How nature-based solutions are failing informal settlements
A project may be described as community-led or co-designed but still fail to benefit settlement residents. The researchers say some initiatives start with ideas and priorities formed outside the communities they are meant to serve. Consultation alone does not correct this if residents cannot shape decisions or challenge existing power imbalances. The gap matters because residents’ priorities are not uniform. In Khayelitsha, some people living near rivers and wetlands urgently want flood protection, while others want space for vegetable gardens or places for children to play. External experts and officials may have different goals, such as restoring a wetland or constructing concrete drains. The authors argue that without inclusive deliberation, trade-offs can stay hidden and outside technical priorities can dominate. They recommend moving from short-term consultation to long-term partnerships with shared decision-making. That requires funding and support for local leaders and community facilitators to discuss trade-offs, mediate conflict and build collaboration.
Why can nature-based solutions fail to benefit people in informal settlements, even when projects are described as community-led?
A project may be described as community-led or co-designed but still fail to benefit settlement residents. The researchers say some initiatives start with ideas and priorities formed outside the communities they are meant to serve. Consultation alone does not correct this if residents cannot shape decisions or challenge existing power imbalances.
The gap matters because residents’ priorities are not uniform. In Khayelitsha, some people living near rivers and wetlands urgently want flood protection, while others want space for vegetable gardens or places for children to play. External experts and officials may have different goals, such as restoring a wetland or constructing concrete drains.
The authors argue that without inclusive deliberation, trade-offs can stay hidden and outside technical priorities can dominate. They recommend moving from short-term consultation to long-term partnerships with shared decision-making. That requires funding and support for local leaders and community facilitators to discuss trade-offs, mediate conflict and build collaboration.
What are nature-based solutions, and what are some examples used to reduce climate risks in cities?
Nature-based solutions, or NbS, are approaches that work with nature as part of responding to climate risks. In the article, they are presented as adaptation options for cities facing increasing flood risks as climate change intensifies. The researchers stress that these projects also affect how people use and relate to land and water.
The examples named are urban wetlands, community food gardens, and sustainable urban drainage systems. They are increasingly promoted for urban informal settlements. But residents may want different things from the same place: some need flood protection, while others value land for growing vegetables or for children to play.
The article’s central point is that a solution’s label does not ensure it is fair or useful. Projects may bypass residents’ lived experiences and priorities, even when described as co-designed. The authors urge decision-makers to include local knowledge and share power, so adaptation choices reflect competing needs rather than only external plans.
How many African cities did the Tuwe Pamoja project study, and which one is named in the article?
The Tuwe Pamoja project was carried out across four African cities. The article names Cape Town as one of them. Researchers Petra Holden and Gina Ziervogel draw on the project to examine challenges and opportunities for using nature-based solutions to support just climate adaptation.
Their discussion includes Khayelitsha, an informal settlement in Cape Town. Residents there live along vulnerable river and wetland edges, and some accept serious flood risks simply to secure a place to live. The example shows why decisions about wetlands and flood protection cannot be treated as purely technical choices.
The article does not name the other three cities or provide a separate comparison among all four. Instead, the Khayelitsha example illustrates the competing claims residents, experts, and officials may have. The researchers call for fair deliberation, local voices, and shared decision-making when planners and funders consider NbS in informal settlements.
Why might people living near the same wetland want different things from it?
People living near the same wetland do not necessarily experience it in the same way. Their needs, values, and circumstances can differ, so they may disagree about what should happen to the land and water. The researchers say those competing claims need to be recognized when decisions are made.
In Khayelitsha, residents live along vulnerable river and wetland edges, accepting severe flood risks to secure a place to live. Some residents want flood protection urgently. Others want space for vegetable gardens or places for children to play. Experts and officials can also disagree, for example about wetland restoration versus concrete drains.
These differences mean there is no single local preference that planners can assume. The authors call for inclusive deliberation that brings together scientific approaches and residents’ lived experiences, values, and cultural relationships with nature. They argue that power-sensitive partnerships can help people discuss trade-offs and make decisions together, rather than allowing one group’s priorities to dominate.
What can happen when decisions about flood protection are made without residents sharing power?
When residents do not share power in decisions, important trade-offs can remain invisible. The article describes officials debating whether to use concrete or nature-based flood protection to protect settlements or neighboring suburbs. Those choices can have major consequences for people living in the area.
In the Khayelitsha example, residents already face pressure along vulnerable river and wetland edges. The authors note that flood protection plans could mean bulldozing homes and relocating families. Without inclusive deliberation, external technocratic priorities may dominate, even when residents have different needs or ways of relating to the wetland.
The researchers argue that consultation by itself is not enough to address these power imbalances. They call for long-term partnerships where residents participate in shared decision-making and can deliberate on competing claims. Funding should also support local leaders and community facilitators to mediate conflict and enable meaningful collaboration. This approach is intended to make adaptation fairer, though the article does not claim it removes every difficult trade-off.
What three approaches do the researchers recommend for making nature-based solutions fairer?
The researchers outline three pathways for making nature-based solutions support just climate adaptation. The first is distributive justice: acknowledging competing claims over land and water so people can deliberate fairly about possible solutions. This matters because residents and decision-makers may want different things from the same place.
The second pathway is power-sensitive partnerships. Rather than relying on short-term, externally led consultations, these partnerships build trust over time and share decision-making. The authors say funding and incentives should support government and provide resources for local leaders and community facilitators to discuss trade-offs, mediate conflict, and build collaboration.
The third is care-full pluralism, which means recognizing multiple ways of knowing. Decision-makers should connect scientific approaches with residents’ lived experiences, values, and cultural relationships with nature. The article presents these pathways as a call to action for planners, policymakers, and climate funders. Together, they aim to prevent technical priorities from overriding vulnerable communities’ needs.
How can wetlands and other natural landscapes help reduce flooding in cities?
The article identifies urban wetlands as one nature-based solution promoted for climate adaptation in cities facing increasing flood risks. It focuses mainly on how decisions about these landscapes affect residents, rather than detailing the physical processes that reduce flooding. It also notes that experts may favor restoring a wetland to its fully natural historical state.
As general background beyond the article, wetlands can help manage floodwater by holding water and slowing its movement. This can reduce the amount of water moving through an area at once. The article does not quantify this effect or explain how it varies by wetland, so the precise benefit depends on local conditions.
The researchers’ main concern is that flood-reduction plans must also account for people and competing uses of land. In Khayelitsha, residents face flood risks but may also seek gardens or play areas. The authors recommend fair deliberation and shared power so that wetland decisions consider both climate adaptation and residents’ lived experiences.
This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.
Read more in the JupiteX app
Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.
Or read more news on the web