Exclusive: UAE's Nusseibeh lobbied UK's Iain Duncan Smith over UN candidacy
Duncan Smith said the UAE’s alleged role in Sudan’s war and Nusseibeh’s impartiality were central issues. He had called in Parliament for the UK to use its Security Council veto against her candidacy, arguing that the UAE sponsored terrorism in Sudan. Abu Dhabi denies supporting the RSF. At their meeting, he repeated that the UAE should “cease and desist” from involvement in the war. He also called for the release of Ryan Cornelius and Charles Ridley, two British citizens detained in Dubai for almost 20 years. Duncan Smith said Nusseibeh did not deny UAE involvement, but told him she wanted to act independently. He replied that her foreign ministry role meant she was not seen as impartial. Nusseibeh’s campaign said she was meeting a wide range of stakeholders and had taken leave from her ministerial role after her nomination. The meeting highlights how allegations about the UAE could affect her bid to become UN secretary-general. The article reports that eight candidates are competing for the post.
What issues did Iain Duncan Smith raise with Lana Nusseibeh when he met her about her UN candidacy?
Duncan Smith said the UAE’s alleged role in Sudan’s war and Nusseibeh’s impartiality were central issues. He had called in Parliament for the UK to use its Security Council veto against her candidacy, arguing that the UAE sponsored terrorism in Sudan. Abu Dhabi denies supporting the RSF.
At their meeting, he repeated that the UAE should “cease and desist” from involvement in the war. He also called for the release of Ryan Cornelius and Charles Ridley, two British citizens detained in Dubai for almost 20 years. Duncan Smith said Nusseibeh did not deny UAE involvement, but told him she wanted to act independently. He replied that her foreign ministry role meant she was not seen as impartial.
Nusseibeh’s campaign said she was meeting a wide range of stakeholders and had taken leave from her ministerial role after her nomination. The meeting highlights how allegations about the UAE could affect her bid to become UN secretary-general. The article reports that eight candidates are competing for the post.
What does it mean to lobby someone over a political candidacy?
To lobby someone over a political candidacy is to try to influence their view or actions about a person seeking office. That might mean asking for support, answering objections, or seeking to prevent opposition. It is a form of political persuasion, not itself a formal vote or appointment.
The article describes Lana Nusseibeh visiting Iain Duncan Smith at his office in Parliament while seeking the UN secretary-general post. Duncan Smith had called for the UK to use its Security Council veto to block her nomination, citing the UAE’s alleged involvement in Sudan. He said he raised Sudan and two detained British citizens with her. Her campaign said she was meeting a wide range of stakeholders but would not comment on the meeting’s content.
The meeting therefore fits the broad meaning of lobbying: a candidate or representative engages an influential person amid a contested decision. The article does not establish precisely what Nusseibeh asked Duncan Smith to do. It does report her stated commitment to an independent campaign and that she had taken leave from her ministerial role.
How is the UN secretary-general chosen, and what role does the Security Council play?
The Security Council is the decisive gatekeeper in the selection process described in the article. It conducts an informal straw poll, in which members indicate whether they encourage, discourage, or have no opinion about a candidate. A candidate needs nine approving votes from the Council’s 15 members and must avoid a disapproving vote from any of its five permanent members.
Those permanent members are the UK, US, Russia, France, and China. Each has veto power, so their opposition can block a candidate from advancing. The straw poll itself is informal and anonymous; it is not the final appointment vote. The article says the next poll was expected on Friday after being postponed from Thursday.
The article does not describe the final appointment stage. Under standard UN procedure, the Security Council recommends a candidate and the General Assembly appoints the secretary-general. This means a candidate must first clear the Council’s political hurdle before the wider membership completes the appointment. The article gives no result for the expected poll.
How many candidates are in the race, and how many Security Council members must approve a candidate?
The article reports eight candidates in the race to succeed Antonio Guterres as UN secretary-general. The Council has 15 members, and a candidate needs at least nine “approve” votes to meet the threshold described in the report. That number is a key measure of whether a candidate has enough support to proceed.
Votes are not the only hurdle. The five permanent members—the UK, US, Russia, France, and China—each have a veto. The article says a candidate must ensure that none of the “disapprove” votes comes from one of those five. So support from nine members alone would not overcome opposition from a permanent member.
The next step mentioned in the article was an informal, anonymous straw poll, expected Friday after being postponed from Thursday. In it, Security Council members indicate whether they encourage, discourage, or have no opinion about each candidate. The report does not give a poll result, so it does not say which candidate was leading or whether anyone had secured the required support.
What happens to a candidate if one of the five permanent Security Council members votes against them?
The five permanent members of the Security Council are the UK, US, Russia, France, and China. Each holds a veto. In the selection process described, a candidate must avoid disapproval from any of these members, even while seeking nine approving votes from the full 15-member Council. A permanent member’s opposition can therefore stop a candidate from advancing.
The article describes an anonymous straw poll where members mark “encourage,” “discourage,” or “no opinion.” That poll is informal, not the formal decision itself. A “disapprove” response in a straw poll signals a problem, but it is not identical to casting a formal veto in a Council vote. Duncan Smith urged the UK to use its veto against Nusseibeh’s nomination.
Under standard UN procedure, the Security Council must recommend a secretary-general candidate before the General Assembly appoints one. A veto can prevent that recommendation. The article gives no outcome of the next straw poll or of any formal vote, so it does not establish whether any candidate has been blocked.
What are the RSF and Sudanese Armed Forces, and how does their war connect to the allegations against the UAE?
The Rapid Support Forces, or RSF, are a paramilitary force in Sudan. The Sudanese Armed Forces, or SAF, are the opposing armed force in a war that has been underway since April 2023. The article says the RSF was found by the UN and US to have committed genocide in Darfur.
The UAE’s alleged support for the RSF connects the conflict to Nusseibeh’s candidacy because she is an Emirati diplomat seeking to lead the UN. The article says UN Panel of Experts reports confirmed that the UAE supplied the RSF with weapons and mercenaries. Nusseibeh previously dismissed findings from Panel reports and lobbied European Parliament members to remove the UAE’s name from a resolution on Sudan.
The UAE denies supporting the RSF. The SAF, meanwhile, receives military backing from Turkey and Egypt, according to the article. The allegations have become a source of controversy around Nusseibeh’s bid, and Duncan Smith said her Emirati foreign ministry role meant she was not impartial. The article does not report any resolution of the competing claims.
How can investment and economic ties give a country diplomatic influence beyond its size?
Economic ties can give a country diplomatic influence when another government wants its investment, trade, or financial partnership. Such ties may make officials weigh diplomatic disputes against possible economic costs. This is a general explanation of how influence can work; the article does not detail particular UK investment deals or prove that they shaped a decision.
The article does include Duncan Smith’s claim about the UK Treasury. He said it was “panic stricken” that a wealthy country would not invest in the UK. His remark suggests that he believed concern about investment could affect how the British government approached the UAE. It is presented as his view, not as an independently established finding in the report.
The article links that concern to the wider dispute over Sudan and Nusseibeh’s UN candidacy, but does not say investment altered the UK’s position or that officials made a specific decision for economic reasons. The broader implication is that economic interests can complicate diplomatic choices. Establishing whether they actually influence policy would require evidence beyond the quote included here.
This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.
Read more in the JupiteX app
Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.
Or read more news on the web