide the legal status of every property identified by authorities. The order was issued for road safety, but it did not establish that particular buildings were encroachments or settle their owners’ rights.

That distinction matters where an owner disputes the highway’s right-of-way boundary. Some applicants presented sale deeds, revenue records, acquisition papers or official permissions. Others challenged NHAI’s measurements. The court said a general direction to remove encroachments cannot substitute for deciding whether a specific property is one.

Affected owners must take their challenges to the relevant high courts, which must independently examine the disputes. Existing interim protection continues until those cases are decided. Where no protection had been granted, the Supreme Court also barred demolition or other coercive action under the disputed notices. Authorities still have statutory powers, but must follow the applicable legal process.

02

What happens to a proposed demolition while an affected owner’s challenge is protected by a court?

An interim protection order temporarily prevents demolition while a legal challenge is being considered. The Supreme Court directed that protections already granted would continue until the relevant proceedings in the high courts are disposed of. This means the proposed demolition must wait in those protected cases.

For example, if an owner had already secured interim protection against a notice, the authorities cannot proceed with demolition while that protection remains in effect. The Supreme Court also restrained NHAI and other authorities from demolishing disputed structures or taking coercive action under the impugned notices in cases where no such protection had earlier been granted.

Owners must bring their challenges before their respective high courts. The Supreme Court’s clarification does not permanently prevent authorities from removing a structure found to be an unauthorised encroachment. Instead, it preserves the legal process: the high court examines the dispute, and existing interim protection remains until the proceedings are decided.

03

Which court should property owners approach to challenge a proposed demolition?

The Supreme Court directed property owners facing proposed demolitions to challenge them in their respective high courts. Those courts must independently consider whether a particular structure is an unauthorised encroachment and whether the authorities followed the law. The April directions did not settle those individual questions.

The disputes include claims that NHAI’s right-of-way demarcation is wrong, as well as claims based on registered sale deeds, revenue records and permissions. For instance, some owners in Gujarat said their properties stood on private land that had not been acquired or compensated for. The high court is the forum the Supreme Court identified for these challenges.

The court also continued existing interim protection until the high court proceedings are disposed of. It separately restrained authorities from demolishing disputed structures under the notices in cases without earlier protection. Owners therefore have a designated forum to raise their claims, while highway authorities retain powers that must be exercised under the governing law.

04

What is a highway’s right-of-way, and how can it extend beyond the paved road?

A highway’s right-of-way, or ROW, is the corridor of land designated for the highway and related purposes. It can extend beyond the paved lanes; depending on the road and its designation, it may include shoulders, drainage areas or space for highway works. The article does not specify the exact width or components of any disputed ROW.

That boundary is central to the reported disputes. Some property owners said NHAI had measured or demarcated the ROW incorrectly. Others argued their buildings stood on privately owned land that had not been acquired or compensated for. The court said an authority’s assertion that a structure lies within the ROW cannot replace the determination required by law when that assertion is disputed.

The article’s immediate issue is not a universal measurement rule, but whether each property is inside the legally relevant corridor and is an unauthorised encroachment. Owners were directed to challenge proposed demolitions in their respective high courts. Those courts must examine the individual claims and the applicable procedure.

05

How long did the April order give authorities to identify and remove unauthorised structures within the highway right-of-way?

The April 13 Supreme Court order gave highway authorities and district administrations 60 days to identify and remove unauthorised structures within national-highway rights-of-way. It covered structures such as dhabas, eateries and other commercial establishments. The direction was framed as a road-safety measure.

The order also required district administrations to create highway safety task forces. Those task forces were to enforce the removal of existing and new unauthorised structures. The removals were to be carried out in accordance with the Control of National Highways (Land and Traffic) Act, 2002; the 60-day direction did not itself establish that every identified structure was illegal.

The Supreme Court later clarified that the April directions could not be used as blanket justification for demolition. Authorities must follow statutory procedure, and disputed properties require individual examination. Affected owners were told to challenge proposed demolitions in their respective high courts, with existing interim protection continuing until those cases are decided.

06

What notice and opportunity to respond does the 2002 law generally require before authorities remove an alleged encroachment?

Under the Control of National Highways (Land and Traffic) Act, 2002, the process described by the court generally starts with a notice identifying the highway land in question. The affected person must get an opportunity to make a representation, and authorities must consider the explanation before taking coercive action. This gives the person a chance to contest the allegation.

For example, an owner who disputes NHAI’s ROW measurements can raise that disagreement in response to a notice. The Supreme Court said an authority’s claim that a structure falls within the ROW is not a substitute for the determination required by law when the claim is disputed. The April road-safety directions did not independently justify skipping statutory requirements.

The law allows removal without prior notice in specified circumstances under subsections (7) and (8) of Section 26. But the court said the conditions governing those powers must be examined. The clarification therefore preserves statutory authority while requiring the applicable process to be followed.

07

Why is proving that a building lies within a highway’s right-of-way different from proving that it is an unlawful encroachment?

A building’s location and its legal status are different questions. A finding that a structure falls within a highway’s right-of-way may identify where it stands, but it does not by itself establish whether it is an unauthorised encroachment. The Supreme Court said authorities cannot treat their own assertion about the ROW as a substitute for the determination required by law when the boundary is disputed.

Owners cited registered sale deeds, revenue records, acquisition documents and permissions to contest demolitions. Some challenged NHAI’s measurements; some said their land had not been acquired or compensated for. These documents and claims may be relevant to the individual dispute, but the article does not say that any one item automatically prevents removal.

The court stressed both sides of the distinction: an ownership claim alone cannot block statutory action against an actual unauthorised encroachment, but a government claim alone does not prove one. The relevant high courts must examine individual cases, and authorities must follow the 2002 law’s procedure before coercive action, subject to its specified exceptions.

This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.

Read more in the JupiteX app

Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.

Or read more news on the web