SC to commence final hearing of pleas on marital rape in December
The Supreme Court has set the petitions for December 9 or 10, after the bench could not take them up on Thursday. The question is whether a husband can be prosecuted for rape if he forces his adult wife to have sex. It concerns an exception in both the former penal code and the current law. The immediate obstacle was a part-heard case already before Chief Justice Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana. Senior advocate Indira Jaising said that case was scheduled for 2 pm and the marital-rape petitions might not be reached. The Chief Justice said the bench was trying to finish the part-heard matter that day. The bench first discussed December 2-3 or December 9-10, then said it would fix December 9 or 10. It will try to hear the matter before the winter break, which begins on December 21. The final hearing could examine the exception’s constitutional validity and related questions about prosecution.
When does the Supreme Court plan to hear the marital-rape petitions, and what is it trying to finish first?
The Supreme Court has set the petitions for December 9 or 10, after the bench could not take them up on Thursday. The question is whether a husband can be prosecuted for rape if he forces his adult wife to have sex. It concerns an exception in both the former penal code and the current law.
The immediate obstacle was a part-heard case already before Chief Justice Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana. Senior advocate Indira Jaising said that case was scheduled for 2 pm and the marital-rape petitions might not be reached. The Chief Justice said the bench was trying to finish the part-heard matter that day.
The bench first discussed December 2-3 or December 9-10, then said it would fix December 9 or 10. It will try to hear the matter before the winter break, which begins on December 21. The final hearing could examine the exception’s constitutional validity and related questions about prosecution.
What age cutoff does the marital-rape exception use for a wife?
Under the exception, the wife must be at least 18: its wording excludes a wife who is under eighteen. This age threshold appears in the current Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, as well as the earlier Indian Penal Code provision described in the report. It marks which marriages fall within this particular exception.
The mechanism is the statutory text. The former IPC Section 375 had an exception, while Section 63, Exception 2, of the BNS says intercourse or sexual acts by a man with his own wife are not rape if she is not under eighteen. The new criminal laws took effect on July 1, 2024, replacing the IPC and other previous laws.
The petitions challenge the exception and ask the Supreme Court to examine its legality. The age cutoff is therefore part of the wording being considered, not a ruling by the court. The report does not say the court has decided whether the exception is valid or how it should be interpreted.
What does the marital-rape exception mean for a husband who forces his adult wife to have sex?
The exception means that conduct described in the provision is excluded from the legal definition of rape when the man and woman are married and the wife is at least eighteen. The petitions ask whether a husband should have this protection from prosecution for rape when he forces his adult wife to have sex.
The mechanism is a clause in the law. The former Indian Penal Code included the exception in Section 375; the current Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita has a similar rule in Section 63, Exception 2. It states that intercourse or sexual acts by a man with his own wife, if she is not under eighteen, are not rape. This describes the rape-law exception, not immunity from every possible legal claim.
The Supreme Court has not yet decided the challenge. It is due to hear the petitions in December and has said it will examine whether the exception is constitutional. The bench has also identified a separate question: whether prosecution can be sustained if the exception remains in force.
What could change if the Supreme Court rules that the exception is unconstitutional?
If the Supreme Court rules the exception unconstitutional, the clause would no longer provide the stated protection from rape law for a husband who forces his adult wife to have sex. This is a possible consequence, not a decision already made. The court has not yet completed its hearing or ruled on the petitions.
Even if the exception were struck down, that would not itself prove that a person committed rape. As a matter of general criminal-law process, a prosecution would still have to proceed under applicable law and establish the required facts. The article does not set out how any individual case would be handled or what other legal claims might apply.
The bench has said it will examine both whether the exception is constitutionally valid and whether prosecution can be sustained if it survives. The petitions concern corresponding provisions in the former IPC and current BNS. The ruling could therefore determine whether the statutory exception continues to operate, but the article gives no prediction of the outcome.
Why did the Delhi High Court judges reach different conclusions about the exception in 2022?
The Delhi High Court delivered a split verdict on May 11, 2022, because its two judges reached opposite conclusions about the marital-rape exception. Justice Rajiv Shakdher favoured striking it down as unconstitutional. Justice C Hari Shankar concluded that it was not unconstitutional and relied on what he called an intelligible differentia.
Their disagreement concerned whether the law’s distinction between wives and other women could stand. Justice Shakdher said it would be tragic if a married woman’s call for justice went unheard even after 162 years since the IPC’s enactment. Justice Shankar, by contrast, considered the exception constitutionally valid. The article does not provide a fuller account of each judge’s reasoning.
The judges agreed that the issue raised substantial questions of law requiring a decision by the Supreme Court, and granted a certificate of leave to appeal. One appeal was filed by a woman who had petitioned the High Court. The Supreme Court is now set to hear the batch of petitions in December.
How does Article 14 of India’s Constitution relate to arguments about the exception?
Article 14 is the constitutional provision at the centre of an equality argument about the exception. In general, it guarantees equality before the law and equal protection of the laws. The challenge is whether giving a husband this specific protection treats married women differently in a way the Constitution permits. The article does not give the full legal test applied by the Karnataka High Court.
The report says the Karnataka High Court earlier stated that exempting a husband from allegations of rape and unnatural sex with his wife runs against Article 14. This is a separate court’s view mentioned in the article. It is not presented as the Supreme Court’s final ruling on the petitions now before it.
The Supreme Court has said it will examine whether the marital-rape exception itself is constitutionally valid. The Article 14 argument may form part of that broader constitutional challenge, but the article does not say how the top court will resolve it. The exception remains in the BNS provision while the petitions await a final hearing.
How can a court decide whether a law written by lawmakers violates the Constitution?
A court deciding a constitutional challenge asks whether the law is consistent with the Constitution. In general, judges examine the law’s wording, its effect, the constitutional provisions raised, and the arguments made by the parties. The article does not explain a specific test for deciding whether this exception violates the Constitution.
Here, petitioners challenge the exception that says sexual intercourse or sexual acts by a man with his wife, if she is at least eighteen, are not rape. The Supreme Court has said it will examine whether the exception is constitutionally valid. The Delhi High Court’s judges disagreed on that question, and the Karnataka High Court had said the exemption ran against Article 14.
As a general matter, if a court finds a law unconstitutional, it may strike it down or otherwise limit its operation; the precise remedy depends on the ruling. That is general legal context, not a prediction about this case. The Supreme Court has not yet issued its final decision, and the article says the hearing is expected in December.
This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.
Read more in the JupiteX app
Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.
Or read more news on the web