JupiteX Get the app
Politics & Governance19 Nov 2026 · about 8 min

‘Go to Bangladesh’: Bengal minister dismisses criticism of killings in police ‘gunfights’

The brief

Ghosh’s most striking message to critics was to “go to Bangladesh”, with an offer to arrange their departure “without a visa”. The West Bengal minister was defending people accused of crimes being killed in alleged police gunfights. He described the killings as a “necessary act to decriminalise a criminalised society”. His remarks matter because they present lethal police action as a way to address crime, rather than as an event requiring scrutiny. He said the killings would continue and challenged anyone with the “guts” to stop them. Ghosh also pointed to demolitions, saying bulldozers were being used, and argued that law and police were setting things right. He referred to women’s safety and warned that people harassing women, particularly Hindu women, would face consequences like those in the Birbhum gunfight. The article reports at least five deaths in alleged gunfights in the six months since the BJP government took power in May. Ghosh also said Bengal should become like BJP-ruled Uttar Pradesh and Gujarat. His remarks came amid concerns about detentions and cross-border expulsions of Bengali-speaking people, mostly Muslims, described in the article.

01

What did West Bengal minister Dilip Ghosh say to people criticizing the alleged police killings?

Ghosh’s most striking message to critics was to “go to Bangladesh”, with an offer to arrange their departure “without a visa”. The West Bengal minister was defending people accused of crimes being killed in alleged police gunfights. He described the killings as a “necessary act to decriminalise a criminalised society”. His remarks matter because they present lethal police action as a way to address crime, rather than as an event requiring scrutiny.

He said the killings would continue and challenged anyone with the “guts” to stop them. Ghosh also pointed to demolitions, saying bulldozers were being used, and argued that law and police were setting things right. He referred to women’s safety and warned that people harassing women, particularly Hindu women, would face consequences like those in the Birbhum gunfight.

The article reports at least five deaths in alleged gunfights in the six months since the BJP government took power in May. Ghosh also said Bengal should become like BJP-ruled Uttar Pradesh and Gujarat. His remarks came amid concerns about detentions and cross-border expulsions of Bengali-speaking people, mostly Muslims, described in the article.

02

What does a police “encounter” or “gunfight” mean, and why is the term sometimes disputed?

In common usage in India, a police “encounter” or “gunfight” refers to a confrontation involving police and a person, often one accused of a crime, in which police gunfire may cause injury or death. The term describes the claimed circumstances; by itself, it does not establish what happened or whether the shooting was lawful. The article uses the cautious phrase “alleged gunfight”.

The label can be disputed when accounts of a shooting differ or when the circumstances have not been independently established. For example, an account that a person died during an armed exchange may be challenged over whether there was an exchange, what led to the shooting, or whether the use of force was justified. Those questions require evidence and investigation. The article gives accusations and outcomes, but does not provide detailed accounts of the shootings.

That distinction matters because being accused of a crime is not the same as being found guilty in court. The article reports Ghosh defending the deaths and saying they would continue, but it does not report findings about the legality of any individual shooting. This explanation of the term reflects general knowledge; the article itself does not define “encounter”.

03

How many people had been killed in alleged police gunfights in West Bengal since the BJP government took power, and who was the most recent?

At least five people had been killed in alleged police gunfights in West Bengal during the six months since the Bharatiya Janata Party government came to power in May, the article reports. The figure is a minimum, not a claim that exactly five people died. These deaths were described as alleged gunfights, and the people killed had been accused of crimes. The article does not report court findings establishing their guilt.

The most recent case described was Ratan Sheikh’s death on Sunday in Birbhum district. He had been accused of shooting and injuring a constable two days earlier. The other cases named were Dilip Roy, Prahlad Das, Samaul Sheikh and Prabhas Mondal. Their alleged offences included rape and murder, or the murder of a BJP worker. Each was reported killed in an alleged police gunfight or police shooting.

The article gives dates for several cases: Prabhas Mondal was shot on July 8; Samaul Sheikh and Prahlad Das died on October 28; and Dilip Roy died on November 9. It does not give a calendar date for the Sunday on which Ratan Sheikh died. Ghosh defended the killings and said they would continue, but the article reports no further outcome or official review.

