Mentors, colleagues and friends: tributes paid to the ‘Eritrea 16’ who disappeared 25 years ago
The “Eritrea 16” are 16 journalists who disappeared into Eritrea’s prison system on 18 September 2001. That day, known as Black Tuesday, the government shut down all the country’s newspapers. Their disappearance matters because it left families and colleagues without answers and silenced journalists whose work informed the public. Among them is Amanuel Asrat, a poet, writer, and founder of Zemen newspaper. The group also includes Dawit Isaak and Seyoum Tsehaye. The Committee to Protect Journalists says they are among the world’s longest-detained journalists. Their families have not received proof that they are alive, and the journalists have not been brought to trial, according to the article. The CPJ has renewed its call for Eritrean authorities to disclose the journalists’ fate and whereabouts. It will honour them in absentia at a New York ceremony on 19 November. The award recognizes their courage and sacrifice, but, as the CPJ chief executive stresses, recognition cannot replace truth, freedom, or justice.
Who are the “Eritrea 16,” and what happened to them on 18 September 2001?
The “Eritrea 16” are 16 journalists who disappeared into Eritrea’s prison system on 18 September 2001. That day, known as Black Tuesday, the government shut down all the country’s newspapers. Their disappearance matters because it left families and colleagues without answers and silenced journalists whose work informed the public.
Among them is Amanuel Asrat, a poet, writer, and founder of Zemen newspaper. The group also includes Dawit Isaak and Seyoum Tsehaye. The Committee to Protect Journalists says they are among the world’s longest-detained journalists. Their families have not received proof that they are alive, and the journalists have not been brought to trial, according to the article.
The CPJ has renewed its call for Eritrean authorities to disclose the journalists’ fate and whereabouts. It will honour them in absentia at a New York ceremony on 19 November. The award recognizes their courage and sacrifice, but, as the CPJ chief executive stresses, recognition cannot replace truth, freedom, or justice.
Why are the journalists being honoured now, 25 years after their disappearance?
The award brings attention to journalists who have spent decades disappeared, among the world’s longest-detained journalists. The Committee to Protect Journalists announced in August that it would honour the Eritrea 16 with an International Press Freedom award. The recognition matters because their case has not been resolved: families and colleagues still do not know their fate or whereabouts.
The group includes Amanuel Asrat, a poet, writer, and newspaper founder. Fellow journalist Fisseha Yirgalem, who had been his colleague and friend, described him in a letter read at a Nairobi memorial. Relatives also shared memories. Beilula Sium recalled seeing her father, journalist Seyoum Tsehaye, only once after his arrest, briefly through prison bars.
The journalists will be honoured in absentia at a New York ceremony on 19 November. CPJ chief executive Jodie Ginsberg says the award cannot replace truth, freedom, or justice. The CPJ is also calling on Eritrean authorities to disclose what happened to the journalists and where they are. The recognition keeps the unresolved case in public view.
In a human rights context, what does it mean when someone is forcibly disappeared?
In human rights usage, a forced disappearance occurs when state agents—or people acting with state support or consent—take someone into custody and then deny the detention or hide what happened to them. This leaves the person outside the protection of ordinary legal safeguards. The definition draws on established human rights usage; the article describes the Eritrea 16 as disappeared into the prison system.
The key mechanism is concealment: families cannot confirm where a detained person is, what condition they are in, or whether they are alive. In the article, the families and colleagues of 16 Eritrean journalists have no answers about their fate and whereabouts. CPJ says their families have been denied proof that they are alive.
The article says the journalists were arrested after Eritrea shut down its newspapers on 18 September 2001. It reports that neither their families nor colleagues know whether they are still alive. UN human rights experts have called for Eritrea to stop arbitrary detentions and disappearances. Disclosing the journalists’ fate and whereabouts remains CPJ’s demand; the article reports no confirmation or resolution.
How many journalists are imprisoned worldwide, and how many of them are the Eritrea 16?
