JupiteX Get the app
Politics & Governance19 Nov 2026 · about 7 min

Top court overturns 15-year prison term for ex-PM Han over martial law role

The brief

The Supreme Court overturned Han Duck-soo’s 15-year prison sentence and returned his case to the Seoul High Court. This is a remand, not a ruling that clears him of every conviction. The appeals court must review the parts of the case the Supreme Court questioned and deal with the case again under its ruling. The Supreme Court upheld convictions tied to Han’s attempts to collect Cabinet members’ signatures on a martial law-related document and to his review of plans to cut power and water to some media outlets. But it said it was difficult to determine whether his actions before the declaration showed an intent to subvert the Constitution, given the urgent situation at the time. Han will remain in custody while the case returns to the appeals court. The article gives no date for that court’s next ruling or the sentence it may impose. The Supreme Court also ruled that Yoon’s martial law declaration was unconstitutional and illegal.

01

What did the Supreme Court do to Han’s 15-year sentence, and where did it send his case?

The Supreme Court overturned Han Duck-soo’s 15-year prison sentence and returned his case to the Seoul High Court. This is a remand, not a ruling that clears him of every conviction. The appeals court must review the parts of the case the Supreme Court questioned and deal with the case again under its ruling.

The Supreme Court upheld convictions tied to Han’s attempts to collect Cabinet members’ signatures on a martial law-related document and to his review of plans to cut power and water to some media outlets. But it said it was difficult to determine whether his actions before the declaration showed an intent to subvert the Constitution, given the urgent situation at the time.

Han will remain in custody while the case returns to the appeals court. The article gives no date for that court’s next ruling or the sentence it may impose. The Supreme Court also ruled that Yoon’s martial law declaration was unconstitutional and illegal.

02

How did Han’s sentence change as his case moved through the lower courts, and what sentence did the Supreme Court overturn?

Han’s prison term changed at each stage of the lower-court process. A district court sentenced the former prime minister to 23 years in prison on Jan. 21. The Seoul High Court later reduced that term to 15 years, after acquitting him of some charges. The Supreme Court then overturned the 15-year sentence and returned the case to the appeals court.

The reduction followed the High Court’s decision to acquit Han of some allegations, including failing to fulfill his duty to stop Yoon’s martial law bid. The Supreme Court’s review addressed other parts of the case, too. It upheld some convictions but questioned whether Han intended to subvert the Constitution through actions before the martial law declaration.

The 15-year term is therefore the sentence that the Supreme Court overturned, not a final outcome after its review. The Seoul High Court must reconsider the case. The article does not say what sentence that court will impose or when it will rule again.

03

Which parts of Han’s convictions did the Supreme Court leave intact, and which part did it question?

The Supreme Court left some of Han’s convictions intact while questioning another part of the lower-court ruling. That distinction matters because the court did not reject the entire case against him. It returned the case for further review after deciding that the evidence about his actions before Yoon’s declaration did not clearly establish his intent.

The convictions the Supreme Court upheld concerned Han’s attempt to collect Cabinet members’ signatures on a martial law-related document and his review of plans to cut power and water to some media outlets. The court questioned the finding that his earlier conduct, including proposing a Cabinet meeting to give legitimacy to Yoon’s decree, showed an intent to subvert the Constitution.

The Supreme Court cited the urgent situation at the time as a reason that intent was difficult to determine. It ruled that the martial law declaration itself was unconstitutional and illegal, but sent Han’s case back to the Seoul High Court. Han remains in custody while that court revisits the case.

04

Why was it important for prosecutors to show whether Han intended to undermine the Constitution before martial law was declared?

The question of intent mattered because the Supreme Court was reviewing whether Han’s actions before Yoon declared martial law amounted to an attempt to subvert the Constitution. The court did not say that the declaration was lawful; it ruled that the declaration was unconstitutional and illegal. Instead, it questioned whether Han’s earlier conduct proved the particular intent attributed to him.

For example, the lower ruling found Han guilty for actions such as proposing a Cabinet meeting that could give legitimacy to Yoon’s decree. The Supreme Court said it was difficult to determine whether Han intended to undermine the Constitution through those actions, given the urgent situation at the time. It upheld other convictions, including those related to Cabinet signatures and media utilities.

That distinction affects which findings can stand and what the Seoul High Court must review on remand. The article does not detail the prosecution’s evidence or describe a specific argument made by prosecutors. It does show that the Supreme Court treated intent as unresolved, rather than treating the illegal declaration alone as proof of Han’s intent.

05

What happens next in Han’s case, and why will he remain in custody for now?

Han’s case is not finished. The Supreme Court overturned the 15-year sentence and sent the case back to the Seoul High Court, which must reconsider it in light of the Supreme Court’s ruling. The article does not give a date for the next hearing or say what sentence the appeals court will eventually set.

The Supreme Court upheld convictions over Han’s attempt to collect Cabinet members’ signatures on a martial law-related document and his review of plans to cut power and water to some media outlets. It questioned whether his earlier actions showed that he intended to subvert the Constitution. The court ruled that the martial law declaration itself was illegal and unconstitutional.

Han will remain in custody, even though the Supreme Court overturned his sentence. The article says this is apparently because some earlier convictions remained intact. His arrest was due to expire the following day, but the court said it would continue to hold him. Han has been detained since the district court sentenced him on Jan. 21.

06

What is martial law, and what kinds of powers can it give a government?

Martial law is a form of emergency rule in which a government gives military authorities expanded powers, sometimes over areas normally handled by civilian officials. This definition comes from general knowledge, not the article. What those powers include, and how they may be used, depends on a country’s constitution and laws. The term alone does not establish that any particular action is lawful.

In this case, former President Yoon Suk Yeol declared martial law on Dec. 3, 2024. The Supreme Court said the declaration violated the constitutional order and people’s basic rights, and ruled it unconstitutional and illegal. The article also says Han was convicted over reviewing plans to cut power and water to some media outlets after the declaration.

The court’s ruling did not end Han’s case. It overturned his 15-year sentence, upheld some convictions, and returned the case to the Seoul High Court. Han remains in custody. The article also reports that a district court sentenced Yoon to life imprisonment and that an appellate court is scheduled to rule on his case on Jan. 26.

07

How can a constitution and the courts limit a leader’s power to impose emergency rule?

A constitution sets rules for how government power may be used, including during emergencies. Courts can help enforce those rules by reviewing official actions and deciding whether they comply with the constitution. These are general principles; the article does not explain South Korea’s full constitutional procedure for emergency rule.

In this case, the Supreme Court ruled that Yoon’s Dec. 3, 2024, martial law declaration was unconstitutional and illegal. Chief Justice Cho Hee-dae said it did not align with the constitutional order and violated people’s basic rights. The court’s judgment shows one way legal limits can operate: a court can assess an emergency measure after it is imposed and rule that it breaches constitutional protections.

The ruling also shaped Han’s case, though it did not resolve every issue about his conduct. The Supreme Court questioned whether he intended to subvert the Constitution before the declaration, upheld some convictions, and sent the case back to the Seoul High Court. Han remains in custody as the case proceeds.

This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.

Read more in the JupiteX app

Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.

Or read more news on the web