JupiteX Get the app
Politics & Governance20 Nov 2026 · about 8 min

SC to hear in January pleas seeking review of 2022 verdict upholding ED's powers

The brief

The Supreme Court said it would hear review petitions in January. They challenge its July 2022 verdict upholding certain Enforcement Directorate powers under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, or PMLA. That ruling matters because it approved important powers used in money-laundering investigations, including arrest and property attachment. A bench led by Chief Justice Surya Kant, with Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana, set the hearing after lawyers asked for an early date. The petitions seek reconsideration of the 2022 judgment, which arose from more than 200 petitions challenging PMLA provisions. The Court previously said it would consider whether the review petitions could be heard before examining their proposed questions. The January date will be notified, but the article does not give a specific day. Nor does it report that the Court has agreed to change its earlier ruling. The next stated step is a hearing, beginning with maintainability. If the petitions pass that stage, the Court would then consider the questions raised by the review petitioners.

01

What has the Supreme Court scheduled for January, and which 2022 ruling are the petitions asking it to reconsider?

The Supreme Court said it would hear review petitions in January. They challenge its July 2022 verdict upholding certain Enforcement Directorate powers under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, or PMLA. That ruling matters because it approved important powers used in money-laundering investigations, including arrest and property attachment.

A bench led by Chief Justice Surya Kant, with Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana, set the hearing after lawyers asked for an early date. The petitions seek reconsideration of the 2022 judgment, which arose from more than 200 petitions challenging PMLA provisions. The Court previously said it would consider whether the review petitions could be heard before examining their proposed questions.

The January date will be notified, but the article does not give a specific day. Nor does it report that the Court has agreed to change its earlier ruling. The next stated step is a hearing, beginning with maintainability. If the petitions pass that stage, the Court would then consider the questions raised by the review petitioners.

02

What does it mean for a court to review its own judgment, and what does it mean to ask whether a review petition is maintainable?

In general legal usage, a review is a request asking the court that issued a judgment to reconsider it. It is different from a fresh appeal to a higher court. Review is usually a limited process, not an automatic second chance to argue every point. The article reports that petitioners are asking the Supreme Court to review its 2022 PMLA judgment.

Before considering the substance of a review request, a court may decide whether the petition is maintainable. That means asking whether it is legally fit to be heard and whether procedural or other threshold requirements are met. The question is not yet whether the earlier judgment was right or wrong; it is whether the review process can proceed.

That distinction is central here. The Supreme Court previously said it would hear the parties on maintainability first, and only then consider the questions proposed by the review petitioners. The article reports that the ED proposed three preliminary issues about maintainability, while the petitioners proposed 13 questions. The Court has scheduled the matter for January, but has not reported a decision on either stage.

03

Which two issues did the Court previously say it would consider first: access to the ECIR and the burden of proof under Section 24?

The two issues named by Solicitor General Tushar Mehta concerned information given to an accused and the burden of proof. He said the bench that considered the review petitions for admission in August 2022 had issued notices only on those aspects. The distinction matters because the Centre argued that the review hearing should stay within that scope.

One issue was whether a copy of the Enforcement Case Information Report, or ECIR, must be supplied to the accused. The other was the reversal of the burden of proof under Section 24 of the PMLA. The article does not detail how Section 24 operates; it identifies the reversal of the burden as one of the questions raised. The 2022 judgment had said an ECIR need not be supplied in every case if the grounds for arrest are disclosed.

Separately, the Supreme Court had said it would first hear parties on maintainability, then consider questions proposed by the review petitioners. The ED had proposed three preliminary maintainability issues, and petitioners proposed 13 questions. The January hearing is scheduled, but the article does not report a decision resolving the scope dispute.

04

What powers did the 2022 verdict uphold for the Enforcement Directorate under the PMLA?

The Enforcement Directorate’s powers under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act were at the heart of the 2022 judgment. The Supreme Court upheld the ED’s authority to arrest people, attach properties involved in money laundering, and carry out search and seizure under the law. These powers matter because they allow the agency to act during money-laundering investigations.

The Court also addressed procedure. It said authorities under the 2002 law were “not police officers as such” and that an ECIR could not be equated with an FIR under the Code of Criminal Procedure. It said supplying an ECIR copy in every case was not mandatory, provided the ED disclosed the grounds for arrest at the time of arrest. The Court also upheld Section 45’s twin conditions for bail.

Those positions are the subject of review petitions now scheduled for a January hearing. The article does not say the Court has changed or suspended the 2022 ruling. It says the Court previously intended to hear maintainability first, before considering questions proposed by the review petitioners. The date in January is to be notified.

05

How many petitions challenged provisions of the PMLA in the case that led to the 2022 verdict?

The 2022 Supreme Court verdict came in a batch of more than 200 petitions challenging various provisions of the Prevention of Money Laundering Act. That scale shows the ruling addressed a broad legal challenge, rather than a single individual case. The petitions questioned the powers and procedures established under the law.

The Court upheld the ED’s powers to arrest, attach properties involved in money laundering, and carry out searches and seizures. It also upheld certain PMLA provisions, including Section 45’s twin conditions for bail. The Court described money laundering as a threat to the proper functioning of financial systems worldwide and said it was not an ordinary offence.

Some petitioners are now asking the Supreme Court to review that judgment. The article gives no exact petition count, only “more than 200.” The review matters because it concerns a judgment that resolved challenges across multiple PMLA provisions. The Court has scheduled a January hearing, with maintainability to be addressed before the proposed questions, according to its earlier stated approach.

06

If the Court changes or overturns parts of its 2022 ruling, how could that affect the ED’s ability to arrest people or seize and attach property?

The 2022 judgment upheld the ED’s powers to arrest, attach property involved in money laundering, and conduct searches and seizures under the PMLA. If the Supreme Court later altered or overturned relevant parts of that judgment, the legal rules supporting those powers could be different. That is a conditional consequence, not an outcome reported in the article.

For example, a change to the ruling on arrest or property attachment could affect the authority the ED relies on when using those measures under the PMLA. The review petitions also raise issues about ECIR access and the reversal of the burden of proof under Section 24. The article does not say that the Court will accept those arguments or explain what any change would cover.

At present, the article reports that the Court has set a January hearing and previously planned to address maintainability first. It does not report that the 2022 judgment has been paused, changed, or overturned. Any practical effect would depend on the Court’s eventual decision and its terms, neither of which is stated in the article.

07

What does reversing the burden of proof mean, and how does it differ from the usual idea that the prosecution must prove a person’s guilt?

In the usual criminal-law understanding, the prosecution must prove the charge against a person. A reversal or shift of the burden means that the law may require the accused to establish a specified fact or answer a particular presumption. The exact effect depends on the wording of the relevant law; a shift on one issue does not automatically mean that every part of the case is treated the same way.

Here, the article identifies the reversal of the burden of proof under Section 24 of the PMLA as one of two issues raised in the review proceedings. It does not explain the section’s detailed operation or specify which facts an accused would need to prove. The 2022 verdict upheld certain PMLA provisions, and the review petitioners now seek reconsideration.

The Centre argued that the review hearing should not go beyond the two aspects on which notices were issued: ECIR supply and Section 24’s burden-of-proof issue. The Supreme Court has said it would hear maintainability first, then the proposed questions. Its January hearing is scheduled, but no outcome on the burden of proof is reported.

This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.

Read more in the JupiteX app

Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.

Or read more news on the web