Cop31 draft agreement ‘the worst ever', campaigners warn
The latest COP31 draft removes a direct commitment to transition away from fossil fuels. Instead, it calls for an irreversible global transition towards low greenhouse gas emissions and climate resilience. That change matters because campaigners say the weaker wording does not require countries to phase out fossil fuels. The draft also omits several finance commitments. An earlier version included a $120bn target for helping developing countries adapt, but that was removed. The final text also has no mention of Article 9.1, which requires developed countries to provide financial resources for mitigation and adaptation. A reference to tripling climate adaptation finance by 2035, agreed the previous year at Belem, was removed from an earlier draft, as was mention of developed countries’ historical responsibility. Campaigners say these omissions weaken support for countries facing climate impacts. The final text also backs expanding carbon capture technologies, rather than restoring the dropped phase-out commitment.
What commitments on fossil fuels and climate finance were removed or weakened in the latest COP31 draft?
The latest COP31 draft removes a direct commitment to transition away from fossil fuels. Instead, it calls for an irreversible global transition towards low greenhouse gas emissions and climate resilience. That change matters because campaigners say the weaker wording does not require countries to phase out fossil fuels.
The draft also omits several finance commitments. An earlier version included a $120bn target for helping developing countries adapt, but that was removed. The final text also has no mention of Article 9.1, which requires developed countries to provide financial resources for mitigation and adaptation.
A reference to tripling climate adaptation finance by 2035, agreed the previous year at Belem, was removed from an earlier draft, as was mention of developed countries’ historical responsibility. Campaigners say these omissions weaken support for countries facing climate impacts. The final text also backs expanding carbon capture technologies, rather than restoring the dropped phase-out commitment.
Which countries or groups does the article say pushed to weaken the fossil-fuel language and climate-finance commitments?
The article identifies different actors in the disputes over fossil fuels and finance. Saudi Arabia is described as one of the main blockers of references to phasing out fossil fuels. The Guardian, citing people familiar with the talks, reported that the kingdom met with the COP presidency and pushed to weaken the wording and include a carbon-capture target.
On finance, campaigners point to developed countries and the European Union. Harjeet Singh specifically named the EU, Australia and Norway as pushing back strongly. The EU had ruled out new climate-finance pledges before the conference, calling them dead in the water.
These are campaigners’ accounts of who resisted commitments, rather than a full record of every negotiating position. The result described in the draft is that Article 9.1 is absent, as are several adaptation-finance references. Campaigners argue that this leaves developing countries without the support they need to address climate impacts and make transitions away from fossil fuels.
What is carbon capture, utilisation and storage, and how is it supposed to reduce emissions?
Carbon capture, utilisation and storage generally means capturing carbon dioxide before it reaches the atmosphere, then either using it in a process or product, or storing it. This is a general definition; the article names the technologies but does not explain their technical steps. The idea is to reduce emissions from industrial or energy activities rather than release all their carbon dioxide.
The draft backs accelerating carbon capture, utilisation and storage and proposes expanding carbon capture technologies. Campaigners object that this emphasis may distract from stopping fossil-fuel use. Andreas Sieber says many projects are linked to new fossil-fuel projects and only reduce some of their emissions.
The article describes these technologies as costly and unreliable, reporting that most projects initiated in the past three decades failed. It also says the draft pledges a 20- to 40-fold increase by 2035. Whether that expansion would meaningfully reduce emissions is disputed in the article; campaigners argue it could instead help fossil-fuel development continue.
How much does the draft propose expanding carbon capture by 2035, and what does the article say about how well these projects work?
The latest COP31 draft proposes increasing carbon-capture technologies 20- to 40-fold by 2035. That is a major expansion target, and it places the technology at the centre of the draft’s approach even as references to transitioning away from fossil fuels have been removed.
The article reports that carbon-capture technologies are costly and unreliable, with most projects initiated in the last three decades failing. It also cites Andreas Sieber, who says about 80 percent of carbon-capture and storage projects are linked to new fossil-fuel projects. In his account, they do not neutralise those projects’ emissions; they abate only a small amount.
The article therefore presents a sharp gap between the proposed scale-up and campaigners’ assessment of performance. They warn that the expansion could give the fossil-fuel industry cover to keep drilling. The draft’s target is a proposal, not evidence that the technologies will deliver the promised emissions reductions, and the article offers no details on how the target would be achieved.
What could happen to fossil-fuel expansion if countries rely on carbon capture instead of phasing out fossil fuels?
Campaigners fear that relying on carbon capture instead of phasing out fossil fuels could allow fossil-fuel expansion to continue. Their concern is that the technology may be used to justify new projects, rather than replacing fossil fuels with lower-emission alternatives. That matters because the latest draft removes a direct commitment to transition away from fossil fuels.
Andreas Sieber of 350.org says about 80 percent of carbon-capture and storage projects are linked to new fossil-fuel projects. He argues that the technology does not neutralise emissions from those projects, but only abates them a tiny bit. He describes it as a fig leaf for new fossil-fuel projects.
The article also reports that the draft proposes expanding carbon capture 20- to 40-fold by 2035, while campaigners describe the technologies as costly and unreliable. If governments rely on the approach without stronger limits on fossil fuels, campaigners warn that drilling and expansion could continue. That is their stated concern, not a measured prediction of what the draft will cause.
What does Article 9.1 of the Paris Agreement require, and why is climate finance important for developing countries?
Article 9.1 of the Paris Agreement requires developed countries to provide financial resources to help developing countries with mitigation and adaptation. The COP31 final text contains no mention of this provision. The omission matters because climate finance is meant to support countries that need resources to respond to climate change and its effects.
The article also describes other finance commitments being removed or weakened. An earlier draft included a $120bn target for helping developing countries adapt, and a reference to tripling adaptation finance by 2035 was removed from a previous version. The text also drops any mention of developed countries’ historical responsibility.
Henan Keskes of Greenpeace Mena says climate finance is a question of survival in the region, citing rising sea levels, fires, droughts and heat waves. Keskes says the region receives only a very tiny portion of the finance needed for mitigation and adaptation. The article presents finance as a pressing need, while the draft offers no reference to Article 9.1.
What is the difference between climate mitigation and adaptation, and why do countries need both?
In general climate terminology, mitigation means reducing the causes of climate change, especially greenhouse gas emissions. Adaptation means adjusting to climate impacts and reducing harm from them. These are standard definitions; the article refers to both terms but does not define them. The distinction matters because cutting emissions alone does not remove the need to prepare for impacts already affecting communities.
The article connects mitigation with finance required under Article 9.1 and adaptation with support for developing countries facing climate risks. Henan Keskes of Greenpeace Mena points to rising sea levels, fires, droughts and heat waves in the region, and calls adaptation a huge priority. The draft, however, contains no mention of Article 9.1.
Countries need both approaches for different reasons: mitigation can limit emissions, while adaptation helps people and communities cope with climate effects. The article says the final draft also removes a reference to tripling adaptation by 2035. Campaigners warn that the region receives only a tiny portion of the climate finance needed for mitigation and adaptation.
This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.
Read more in the JupiteX app
Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.
Or read more news on the web