JupiteX Get the app
Politics & Governance21 Nov 2026 · about 7 min

Safeguards against abuse of power essential to preserve critical institutions like ECI: S.Y. Quraishi

The brief

Former Chief Election Commissioner S.Y. Quraishi warned that the Election Commission of India’s credibility “may take years, perhaps decades, to repair.” He raised the concern at a lecture on the direction of India’s constitutional institutions. His warning matters because public confidence in the body responsible for elections is important to the legitimacy of the electoral process. Quraishi said the ECI’s credibility had come under strain since 2019. He cited controversy over turnout figures in the 2024 Lok Sabha election, former Election Commissioner Ashok Lavasa’s dissent, and concerns about the SIR. In West Bengal, 27 lakh voters were deleted during adjudication; 22 lakh appealed, but only 1,607 names were restored before the Assembly election. He said appellate tribunal decisions reportedly found 93% of more than 1.2 lakh exclusions incorrect. Quraishi called for an independent SIR audit, public decision records, digital audit trails, and restoration of names removed without lawful authority. He also urged transparent appointments and stronger safeguards against misuse of power. These proposals address both the election process and the institutions that oversee it.

01

What warning did former Chief Election Commissioner S.Y. Quraishi give about the Election Commission’s credibility?

Former Chief Election Commissioner S.Y. Quraishi warned that the Election Commission of India’s credibility “may take years, perhaps decades, to repair.” He raised the concern at a lecture on the direction of India’s constitutional institutions. His warning matters because public confidence in the body responsible for elections is important to the legitimacy of the electoral process.

Quraishi said the ECI’s credibility had come under strain since 2019. He cited controversy over turnout figures in the 2024 Lok Sabha election, former Election Commissioner Ashok Lavasa’s dissent, and concerns about the SIR. In West Bengal, 27 lakh voters were deleted during adjudication; 22 lakh appealed, but only 1,607 names were restored before the Assembly election.

He said appellate tribunal decisions reportedly found 93% of more than 1.2 lakh exclusions incorrect. Quraishi called for an independent SIR audit, public decision records, digital audit trails, and restoration of names removed without lawful authority. He also urged transparent appointments and stronger safeguards against misuse of power. These proposals address both the election process and the institutions that oversee it.

02

What is the Election Commission of India, and what role does it play in elections?

The Election Commission of India, or ECI, is the national body responsible for administering elections in India. In general, it oversees elections to Parliament and State legislatures, as well as elections for the offices of President and Vice-President. The source article discusses the ECI’s credibility and powers but does not provide a formal definition of the institution.

Its role includes organizing the election process and managing key procedures so voters can cast ballots and results can be determined. The article gives a West Bengal example involving the SIR, in which voter names were deleted and some people appealed for restoration. Those decisions affected whether people could vote before the Assembly election.

Quraishi argued that public trust in the ECI had been strained since 2019. He connected that concern to election turnout figures, a former commissioner’s dissent, the SIR, and the way election commissioners are appointed. He called for independent appointments, transparent processes, and stronger safeguards. Such steps, he said, would help protect the institution from misuse of power and improve accountability.

03

How many voters were deleted in the West Bengal SIR exercise, and how many had their names restored before the election?

In West Bengal, 27 lakh voters were deleted during adjudication in the SIR exercise. Of those affected, 22 lakh appealed to have their names restored. Before the Assembly election, only 1,607 names had been restored. These figures show the scale of the deletions and the gap between the number of appeals and the number of restorations reported by Quraishi.

The key mechanism described is adjudication followed by an appeal. Quraishi said the overwhelming majority remained unable to vote because hearings had not been completed. He also said the Supreme Court could have allowed the large group of affected voters to vote, though he framed that as his view of what the Court could have done.

Quraishi added that appellate tribunal decisions reportedly found 93% of more than 1.2 lakh exclusions incorrect. He said this raised further questions about the exercise. He called for an independent audit, disclosure of decision records and digital audit trails, and restoration of names deleted without lawful authority. The article does not report a later total of restored names.

