JupiteX Get the app
International Relations20 Nov 2026 · about 7 min

European leaders reject 'Yalta 2.0' for Ukraine after Trump meets Putin and Xi

The brief

European leaders rejected what commentators called “Yalta 2.0”: the possibility that powerful countries might decide Ukraine’s future or Europe’s security without those affected at the table. German Chancellor Friedrich Merz said a Yalta-style format would not bring peace. French President Emmanuel Macron also said the China meeting did not amount to a reorganisation of the world. The concern followed a meeting in Shenzhen between Donald Trump, Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping. They discussed Ukraine, but their joint “Declaration Toward Peace” did not mention it. In Berlin, leaders insisted that negotiations must include Ukraine, Europe, the United States and Russia. British Prime Minister Andy Burnham said there should be no decision about Ukraine without Ukraine present. The Berlin gathering included more than 40 delegations. European leaders agreed to form a seven-member team for the next round of talks, while Russia had not committed to a multilateral format. Europe’s participation and Ukraine’s place in negotiations remain central questions as diplomatic efforts continue.

01

What did European leaders reject as “Yalta 2.0,” and who do they say must be included in talks about Ukraine and European security?

European leaders rejected what commentators called “Yalta 2.0”: the possibility that powerful countries might decide Ukraine’s future or Europe’s security without those affected at the table. German Chancellor Friedrich Merz said a Yalta-style format would not bring peace. French President Emmanuel Macron also said the China meeting did not amount to a reorganisation of the world.

The concern followed a meeting in Shenzhen between Donald Trump, Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping. They discussed Ukraine, but their joint “Declaration Toward Peace” did not mention it. In Berlin, leaders insisted that negotiations must include Ukraine, Europe, the United States and Russia. British Prime Minister Andy Burnham said there should be no decision about Ukraine without Ukraine present.

The Berlin gathering included more than 40 delegations. European leaders agreed to form a seven-member team for the next round of talks, while Russia had not committed to a multilateral format. Europe’s participation and Ukraine’s place in negotiations remain central questions as diplomatic efforts continue.

02

What was the 1945 Yalta Conference, and why is it being compared to these talks?

The Yalta Conference was a 1945 meeting of Allied leaders near the end of the Second World War. As general historical context, the leaders were Franklin D. Roosevelt, Winston Churchill and Joseph Stalin. They discussed the postwar order in Europe, including the treatment of Germany and arrangements for liberated countries. The article highlights Yalta as a moment when Europe was “divided up” and “parcelled up.”

That history makes Yalta a powerful comparison whenever major powers appear to negotiate Europe’s future among themselves. In the article, media commentators called a meeting between Donald Trump, Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping in Shenzhen “Yalta 2.0.” The three leaders discussed Ukraine, but their joint statement did not mention the country.

European leaders rejected the comparison as a model for peace. Merz said Europe would not allow a repeat of being divided without its consent. Macron said the Shenzhen statement did not reproduce Yalta’s outcome. He argued that Ukraine, Europe, the United States and Russia must take part in negotiations affecting them.

03

How large was the European effort to take part in the next round of talks?

Europe’s planned participation in the next round of talks is organised through a joint team of seven representatives. The article describes this as a concrete step toward direct European involvement in negotiations with Russia. The team is intended to represent several national governments as well as European and transatlantic institutions.

Its seven representatives are drawn from France, the United Kingdom, Germany, Poland and Italy, alongside the EU institutions and NATO. That makes seven sources of representation, not seven separate countries. The team was appointed after leaders at the Berlin meeting agreed it was time for Europe to engage in face-to-face negotiations with Russia.

This is a planned next step, not evidence that talks have already taken place in this format. Moscow has not committed to multilateral negotiations. Putin said he had invited Europeans to Moscow to define their positions, after which the Kremlin would decide whether to continue dialogue with Ukraine. The article does not name the seven individual representatives.

04

What could an Article 5-like security guarantee mean if Russia attacked Ukraine again?

An Article 5-like guarantee would be a security commitment modeled on NATO’s collective-defence principle. In the article, the proposed clause would apply if Russia attacked Ukraine again. It is presented as one possible future guarantee for Ukraine, not as a guarantee already in force or a settled agreement.

The key mechanism described is a promise of collective defence in response to another attack. The article does not spell out the exact response, who would provide it, or the legal terms. It also mentions a separate possible guarantee: a Europe-led peacekeeping force. Putin said he would not allow such a force in any scenario.

The proposals remain under discussion, and Merz said debate about European security would happen only after peace had been established in Ukraine. US envoy Jared Kushner called an Article 5-like commitment a very big deal for America. He said Trump was open to it, but that it would need to serve America’s interests.

05

How did the Yalta Conference help shape Europe’s division and the Cold War?

The Yalta Conference took place in 1945, as the Second World War was ending. As broader historical context, the meeting brought together the leaders of the United States, Britain and the Soviet Union to discuss the postwar settlement. The article’s account stresses that Europe was “divided up” and “parcelled up” at Yalta, a description Merz used to reject any repeat.

The conference is compared with the later division of Europe into zones of influence and rival political blocs. The article says Yalta set the stage for the four-decade-long Cold War. That framing connects the conference not just to wartime diplomacy, but to a long period in which Europe’s security and political future were shaped by competing powers.

The comparison arose after Trump, Putin and Xi met in China and discussed Ukraine. European leaders rejected the idea of decisions about Ukraine or European security being made without those concerned. Macron said Europe should determine its own fate, while Merz said the security debate would follow the establishment of peace in Ukraine.

06

Why do Ukraine and its allies argue that Ukraine must have a seat in negotiations about its future?

Ukraine’s case for a seat is direct: the negotiations concern its future, its war and the security guarantees being considered for it. At the Berlin meeting, leaders rejected decisions about Ukraine being made without Ukraine in the room. Burnham stated the principle plainly, and Zelenskyy said the meeting showed Russia had failed to divide Ukraine’s European allies.

The concern was sharpened by the talks in Shenzhen between Trump, Putin and Xi. They discussed Ukraine, yet their joint “Declaration Toward Peace” did not mention the country. Macron said negotiations to end the war would need Ukraine, Europe, the United States and Russia seated at the same table. That includes the country whose future is being negotiated.

The article describes this as an agreed position among the four leaders, while Russia has not committed to a multilateral format. Putin said the Kremlin would decide whether to continue dialogue with Ukraine after Europeans came to Moscow to define their positions. Meanwhile, European leaders said support for Ukraine would continue to strengthen its position at the negotiating table.

07

What are “spheres of influence,” and how can powerful countries use them to shape other countries’ choices?

In general historical and political usage, a sphere of influence is an area where a powerful country has, or seeks, special sway over other countries’ decisions. That sway can involve security, politics or foreign relations. It does not necessarily mean formal control, but it can limit how freely another country chooses its alliances or policies. The article uses the idea in the context of Europe’s possible division by outside powers.

The comparison comes from Yalta, which Merz described as Europe being “divided up” and “parcelled up.” Commentators called the Shenzhen meeting between Trump, Putin and Xi “Yalta 2.0.” The three discussed Ukraine, but their joint statement did not mention it. European leaders rejected any approach that would decide Ukraine’s future without Ukraine involved.

The Berlin meeting instead emphasized that Europe would determine its own fate and that Ukraine and Europe must be represented in relevant negotiations. The article says Europe appointed a seven-member team for the next talks, while Moscow had not committed to a multilateral format. It does not establish that a new division into spheres has occurred.

This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.

Read more in the JupiteX app

Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.

Or read more news on the web