JupiteX Get the app
Social Issues21 Nov 2026 · about 7 min

Joanne Young’s faith in justice system is sign of real change, but courts are still catching up

The brief

“Suspect-centric” means building an investigation around the suspected offenders and their actions. It matters because rape cases have often put victims under scrutiny, rather than concentrating on the people accused of the crime. In Joanne Young’s case, prosecutor James Foster said this approach helped prove that Philip Young could not provide consent on the victim’s behalf. It also helped show that each defendant played a part in the abuse. The prosecution’s focus was on the suspects’ conduct and responsibility. The article describes this as a major shift from practices that were still troubling a decade earlier. Operation Soteria later directed police and prosecutors to focus on suspects, disrupt repeat offenders and engage with victims. Police referrals and CPS charges for rape had returned to 2016 levels by 2024, but the article warns that most reported rapes still do not reach court and that trials can be delayed.

01

What did prosecutors mean by a “suspect-centric” approach in Joanne Young’s case?

“Suspect-centric” means building an investigation around the suspected offenders and their actions. It matters because rape cases have often put victims under scrutiny, rather than concentrating on the people accused of the crime.

In Joanne Young’s case, prosecutor James Foster said this approach helped prove that Philip Young could not provide consent on the victim’s behalf. It also helped show that each defendant played a part in the abuse. The prosecution’s focus was on the suspects’ conduct and responsibility.

The article describes this as a major shift from practices that were still troubling a decade earlier. Operation Soteria later directed police and prosecutors to focus on suspects, disrupt repeat offenders and engage with victims. Police referrals and CPS charges for rape had returned to 2016 levels by 2024, but the article warns that most reported rapes still do not reach court and that trials can be delayed.

02

What proportion of reported rapes still never reach court, and how long do survivors wait on average for trial?

The article says about 97% of reported rapes never make it to court. For survivors and complainants whose cases do proceed, the average wait for trial is 423 days. These figures show two different pressures: most reported cases do not reach court, while those that do can face lengthy delays.

The article links the waiting time to the courts backlog. It says many people wait far longer than the 423-day average. It also notes that police referrals and CPS charges for rape had returned to 2016 levels by 2024, but more cases moving forward does not remove delays once they reach court.

The figures point to unfinished work in the justice system. Charities have warned against complacency despite the recovery in referrals and charges. Katrin Hohl has also warned that improved police and CPS practices can meet a “cliff edge” at trial. The article does not give a more detailed breakdown of the 97% or the waiting times.

03

What changes did Operation Soteria ask police and prosecutors to make when investigating rape cases?

Operation Soteria Bluestone was a Home Office-funded review of rape investigations, led by academics and criminology experts Betsy Stanko and Katrin Hohl. It examined cases from a number of forces and identified changes police and prosecutors were asked to make. The aim was to improve how investigations were conducted and how victims were treated.

The six areas included focusing investigations on suspects, disrupting repeat offenders and engaging with victims. They also covered learning and development, officer wellbeing, and the use of data and digital forensics. Investigators were told not to search victims’ personal data indiscriminately. Instead, they should request only information that was relevant and proportionate.

The article says many forces have changed, and police referrals and CPS rape charges were back at 2016 levels by 2024. But reform is not complete: about 97% of reported rapes never reach court, and Hohl warns that cases prepared to improved standards can meet a “cliff edge” at trial. The courts remain a concern.

04

What can long court delays mean for survivors and complainants waiting for a trial?

Long delays mean survivors and complainants can wait a long time for a trial after a case has reached court. The article gives an average of 423 days, while noting that many people wait far longer. It identifies the courts backlog as the reason for concern about these delays.

The article does not describe individual survivors’ experiences during the wait. It does show that the backlog is one way progress can stall: police referrals and CPS charges for rape had recovered to 2016 levels by 2024, but the court system may not be ready to hear cases promptly. Katrin Hohl warns that improved investigations can meet a “cliff edge” once cases go to trial.

The implication in the article is that improving police investigations and prosecution alone is not enough. Courts also need to keep cases moving for changes to reach the trial stage. The article does not say how long the backlog will last, but it reports concern that the courts are being left behind.

05

Why did earlier approaches make some victims feel as if they were the ones under investigation?

Earlier approaches could turn attention onto victims rather than the people suspected of rape. A 2021 review concluded that victims were not only being let down, but were made to feel as if they were the ones under investigation. That matters because an investigation should examine the suspected crime and the suspect’s actions, while treating victims fairly.

The article describes practices that help explain this concern. Prosecutors had been advised at training events to “take the weak cases out of the system” to boost conviction rates. Police were also told under Operation Soteria to stop indiscriminately trawling victims’ personal data and request only information that was relevant and proportionate.

The review prompted a major response: Operation Soteria Bluestone examined cases and set out changes, including a suspect-focused approach and better engagement with victims. The article says many forces have changed, but warns that progress remains incomplete. About 97% of reported rapes still never reach court, and trial delays average 423 days.

06

What roles do police, prosecutors, and courts each play in a rape case?

A rape case involves distinct stages. Police investigate reported crimes and can refer cases onward. Prosecutors assess and prepare cases for trial. Courts hear cases and determine them at trial. The article stresses that improving one stage does not automatically fix the others, especially when cases face court delays.

Operation Soteria asked police and prosecutors to focus investigations on suspects, disrupt repeat offenders and engage with victims. The CPS is the prosecution service; in Joanne Young’s case, prosecutor James Foster said a suspect-centric approach helped prove the defendants’ roles. The article also describes police referrals and CPS charges as measures of cases moving through those stages.

The courts are presented as a continuing weak point. Survivors and complainants wait an average of 423 days for trial, and Katrin Hohl says improved cases can meet a “cliff edge” when they get there. The article therefore points to a need for progress beyond policing and prosecution, while warning that about 97% of reported rapes never reach court.

07

What does consent mean in law, and why can one person not give consent on behalf of another adult?

The article does not define consent in law. Under the well-established law of England and Wales, a person consents when they agree by choice and have the freedom and capacity to make that choice. This is important because marriage or another relationship does not itself establish consent to sexual activity.

The case illustrates the point: prosecutor James Foster said the suspect-centric approach helped prove that Philip Young could not provide consent on the victim’s behalf. Consent is personal; another adult cannot simply authorize sexual activity for a person who has capacity to decide for themselves. The article does not discuss legal tests for capacity or other related rules.

The article places this issue within wider efforts to improve rape investigations. Operation Soteria called for investigations to focus on suspects and for victims’ data to be requested only when relevant and proportionate. Those changes have helped move police and CPS practice forward, but court delays and the very high share of reported rapes that never reach court remain serious concerns.

This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.

Read more in the JupiteX app

Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.

Or read more news on the web