World is being ‘held hostage by oil mafia’: How one tiny country is putting its foot down at COP31
Panama has threatened to block a final COP31 deal that does not meet its demands. It wants an outcome that includes a cap on oil production and a strong defence of science. Its warning matters because COP agreements are adopted by consensus, so objections can prevent a deal from being agreed. In a letter to the summit’s hosts, Panama’s environment minister, Juan Carlos Navarro, said the country would not join consensus and would formally object in the closing plenaries. He also said Panama would not lend its name to complacent or ineffective language in the final pact. These are the steps Panama says it will take if the outcome is unsatisfactory. The draft published by co-host Australia removed all mentions of fossil fuels, prompting backlash. Panama’s threat adds pressure as talks enter their final day and divisions deepen. Whether the final text changes remains uncertain. The article reports that the summit may overrun into the weekend, and COP decisions depend on agreement among nearly 200 nations.
What has Panama threatened to do if the COP31 deal lacks an oil-production cap and a strong defence of science?
Panama has threatened to block a final COP31 deal that does not meet its demands. It wants an outcome that includes a cap on oil production and a strong defence of science. Its warning matters because COP agreements are adopted by consensus, so objections can prevent a deal from being agreed.
In a letter to the summit’s hosts, Panama’s environment minister, Juan Carlos Navarro, said the country would not join consensus and would formally object in the closing plenaries. He also said Panama would not lend its name to complacent or ineffective language in the final pact. These are the steps Panama says it will take if the outcome is unsatisfactory.
The draft published by co-host Australia removed all mentions of fossil fuels, prompting backlash. Panama’s threat adds pressure as talks enter their final day and divisions deepen. Whether the final text changes remains uncertain. The article reports that the summit may overrun into the weekend, and COP decisions depend on agreement among nearly 200 nations.
How can one country block a COP agreement when nearly 200 nations are taking part?
COP agreements require consensus, meaning the parties must agree before a final decision can be adopted. That gives each participating country a way to stop a deal from being approved if it formally objects. With nearly 200 nations involved, reaching agreement can be slow and difficult. A country’s objection can therefore matter even when many others support the text.
Panama has said it will not join consensus on a final COP31 decision it finds unsatisfactory. Environment Minister Juan Carlos Navarro said Panama would formally object in the closing plenaries if the deal lacks an outcome aligned with its principles and values. The country is pressing for an oil-production cap and a strong defence of science.
The draft deal from co-host Australia removed all mentions of fossil fuels, which triggered heavy backlash. The summit’s final text is still being negotiated, and the talks may continue into the weekend. Panama’s threat does not guarantee the deal will fail, but it shows how consensus rules give objections real weight in negotiations.
How many countries and other parties need to agree for a COP deal to reach consensus?
The article says COP agreements require consensus from all parties, which it describes as almost 200 nations. In other words, the final deal needs agreement across the participating nations rather than support from only a majority. This requirement makes negotiations complex and can slow progress.
The article gives Panama as a current example. The country has threatened not to join consensus and to formally object in the closing plenaries if the final decision does not satisfy its principles and values. Panama is seeking a cap on oil production and a strong defence of science. Its position matters because consensus gives an objection the power to hold up adoption.
The talks are in their final day, but divisions remain over whether fossil fuels should appear in the deal. Australia’s latest draft removed all mentions of them. The article does not give a precise total beyond “almost 200 nations,” so that is the clearest stated measure of how broad agreement must be.
What does “transition away from fossil fuels” mean?
“Transition away from fossil fuels” means moving away from reliance on coal, oil and gas. The article describes these fuels as the leading driver of climate change and says countries are preparing exit strategies. The phrase is important because governments are debating whether a global agreement should set out this shift.
The article points to national roadmaps as one example of what the transition can involve. France, Germany and the Netherlands published plans to get away from coal, oil and gas before COP31. Denmark, Portugal, Luxembourg and Spain later announced their own national plans. These roadmaps are a way for countries to set out their intended shift beyond the contested wording of a UN pact.
At COP28 in Dubai in 2023, nations agreed to transition away from fossil fuels. But language about energy sources remains highly contested at yearly climate talks. The latest COP31 draft removed all mentions of fossil fuels, while some countries continue to pursue roadmaps outside the UN process. The article does not specify every measure or timetable in those national plans.
What could be the consequence of leaving fossil fuels out of the final COP31 deal?
Fossil fuels are central to the COP31 dispute because the article identifies them as the leading driver of climate change. The latest draft deal removed all mentions of them, despite growing momentum for an exit strategy. Critics warn that a final pact without this issue may fail to show progress on the climate crisis.
Mohamed Adow, director of Power Shift Africa, said the summit would have nothing to show for what happened if the text remained silent on fossil fuels. He contrasted the draft with COP28 in Dubai in 2023, where fossil fuels were mentioned for the first time. WWF’s Inga Fritzen Buan said some producers were succeeding in undermining emissions cuts and the energy transition.
Experts described the risk as a “ghost COP,” meaning a summit with little to show on the issue they consider most important. The final decision had not yet been settled in the article. Talks were in their final day, and the summit might overrun into the weekend as countries continued negotiations.
What are countries doing outside the COP deal to plan their shift away from coal, oil and gas?
Some governments are preparing their own plans to move away from coal, oil and gas, rather than relying only on the wording of a COP agreement. These national roadmaps are one way countries can pursue the transition while language about energy sources remains contested in UN climate talks.
Before COP31, France, Germany and the Netherlands published roadmaps to get away from coal, oil and gas. Finland affirmed its commitment to the transition on 11 November. On 17 November, Denmark, Portugal, Luxembourg and Spain announced national plans. The article links this wider activity to the first transition-away-from-fossil-fuels conference, held in Santa Marta, Colombia, in April.
Germany’s Heike Henn said the ultimate measure of success was action and a growing coalition, not simply having the transition written into a COP cover decision. These plans do not resolve the dispute over the final COP31 text, which removed fossil fuel references. But they show that some countries are pursuing exit strategies outside the UN process as negotiations continue.
How does burning coal, oil and gas contribute to global warming?
The article identifies fossil fuels—coal, oil and gas—as the leading driver of climate change, but it does not explain the physical mechanism. Established climate science explains that burning these fuels releases carbon dioxide, a heat-trapping greenhouse gas. As carbon dioxide builds up in the atmosphere, it strengthens the greenhouse effect and contributes to global warming.
That mechanism helps explain why the COP31 draft’s removal of fossil fuel references drew criticism. The article says momentum had been growing for an exit strategy, while some nations resisted language on the energy transition. Panama is pressing for an oil-production cap, and several European countries have published roadmaps to get away from coal, oil and gas.
The final COP31 text was still under discussion, and the article reports deep divisions among nations. The draft included a call to raise electricity’s share of final energy demand to 35 per cent by 2035, but did not explicitly require that extra electricity to come from clean sources. The source does not detail the emissions from each fuel or quantify their warming effects.
This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.
Read more in the JupiteX app
Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.
Or read more news on the web