JupiteX Get the app
Social Issues21 Nov 2026 · about 7 min

Same neighbourhood, different intakes: Why are some primary schools not filling their classrooms?

The brief

At the end of Phase 2C Supplementary in the 2026 exercise, Pei Tong Primary had filled fewer than half its vacancies, while Nan Hua Primary received almost three times as many applications. The contrast is striking because all three primary schools in the area are within easy reach for many families. The article does not give a specific reason for the difference between Pei Tong and Nan Hua. It notes that about 870 children eligible for P1 in 2027 live within 1km of at least one of the schools, and each offered 240 to 280 places. A decade earlier, applications were more evenly spread across the three schools. The local contrast reflects a broader shift: demand is becoming more concentrated in popular schools. SAP status, secondary-school affiliation and social proof can help explain why some schools attract families, but the article does not establish which factor drove Nan Hua’s applications or Pei Tong’s shortfall. It also notes that parents can see daily application figures and still choose oversubscribed schools.

01

Why did Pei Tong Primary have fewer than half its places filled while Nan Hua Primary received almost three times as many applications?

At the end of Phase 2C Supplementary in the 2026 exercise, Pei Tong Primary had filled fewer than half its vacancies, while Nan Hua Primary received almost three times as many applications. The contrast is striking because all three primary schools in the area are within easy reach for many families.

The article does not give a specific reason for the difference between Pei Tong and Nan Hua. It notes that about 870 children eligible for P1 in 2027 live within 1km of at least one of the schools, and each offered 240 to 280 places. A decade earlier, applications were more evenly spread across the three schools.

The local contrast reflects a broader shift: demand is becoming more concentrated in popular schools. SAP status, secondary-school affiliation and social proof can help explain why some schools attract families, but the article does not establish which factor drove Nan Hua’s applications or Pei Tong’s shortfall. It also notes that parents can see daily application figures and still choose oversubscribed schools.

02

How has demand shifted over the past decade between undersubscribed and oversubscribed schools?

Over the past decade, applications have become less evenly distributed among Singapore’s primary schools. The median application rate for undersubscribed schools fell from 82% to 67% by the end of Phase 2C Supplementary. Meanwhile, oversubscribed schools saw their rate rise from 107% to 114% between 2017 and 2026.

An application rate compares applications with available places. So a rate of 67% means an undersubscribed school typically received 67 applications for every 100 places. A rate of 114% means an oversubscribed school received 114 applications per 100 places. The two trends show fewer applications going to less sought-after schools and more competition for popular ones.

The pattern is visible beyond Clementi, where Pei Tong had fewer than half its vacancies filled while Nan Hua received almost three times as many applications. Parents have had daily updates on applicants and vacancies for seven years, but those figures have not spread demand more evenly. Instead, the article describes demand as increasingly concentrated in certain schools.

03

What does an application rate of 67% or 114% mean for a school?

An application rate compares the number of applications a school receives with the number of places it offers. It is a way to show demand relative to capacity, rather than simply giving the raw number of families applying. A rate below 100% means applications are fewer than places; a rate above 100% means they exceed places.

For example, the article says the median rate for undersubscribed schools was 67%. That means such a school typically received 67 applications for every 100 places available. An oversubscribed school’s 114% rate means it received 114 applications per 100 places. The figures are ratios, not percentages of children who will get in.

The contrast matters because demand has become more concentrated. The undersubscribed-school median fell from 82% to 67% over the last decade, while the oversubscribed rate rose from 107% to 114% between 2017 and 2026. A rate above 100% does not itself state who will be admitted; the article notes that ballots took place at some schools and phases.

04

Who can apply in Phase 2C Supplementary, and why is it an important last chance for a P1 place?

Phase 2C Supplementary is the last stage of the annual Primary 1 registration exercise for Singapore citizen and permanent resident children to get a place. It matters because families who have not secured a school earlier have no later phase in that exercise to turn to.

The article describes Phase 2C as the fourth and typically most competitive stage. It is open to families without prior ties to a school and those who were unsuccessful in earlier phases. Places are limited: schools in the Clementi comparison each offered between 240 and 280 places for children entering P1 in 2027.

The 2026 exercise shows how tight the choices can be. Pei Tong Primary had not filled half its vacancies by the end of Phase 2C Supplementary, while Nan Hua had almost three times as many applications. Since 2020, registration has been fully online, and MOE has provided daily figures on applicants and vacancies for seven years. Families can use those figures, but the final phase remains a high-stakes opportunity.

05

What school features—such as SAP status, secondary-school affiliation, or convenient location—attract families?

Families may be drawn to a school for what it offers and for how it connects to later schooling. The article highlights Special Assistance Plan (SAP) schools, which place greater emphasis on Chinese language and heritage, and primary schools affiliated with a secondary school. It reports that schools with these attributes are 71% more likely to be fully filled than other schools.

The examples show why. CHIJ Primary (Toa Payoh) is affiliated with CHIJ Secondary (Toa Payoh). In 2026, affiliated pupils could enter the secondary school with a PSLE score of 20 points, while non-affiliated pupils needed 10 points or better. Pei Chun Public School’s SAP status and Chinese language and culture reputation drew interest from as far away as Tampines.

Location can also feature in registration choices: the article discusses applicants living within 1km or between 1km and 2km of schools, and describes about 870 eligible children living within 1km of at least one of three Clementi schools. These draws can make demand uneven, even when families have several nearby schools.

06

How can seeing high application numbers influence parents and concentrate demand in already popular schools?

Application figures are meant to help parents make informed choices, but they can also shape what parents want. Vincent Chua, an associate professor at the National University of Singapore, describes this as a calculated gamble driven by social proof, rather than irrational panic. When parents see many others applying, they may read that popularity as evidence that a school is valuable.

Since 2020, registration has been fully online. For the last seven years, MOE has provided daily updates on applicants and vacancies at each school. Chua says seeing hundreds of applicants vying for a school can act as a powerful signal. Parents may still apply even when their odds of securing a place are slim.

This can reinforce existing popularity: more applications make a sought-after school look even more in demand, while less popular schools may remain undersubscribed. Across Singapore, the oversubscribed-school application rate rose from 107% to 114% between 2017 and 2026. Meanwhile, the median rate for undersubscribed schools fell from 82% to 67%. The figures show demand becoming increasingly concentrated.

07

How does PSLE-based secondary-school placement make an affiliated primary school a form of insurance for families?

For families, an affiliated primary school can offer a potential advantage when a child moves on to its linked secondary school. The article describes this as a form of insurance: affiliation may soften the pressure of PSLE-based sorting by giving pupils a more forgiving entry cut-off. It does not remove the exam or guarantee a place, but it can make the linked school route more attractive.

CHIJ Primary (Toa Payoh) illustrates the difference. In 2026, non-affiliated pupils needed a PSLE score of 10 points or better to qualify for CHIJ Secondary (Toa Payoh). Pupils from the affiliated primary school had a cut-off of 20 points. Vincent Chua said some families view an affiliated primary school as a 10- or even 12-year insurance policy.

As academic competition intensifies, Chua said families may concentrate effort around schools with this built-in safety net. That helps explain CHIJ Primary’s popularity: a ballot was held in Phase 2C for citizens living between 1km and 2km from the school. Affiliation can therefore influence demand well before a child sits the PSLE.

This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.

Read more in the JupiteX app

Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.

Or read more news on the web