CEA flags derivatives boom as India struggles to mobilise long-term capital
India’s equity derivatives market is among the world’s largest, but chief economic adviser V. Anantha Nageswaran warned that markets may be drifting from their basic role: turning household savings into productive investment. He questioned whether technology-enabled access is creating informed investors or more speculators. Easy access, he said, has expanded faster than households’ ability to judge investments. The concern is visible in retail trading losses. Individual traders lost ₹91,685 crore in futures and options in FY26, according to a Securities and Exchange Board of India study cited by Mint. Although the number of participants fell, the average loss per trader rose 2% to ₹1.17 lakh. Nageswaran said derivatives are meant to move risk to people able to bear it, but much risk had moved to people who may not understand it. He also pointed to a shortage of long-term capital for factories and infrastructure. Equity market capitalisation was around 130% of GDP, while the corporate bond market was around 16%. He urged market participants to measure success by new investment raised, its timeframe and cost—not simply trading turnover.
What concern did India’s chief economic adviser raise about the country’s growing equity derivatives market?
India’s equity derivatives market is among the world’s largest, but chief economic adviser V. Anantha Nageswaran warned that markets may be drifting from their basic role: turning household savings into productive investment. He questioned whether technology-enabled access is creating informed investors or more speculators. Easy access, he said, has expanded faster than households’ ability to judge investments.
The concern is visible in retail trading losses. Individual traders lost ₹91,685 crore in futures and options in FY26, according to a Securities and Exchange Board of India study cited by Mint. Although the number of participants fell, the average loss per trader rose 2% to ₹1.17 lakh. Nageswaran said derivatives are meant to move risk to people able to bear it, but much risk had moved to people who may not understand it.
He also pointed to a shortage of long-term capital for factories and infrastructure. Equity market capitalisation was around 130% of GDP, while the corporate bond market was around 16%. He urged market participants to measure success by new investment raised, its timeframe and cost—not simply trading turnover.
What are equity derivatives such as futures and options, and what are they designed to do?
In general, equity derivatives are contracts whose value is linked to a share or stock-market index. Futures and options are two common forms. They let people take positions based on how an underlying price may move, without simply buying and holding the underlying shares. This description uses standard financial knowledge; the article does not spell out the contract terms.
A futures contract sets an agreement to buy or sell an asset at a set price on a future date. An option gives its buyer the right, but not the obligation, to buy or sell at specified terms. These contracts can help market participants manage exposure to price changes. Nageswaran described the basic purpose as moving risk from those unable to bear it to those able to do so.
His concern was that this purpose can be undermined if participants do not understand the risk they take. He said that in India, risk had moved in significant part from people who understand derivatives to people who do not. The article also notes persistently high losses among retail derivatives traders, making informed judgment important.
How much did individual traders lose in futures and options in FY26, and what share of them lost money?
Individual traders lost ₹91,685 crore in futures and options during FY26, according to a Securities and Exchange Board of India study previously reported by Mint. The share of individual traders who lost money was 87.7%, down from 90.9% a year earlier. The figures show that losses remained widespread even as the proportion of losing traders eased.
The total loss was lower than the ₹1.12 trillion recorded in FY25. The number of participants also fell 18% to 8.77 million. Yet the average loss per trader rose 2% to ₹1.17 lakh. Traders active for more than 100 days accounted for 94% of turnover and 87% of total losses, with an average loss of ₹2.76 lakh.
Nageswaran cited the losses amid concern that accessible technology may encourage speculation without building people’s ability to judge investments. He said derivatives were intended to transfer risk to those who could bear it, not to those who did not understand it. The figures underline why he urged market participants to look beyond turnover when judging market success.
How can a market dominated by trading fail to channel enough household savings into factories and infrastructure?
Trading can be busy without directing much new household money to productive projects. In general, when investors trade existing shares or bonds with one another, the payment goes to the seller. That changes who owns the asset, but does not automatically give a company fresh funds to build a factory or infrastructure. This distinction helps explain the concern raised in the article.
Derivatives trading adds another layer: participants can take positions tied to share prices, and Nageswaran said derivatives were designed to move risk between people. Such activity can generate substantial turnover, but turnover alone does not show how much capital has been raised for new investment, for how long, or at what cost. The article describes India’s equity derivatives market as among the world’s largest.
Nageswaran said technology had made markets faster and safer in their mechanics, while taking them further from their core function of turning household savings into productive investment. He urged market participants to judge success by financing raised for new investment. He also called for more long-term capital from pension funds, insurers and provident funds for manufacturing and infrastructure.
Why do factories, power grids and ports need financing that can stay invested for 20 to 25 years?
Factories, power grids and ports are long-gestation projects: they need financing that can support them over many years. The article says India has yet to build a financial system designed to finance productive assets over 20–25 years. That matters because funding needs to match the time it takes such projects to develop and produce returns, rather than relying only on shorter-term money.
Nageswaran argued that factories, power grids, ports and fabrication plants require long-term debt. He contrasted the equity market’s capitalisation, around 130% of GDP, with the corporate bond market, around 16%. The figures point to a much smaller corporate bond market, which he cited while explaining the need for deeper pools of long-term capital.
He urged pension funds, insurers and provident funds to become long-term owners and help create investment vehicles for projects in agriculture, manufacturing and infrastructure. A day earlier, Arunish Chawla said banks alone could not meet India’s long-term financing needs, citing the medium-term nature of their deposits. The article points to a wider financing role for long-term funds.
How could pension funds, insurers and provident funds help finance projects that take many years to pay off?
Pension funds, insurers and provident funds can help provide the long-term capital that India needs for productive assets. The chief economic adviser said India still lacks deep pools of capital for the manufacturing and infrastructure it requires, and has yet to build a financial system designed to finance assets over 20–25 years. These funds could help address that gap by taking a longer view.
Nageswaran called on them to act as long-term owners, engage with companies they own and create investment vehicles for projects in agriculture, manufacturing and infrastructure. These steps could connect institutional money with projects that need financing over a long period. The article does not specify a particular vehicle or project; it sets out the role he wants these funds to take.
The call came as Nageswaran said factories, power grids, ports and fabrication plants require long-term debt. A day earlier, Department of Investment and Public Asset Management secretary Arunish Chawla had said banks alone could not meet India’s long-term financing needs, citing the medium-term nature of their deposits. Together, their remarks point to a larger role for insurance, pension and capital-market funds.
What is the difference between trading existing shares and bonds and raising new capital for investment?
In general, trading existing shares or bonds means one investor sells an asset and another buys it. The money goes to the seller, not automatically to the company that issued the asset. Raising new capital is different: a company receives funds that can support investment. This basic distinction helps explain why high market turnover does not necessarily mean factories or infrastructure have gained financing.
Nageswaran said India’s markets had become faster and safer in their mechanics but were moving away from turning household savings into productive investment. He urged market participants to ask how much capital markets raise for new investment, over what horizon and at what cost. Those measures focus on funds supporting new activity rather than the volume of trading alone.
The article says factories, power grids, ports and fabrication plants need long-term debt. Nageswaran cited equity market capitalisation of around 130% of GDP and a corporate bond market of around 16%, and called for more long-term financing. He urged pension funds, insurers and provident funds to help fund long-gestation projects.
This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.
Read more in the JupiteX app
Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.
Or read more news on the web