04

What could happen to eligible voters when hearings and appeals over deleted names are delayed?

When a voter’s name is deleted, delayed hearings and appeals can leave that person without a chance to have the deletion reviewed in time to vote. The article’s West Bengal example shows why timing matters: the election arrived while most appeals were still unresolved. The consequence can be exclusion from voting even when a person is eligible.

Quraishi said 27 lakh voters were deleted during SIR adjudication, and 22 lakh appealed for restoration. Before the Assembly election, just 1,607 names were restored because hearings had not been done. He said the overwhelming majority were therefore unable to vote. The process involved initial deletion, a hearing or adjudication, and then an appeal for restoration.

Quraishi also noted that appellate tribunal decisions reportedly found 93% of more than 1.2 lakh exclusions incorrect. He called for an independent audit, disclosure of decision records and digital audit trails, and restoration of names deleted without lawful authority. The example illustrates how procedural delays can affect electoral rights before a review is completed.

05

How did the 2023 law change the panel that appoints election commissioners?

The 2023 law changed who sits on the panel that selects election commissioners. It replaced the Chief Justice of India with a Union Minister nominated by the Prime Minister. Quraishi criticised the change because, in his view, it effectively gave the government control over two of the panel’s three votes. He argued that appointments should be transparent and independent.

The mechanism matters because the panel makes choices about the people who lead the ECI. Replacing a judicial member with a minister nominated by the Prime Minister changes the balance described by Quraishi. The article does not identify the panel’s third member, so the key point it reports is the substitution and Quraishi’s assessment of its effect.

Quraishi called for an independent selection process and transparent appointments as safeguards against government control. His broader address urged constitutional institutions to use collective decision-making, record reasons and dissent, and strengthen accountability. The article does not say that the law was changed after his remarks. His criticism was part of a wider warning about safeguards for institutions, including the ECI, judiciary, and executive.

06

What safeguards did Quraishi call for to make decisions by constitutional institutions more transparent and accountable?

Quraishi argued that constitutional institutions need safeguards against misuse of power. He said decisions should be more transparent and accountable, with independent appointments and collective decision-making. Recording reasons and dissent would make it clearer how decisions were reached and allow scrutiny of disagreements. These measures matter because they can help protect institutions’ credibility and public rights.

He proposed specific steps for the ECI: an independent audit of the SIR, disclosure of decision records and digital audit trails, and restoration of names deleted without lawful authority. For judicial case allocation, he suggested a panel of three senior judges manage the roster through a transparent, preferably computerised, system. He also called for transparent election commissioner appointments and an independent selection process.

Across institutions, Quraishi urged stronger accountability and prompt resolution of disputes involving electoral rights, government formation, and legislative disqualification. He said delays could cause irreversible damage. His proposals also included clearer timelines for Governors’ assent to Bills and limits on court adjournments. The article presents these as safeguards he advocated, not as changes already adopted.

07

Why do constitutional systems divide power among institutions and create checks on how each one uses it?

In general, constitutional systems divide power among institutions to reduce the risk that authority becomes concentrated in one place. Each institution has defined responsibilities, while checks allow other bodies or the public to scrutinize how power is used. This is a well-established constitutional principle; the article does not set out a formal explanation of it.

Quraishi’s examples show why such safeguards matter in practice. He criticised a 2023 law that replaced the Chief Justice of India with a Union Minister nominated by the Prime Minister on the election commissioners’ selection panel. He said this effectively gave the government control over two of the panel’s three votes. He also called for transparent judicial case allocation and questioned delays in deciding disqualification petitions.

His broader recommendations included independent appointments, collective decision-making, recorded reasons and dissent, and stronger accountability. He argued that disputes involving electoral rights, government formation, and legislative disqualification should be resolved promptly to prevent irreversible damage. The article presents these as measures to protect institutions and citizens’ rights, not as reforms already implemented.

This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.

Read more in the JupiteX app

Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.

Or read more news on the web