04

What happens to a criminal case when an accused person is killed before a court can hear the evidence?

As a general legal principle, a criminal case against a person who dies before trial cannot proceed to a verdict against that person in the ordinary way. A court cannot convict or acquit someone who is no longer alive to face the proceedings. The death does not itself prove guilt or innocence, and it does not amount to a court finding that the person committed the alleged offence. This is general legal context; the article does not explain the effect of the deaths on specific cases.

The article names people accused of serious crimes who were killed in alleged police gunfights. It does not report their cases reaching trial, evidence being tested in court, or verdicts. That means the article’s descriptions remain accusations, not reported judicial findings. The distinction is important when discussing a person’s alleged crime and the state’s use of force.

A death may also leave questions about the alleged offence unresolved in court. Proceedings involving other accused people, if any, are a separate matter and depend on the case. The source does not say whether investigations continued, whether anyone else was charged, or whether any formal review followed these deaths. It reports Ghosh’s defence of the killings, not a legal decision on them.

05

What did India’s Supreme Court say about demolishing a person’s property as punishment for an alleged crime?

In November 2024, India’s Supreme Court held that demolishing a person’s property as punishment for an alleged crime was illegal, according to the article. It said authorities must follow due process before removing allegedly illegal encroachments. The ruling matters because the article describes demolitions targeting people accused of crimes, often Muslims and other marginalised groups, in Uttar Pradesh and some other BJP-ruled states.

The article links Ghosh’s defence of police killings to his mention of bulldozers. He asked, “Are bulldozers not being used?” and argued that law and police were working to set things right. But it also notes that Indian law has no provision allowing authorities to demolish the property of people accused of crimes as punishment. The Supreme Court’s stated requirement was due process before removing allegedly illegal encroachments.

The ruling addresses the use of demolition as punishment, not whether any particular structure is an illegal encroachment. Authorities must follow the required procedure before removing such encroachments. The article does not describe a specific demolition case in West Bengal or report how the ruling affected particular cases. It sets the legal context for Ghosh’s remarks and his reference to bulldozers.

06

Why did Ghosh’s “go to Bangladesh” remark matter in the context of Bengali-speaking people being detained and sometimes sent across the border?

Ghosh’s remark came amid reports of Bengali-speaking people being detained in several BJP-ruled states and accused of not being Indian citizens. The article says this began after the April 2025 terror attack in Pahalgam, Jammu and Kashmir. Most of those detained were Muslims. Against that background, telling critics to “go to Bangladesh” carried particular weight: the article describes people being forced across the border after allegedly failing to prove their citizenship.

Some people who were mistakenly sent to Bangladesh later returned to India after state authorities established that they were Indian citizens. The article does not say that Ghosh’s offer to facilitate critics’ departure was carried out. It reports the offer as part of his defence of alleged police killings and his claim that the killings were necessary to decriminalise society.

The context makes the remark more than a general insult about political disagreement. It echoed a real border expulsion described in the article, involving people whose citizenship was disputed and, in some cases, later confirmed by Indian authorities. The report gives no total for those detained or sent across the border, and it does not say what happened next to the people involved in Ghosh’s comments.

07

What is due process, and how does it protect people from being punished without a fair legal procedure?

Due process is the requirement that government authorities follow fair, established legal procedures before taking action that affects a person’s rights or property. It is a general legal concept, rather than a definition given in the article. In practice, the procedures depend on the type of action and the applicable law. The principle matters because it prevents an accusation alone from being treated as proof or as automatic authority to impose punishment.

The article gives a concrete example involving property. In November 2024, the Supreme Court held that demolishing property as punishment for an alleged crime was illegal. It said authorities must follow due process before removing allegedly illegal encroachments. The article also says Indian law contains no provision allowing authorities to demolish the property of people accused of crimes as punishment.

Due process does not mean that authorities can never enforce the law or remove an illegal encroachment. It means they must use the required legal procedure rather than punish someone without it. The article connects this safeguard to Ghosh’s reference to bulldozers and reports that demolitions targeting accused people had become commonplace in some BJP-ruled states. It does not provide details of the procedures required in individual cases.

This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.

Read more in the JupiteX app

Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.

Or read more news on the web