JupiteX Get the app
Politics & Governance20 Nov 2026 · about 7 min

MP High Court pulls up state government for using AI to cite non-existent Supreme Court judgment

The brief

The High Court found a fabricated case name attached to a real citation in the state government’s legal reply. The error mattered because courts rely on accurate legal authorities, and an invented judgment can mislead a court or waste its time. The bench called the drafting callous and irresponsible. The state had cited “State of Andhra Pradesh vs S.S. Mohammad Nisar,” reported as (2008) 5 SCC 230. The court said no such judgment exists. That citation belongs to Sidhartha Vashisht alias Manu Sharma vs State (NCT of Delhi), a case about suspension of sentence in a criminal appeal, unrelated to the sub-inspector’s petition. The court said the mismatch appeared to result from the state blindly using AI tools to draft its pleadings. It warned the state machinery against inserting unverified case law and said the Advocate General’s office must check legal propositions and citations before filing them. The court did not decide the merits of the harassment allegations.

01

What non-existent Supreme Court judgment did the state cite, and which real case did that citation actually belong to?

The High Court found a fabricated case name attached to a real citation in the state government’s legal reply. The error mattered because courts rely on accurate legal authorities, and an invented judgment can mislead a court or waste its time. The bench called the drafting callous and irresponsible.

The state had cited “State of Andhra Pradesh vs S.S. Mohammad Nisar,” reported as (2008) 5 SCC 230. The court said no such judgment exists. That citation belongs to Sidhartha Vashisht alias Manu Sharma vs State (NCT of Delhi), a case about suspension of sentence in a criminal appeal, unrelated to the sub-inspector’s petition.

The court said the mismatch appeared to result from the state blindly using AI tools to draft its pleadings. It warned the state machinery against inserting unverified case law and said the Advocate General’s office must check legal propositions and citations before filing them. The court did not decide the merits of the harassment allegations.

02

What is an AI hallucination, and how can it lead to a made-up case appearing in a legal document?

An AI hallucination is an output that presents false or unsupported information as though it were factual. The term describes a possible error, not proof of exactly how a particular system produced it. The article reports that the High Court attributed the pleading’s error to the state having blindly resorted to AI tools.

In this case, the state’s reply named “State of Andhra Pradesh vs S.S. Mohammad Nisar” and attached a real law-report citation. The court said the named judgment did not exist and that the citation actually belonged to Sidhartha Vashisht alias Manu Sharma vs State (NCT of Delhi), a different case about suspension of sentence in a criminal appeal. This illustrates how a plausible-looking citation can conceal a false match.

The court stressed that legal citations must be checked before being filed. It said fictitious authorities waste judicial time and can border on actively misleading the court. It directed the Advocate General’s office to ensure legal propositions and citations are meticulously verified. The article does not identify the particular AI tool or explain the exact process that generated the mistake.

03

How quickly was the sub-inspector dismissed, and what normal process did the state skip?

The sub-inspector was accused of indecent behaviour with a woman cleaner at the state situation room in Bhopal. The High Court focused on the process used to dismiss him, not on whether the accusation was true. It held that the state could not bypass the required constitutional process on the justification it gave.

The complaint was lodged over alleged conduct on May 26, 2024. The sub-inspector was suspended that same day and dismissed on May 27, within 24 hours, without a departmental inquiry. The state relied on Article 311(2)(b), which permits an inquiry to be dispensed with in exceptional circumstances. The court found that the state’s justification for using that exception was unsustainable in law.

The High Court quashed the dismissal and directed the government to reinstate him forthwith. It also allowed the state to conduct a regular departmental inquiry in accordance with law. The court expressly gave no opinion on the merits of the allegations. So the ruling addressed the dismissal process, while leaving the state able to pursue a proper inquiry.

04

What did the High Court order, and what action may the government still take?