The article says 335 journalists are imprisoned around the world. Sixteen of them are the Eritrea 16, journalists who disappeared into Eritrea’s prison system after the government closed all newspapers on 18 September 2001. Those figures show that imprisonment of journalists is not confined to one country, while the Eritrean case stands out for its decades-long lack of answers.
The CPJ plans to honour the Eritrea 16 with an International Press Freedom award. Its chief executive says the journalists deserve recognition for their journalism, not only for their disappearance. The award will be presented in absentia at a ceremony in New York on 19 November. The CPJ has also called for authorities to reveal the journalists’ fate and whereabouts.
The article gives 335 as the worldwide number, but does not provide a country-by-country breakdown or explain how that figure was compiled. It identifies the Eritrea 16 as part of the total. Their families still lack proof that they are alive, so the award is a form of recognition, not a substitute for answers, freedom, or justice.
What happens to families and public debate when journalists are detained incommunicado?
When journalists are held incommunicado, families may be cut off from basic information about a loved one’s location, health, or legal status. The article describes families who have been denied answers and proof that the Eritrea 16 are alive. This uncertainty can stretch for decades: the journalists disappeared in 2001, and relatives still do not know their fate.
Beilula Sium describes the only time she saw her father, journalist Seyoum Tsehaye, after his arrest. Two months later, her mother persuaded prison wardens to allow a brief visit; Sium saw her father through bars. She says it was the first and last time she was near him. Her memory shows how a short, tightly controlled visit cannot replace contact or reliable information.
The article also warns that silencing journalists puts press freedom at risk everywhere. When reporters cannot publish, the public has less access to their journalism and fewer opportunities to hear about matters journalists investigate. The article does not detail the Eritrean public’s debate, but it links the arrests to the shutdown of all newspapers. The CPJ says families deserve answers and journalists deserve freedom and justice.
Why can widespread or systematic arbitrary detention and enforced disappearance be treated as crimes against humanity?
Crimes against humanity are among the gravest international crimes. In established international law, the label generally applies to certain acts committed as part of a widespread or systematic attack directed against a civilian population, with the perpetrator’s knowledge of that attack. The article reports UN experts’ warning that widespread or systematic prolonged arbitrary detention and enforced disappearance may meet this threshold.
The scale and pattern matter: repeated or organized acts against civilians are different from an isolated unlawful detention. The experts also cite religious persecution. The article describes journalists held without knowing when they will be released, and says none of the 64 Jehovah’s Witnesses mentioned have been charged or tried. It reports a long-running pattern of detention, but does not itself establish every legal element.
The experts have called on Eritrean authorities to stop arbitrary detentions and disappearances and ensure justice for victims and families. They say these practices may constitute crimes against humanity; this is a warning about possible legal classification, not a reported court judgment. The article adds that Eritrea rarely responds to such calls. Accountability and reliable information remain unresolved in the cases it describes.
What is press freedom, and why does silencing journalists affect more than the journalists themselves?
Press freedom means that journalists and media can gather and publish information without being silenced by authorities or punished for their reporting. It matters beyond the newsroom because journalism gives people information about events and enables public scrutiny. The article’s central example is stark: Eritrea shut down every newspaper on 18 September 2001 and journalists disappeared into prison.
Among those detained was Amanuel Asrat, a poet, writer, and founder of Zemen newspaper. The article says 16 journalists were taken into Eritrea’s prison system, and their families and colleagues still do not know whether they are alive. The shutdown removed newspapers from public life, while detention prevented the journalists from continuing their work. The CPJ warns that silencing journalists with impunity puts press freedom everywhere at risk.
The CPJ is calling for authorities to disclose the journalists’ fate and whereabouts, and will honour them in absentia. Yet its chief executive says an award cannot replace truth, freedom, or justice. Protecting press freedom therefore means more than recognizing individual journalists: it also means resisting the conditions that let journalists be silenced without accountability.
This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.
Read more in the JupiteX app
Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.
Or read more news on the web