‘Want to return, but can’t without safety’: Rohingyas in India react to ICJ ruling on Myanmar genocide
The court’s finding was stark: in a 9-6 decision, the International Court of Justice said Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya in northern Rakhine State. It found this violated Myanmar’s obligations under the Genocide Convention. The ruling is a formal judgment by the top UN court on the state’s treatment of the group. ICJ president Yuji Iwasawa announced the decision. The court also ordered Myanmar to allow Rohingya who fled the violence to return home. That instruction addresses the displacement at the heart of the refugees’ concerns: many are living away from their homeland and want to return, but say they cannot do so without safety. Rohingya refugees in India welcomed the ruling as historic, while stressing that a judgment alone does not make a return safe. They called for accountability, reparations and protection, alongside a dignified return. Their response highlights the gap between the court’s order and their stated need for security, equal rights and assurance they will not face persecution again.
What did the ICJ rule about Myanmar’s treatment of the Rohingya, and what did it say Myanmar must allow?
The court’s finding was stark: in a 9-6 decision, the International Court of Justice said Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya in northern Rakhine State. It found this violated Myanmar’s obligations under the Genocide Convention. The ruling is a formal judgment by the top UN court on the state’s treatment of the group.
ICJ president Yuji Iwasawa announced the decision. The court also ordered Myanmar to allow Rohingya who fled the violence to return home. That instruction addresses the displacement at the heart of the refugees’ concerns: many are living away from their homeland and want to return, but say they cannot do so without safety.
Rohingya refugees in India welcomed the ruling as historic, while stressing that a judgment alone does not make a return safe. They called for accountability, reparations and protection, alongside a dignified return. Their response highlights the gap between the court’s order and their stated need for security, equal rights and assurance they will not face persecution again.
Why do Rohingya refugees in India say they still cannot safely return to Myanmar?
For Rohingya refugees in India, wanting to return home does not mean they believe it is safe to do so now. They describe living far from Myanmar with no certainty about when they can go back. Their central concern is whether they and their families would be protected if they returned.
Kamal Hussain, living in a camp in Haryana’s Nuh district, said his community needed safety and the ability to live with equal rights and dignity. In Jammu, Zabul Haq said he was not willing to return because there was no safety; he has a wife and four children. Hyderabad resident Jaffer Alam said he would return if his rights were protected and there were no threats to his life.
Their accounts show that the ICJ’s order allowing return does not, by itself, resolve their fears. Refugees say security and protection from persecution must come first. Some, including Alam and Mohammad Taher, say they would consider going back if they could live with dignity and respect, without harassment.
What protections and rights do the refugees say they need before returning?
The refugees’ demands go beyond permission to cross back into Myanmar. They say a safe return depends on being protected from harm and able to live as equal members of society. They also want assurance that they will not be persecuted again. These conditions matter because returning without security or rights would not meet their stated hope for a safe and dignified life at home.
Kamal Hussain said Rohingya should be allowed to live with equal rights and dignity. Ali Johar called for security, recognition of rights and assurance against renewed persecution. Jaffer Alam and Mohammad Taher said they would consider returning if their rights and safety were guaranteed. Their examples show what refugees mean by protection: safety for their families, respect, and freedom from harassment.
Sabber Kyaw Min, founder and director of the Rohingya Human Rights initiative, said justice must include accountability, reparations and protection, and lead ultimately to safe, dignified return. The refugees welcomed the ICJ judgment, but their statements make clear that they see it as a step, not the end of the work needed to return.
How many Rohingya are reported to live in the settlements described in Nuh and Hyderabad?
The figures describe Rohingya communities in two Indian locations, but they are not presented on exactly the same basis. In Haryana’s Nuh district, the article reports around 1,695 refugees living across 10 settlements. In Hyderabad, Mohammad Taher estimates there are around 10,000–15,000 Rohingya. The report does not say that all Hyderabad residents live in one camp.
Nuh’s figure is tied specifically to settlements: Kamal Hussain is identified as a refugee living in one of the camps there. Hyderabad’s figure comes from Taher, who also describes his sister remaining in Myanmar and says he would like to return if he could live with dignity and respect. The article says many Hyderabad residents are daily wage workers.
Together, these numbers show the scale of Rohingya displacement described in the two places, while remaining local estimates rather than a national total. The refugees’ accounts connect those figures to the conditions of life in India and to hopes of returning only if Myanmar can offer safety, rights and dignity.
Who are the Rohingya, and what events led many of them to flee Myanmar?
The article identifies the Rohingya as a group targeted in northern Rakhine State, Myanmar, and reports that many fled violence and now live as refugees in India. It does not give a full history of the community or detail every event that drove people to leave. As broader historical background, the Rohingya are a largely Muslim ethnic minority from Myanmar’s Rakhine State, and their displacement has followed years of discrimination and violence.
The article describes individual experiences of flight and separation. Jaffer Alam said he and his family fled Rakhine State in 2014. Mohammad Taher said his sister was driven from her home by Buddhist monks and remained in Myanmar in a remote village. A related headline refers to a 2017 Rohingya crackdown, but the article’s main accounts do not provide a detailed timeline of that episode.
The ICJ’s ruling links the group’s treatment in northern Rakhine to genocide, and Rohingya refugees in India say they hope to rebuild their lives at home. They say return depends on safety, recognition of rights and protection from renewed persecution. The court ruling itself cannot erase displacement or the fears they describe.
What does the Genocide Convention mean by genocide?
The Genocide Convention defines genocide through both intent and acts. A person must intend to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnic, racial or religious group as such. The acts covered include killing members of the group, causing them serious bodily or mental harm, and deliberately imposing life conditions intended to bring about its physical destruction.
The definition also includes measures intended to prevent births within the group and forcibly transferring its children to another group. The intent requirement is central: severe violence or persecution alone is not automatically genocide under the Convention unless the required intent to destroy the protected group is established. This is general legal background; the article does not explain the full definition.
The article says the ICJ found Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya in northern Rakhine State and violated its Convention obligations. The court announced that finding in a 9-6 decision and ordered Myanmar to allow Rohingya who fled the violence to return. Refugees in India welcomed the ruling but said safety, rights and protection remain essential.
What can an ICJ ruling require a country to do, and how can such a ruling be enforced?
The International Court of Justice settles legal disputes between states and can issue judgments that bind the countries involved. It may find that a country breached an international obligation and require it to stop the breach or take steps to meet its duties. In this case, the article reports that the court ordered Myanmar to allow Rohingya who fled violence to return home.
A court order does not itself physically compel a government to comply. The ICJ has no independent police or enforcement force. Under the UN Charter, if a party fails to perform its obligations under an ICJ judgment, the other party may bring the matter to the Security Council, which can make recommendations or decide on measures. This is general legal background beyond the article.
Enforcement therefore depends on state and UN action, including the Security Council’s response. The article reports the judgment and the refugees’ calls for accountability, reparations and protection, but does not describe any enforcement process. Rohingya refugees said a return would still require safety, equal rights and dignity, so the ruling alone does not settle their practical concerns.
This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.
Read more in the JupiteX app
Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.
Or read more news on the web