The High Court ruled that the state could not use its stated reason to avoid a departmental inquiry before dismissing the sub-inspector. It quashed the dismissal because the state’s reliance on Article 311(2)(b) was unsustainable in law. The decision concerned the procedure followed, not whether the sexual harassment allegations were true.

The sub-inspector had been suspended on the day the complaint was lodged and dismissed the following day, without a departmental inquiry. The bench directed the government to reinstate him forthwith. At the same time, it expressly gave the government liberty to hold a regular departmental inquiry in accordance with law. That means the dismissal was set aside, but the state was not barred from pursuing a proper inquiry.

The court expressed no opinion on the merits of the allegations against him. Its ruling therefore does not clear him of the accusation or decide the complainant’s account. The immediate consequence is reinstatement; any further disciplinary action would need to follow the regular inquiry process. The court’s finding also underscores that the exception the state invoked cannot be used without a legally sustainable justification.

05

What does Article 311(2)(b) allow the government to do, and under what exceptional circumstances?

Article 311(2)(b) is an exception to the usual inquiry process for certain government employees facing dismissal, removal or reduction in rank. In general constitutional law, it applies when the authority empowered to dismiss or remove the employee is satisfied that holding an inquiry is not reasonably practicable. The article itself describes the provision as allowing inquiries to be dispensed with in exceptional circumstances.

The Madhya Pradesh government relied on this provision to dismiss a police sub-inspector without a departmental inquiry. The High Court held that the state’s justification for invoking it was unsustainable in law. The sub-inspector had been suspended on the day of the complaint and dismissed the next day. The court quashed the dismissal, while allowing a fresh, regular inquiry in accordance with law.

The exception does not mean that an authority can skip an inquiry simply because it chooses to. Its use depends on the constitutional condition being met and the decision being legally supportable. In this case, the High Court rejected the state’s justification but did not rule on the merits of the allegations. The government can still pursue the matter through a proper departmental inquiry.

06

Why are government employees ordinarily entitled to a departmental inquiry before being dismissed?

Government employees are ordinarily entitled to an inquiry before dismissal, removal or reduction in rank because these are serious service penalties. The inquiry provides a formal process to hear the allegations and give the employee an opportunity to respond. Article 311 of the Constitution sets out protections against such action, while also providing limited exceptions.

The article’s case shows why process matters. The sub-inspector was dismissed on May 27, the day after being suspended, without a departmental inquiry. The state invoked Article 311(2)(b), but the High Court held that its justification for dispensing with an inquiry was unsustainable in law. It quashed the dismissal and allowed a regular inquiry to be held in accordance with law.

The ruling did not decide whether the allegation of indecent behaviour was true. Instead, it required the state to follow a lawful process if it wished to pursue disciplinary action. In general, the constitutional protection is not absolute: specified exceptional circumstances can permit an inquiry to be dispensed with. The article does not set out all those circumstances, but it makes clear that the state’s reliance on the exception in this case failed.

07

What power does Article 226 give High Courts to review decisions made by government authorities?

Article 226 gives High Courts constitutional power to issue writs, directions or orders to authorities within their jurisdiction. In general legal terms, this power enables a court to review whether a government decision was lawful and whether required procedures were followed. It is not ordinarily a full appeal that simply reweighs every fact.

The state’s reply in this case argued that reappreciation of evidence is impermissible under Article 226. To support that point, government counsel cited a purported Supreme Court judgment that the High Court said did not exist. The citation instead belonged to an unrelated criminal appeal. The High Court went on to quash the sub-inspector’s dismissal because the state had not justified bypassing a departmental inquiry under Article 311(2)(b).

The court directed the sub-inspector’s reinstatement and allowed the government to conduct a regular inquiry in accordance with law. It did not decide the merits of the allegations. The case shows Article 226’s role in reviewing official action and procedure, while leaving the state able to make a fresh decision through a lawful process. The article does not give a wider account of the limits of Article 226 review.

This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.

Read more in the JupiteX app

Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.

Or read more news on the web