Am I Caribbean, or am I a tourist? How art helped me find the answer
The writer arrives with Antiguan and Jamaican heritage and feels a connection to the region. Yet the art fair and its resort setting make her question where she stands: inside the culture, or outside it as a visitor. That matters because even affection for a place can be shaped by the same images that turn it into a tourist fantasy. Caribbean artists complicate those images. Anina Major’s crumpled ceramic baskets reflect a tourist-shaped version of Bahamian identity, while Antonius Roberts’s bright palette draws on the region’s sunlight and beaches. Their work helps the writer see the gap between a postcard view and the histories, traditions, and people that images can flatten. Her uncertainty becomes explicit during a gallery tour. She says she is “not like” the American tourists, but a Black British curator replies, “You are.” The writer then wonders whether her love of the art’s fuchsias, turquoises, and yellows is reclamation or exoticisation. The encounter does not settle her identity; it shows how belonging and tourism can overlap.
How did encountering Caribbean art help the writer think about whether she was seeing the Bahamas as an insider or a tourist?
The writer arrives with Antiguan and Jamaican heritage and feels a connection to the region. Yet the art fair and its resort setting make her question where she stands: inside the culture, or outside it as a visitor. That matters because even affection for a place can be shaped by the same images that turn it into a tourist fantasy.
Caribbean artists complicate those images. Anina Major’s crumpled ceramic baskets reflect a tourist-shaped version of Bahamian identity, while Antonius Roberts’s bright palette draws on the region’s sunlight and beaches. Their work helps the writer see the gap between a postcard view and the histories, traditions, and people that images can flatten.
Her uncertainty becomes explicit during a gallery tour. She says she is “not like” the American tourists, but a Black British curator replies, “You are.” The writer then wonders whether her love of the art’s fuchsias, turquoises, and yellows is reclamation or exoticisation. The encounter does not settle her identity; it shows how belonging and tourism can overlap.
What do people mean by the “tourist gaze” on the Caribbean?
The “tourist gaze” is the habit of seeing the Caribbean mainly through outsiders’ expectations: a place for relaxation, service, and beautiful scenery. The article describes how images of beaches and paradise can make the region seem unreal and simple. This matters because those images can overshadow the lives, histories, and cultures of the people who live there.
John Cox says outside expectations often fetishise an exotic paradise, imagining its inhabitants as less sophisticated. Postcards and photography helped shape this view by presenting the Caribbean as a holiday destination. Tourism can also curate what visitors encounter: Antonius Roberts says cruise companies exclude political art and climate breakdown from what customers see.
The gaze is not just about what tourists look at; it can shape what is sold and displayed. The straw market, for example, now includes imported goods and bags with Minnie Mouse’s face. Artists such as Anina Major and Roberts answer with work rooted in local materials, craft knowledge, colour, and culture. Their art challenges the idea that the islands exist only for visitors’ pleasure.
How do artists such as Anina Major and Antonius Roberts use materials, colour, and imagery to challenge tourist expectations?
Major and Roberts challenge tourist expectations by choosing images, colours, and materials that do not simply reproduce a pretty holiday view. Their work points to local identity, craft knowledge, and the region’s relationship with its land and sea. This matters because the tourist image can reduce a living culture to scenery and souvenirs.
Major makes ceramic sculptures from hand-weaved clay that resemble straw-market baskets. But she crumples and sinks them into themselves, turning a familiar tourist object into a deflated replica of identity performed for visitors. Roberts recalls being told in the United States to stop “painting Black” because his colours were too bright. He answers that the Caribbean’s beaches and sunlight are bright, and he also works with wood, stone, goat skins, and recycled materials.
Together, their approaches refuse a single expected style. Major makes the market’s imagery feel uneasy; Roberts draws on traditional craft knowledge and the region’s vivid palette. Roberts also criticises cruise companies for limiting what tourists see. Their work makes room for cultural depth and dignity beyond the curated holiday scene.
What can happen to local traditions and cultural expression when tourism turns them into products or attractions for visitors?
When tourism turns traditions into attractions or products, cultural expression can be flattened into what visitors expect to buy or see. This matters because a practice with local history may become a performance or commodity, rather than a living tradition whose meaning is shaped by local people.
The Nassau straw market illustrates the change. It once helped local women earn money by selling items made from woven silver top and palmetto palms. Now many goods are imported from China, and a visitor can buy a bag with Minnie Mouse’s face braided onto it. Anina Major’s crumpled ceramic versions of baskets suggest how Bahamian identity can be performed for the tourist gaze. Roberts says cruise companies also curate what their customers see, excluding political art and climate breakdown.
The article shows both livelihood and loss: local women benefited from market sales, while tourism’s current products can replace locally made goods. Artists respond by drawing on traditional craft knowledge and materials. Their work challenges a system that makes the islands legible mainly as a holiday destination, though the article gives no figures on its wider economic effects.
How much of the Bahamas’ economy and employment depends on tourism?
The article does not quantify how much of the Bahamas’ economy or employment depends on tourism. It gives no share of national income, number of jobs, or other measure that could answer “how much?” precisely. That limit matters: the article describes tourism’s influence, but its examples cannot establish the sector’s total economic scale.
It does provide historical and local context. After economies reliant on exports such as sugar gave way to tourism, the Bahamas became a testing ground for a tourist economy aimed importantly at Americans. The article also describes the straw market as a major tourist attraction and says its early trade helped local women earn money. Roberts calls the cruise industry the region’s “new colonial power.”
These details show tourism shaping livelihoods, products, and what visitors see, but they do not show how many people work in tourism today or how large its economic contribution is. A precise answer would require current economic and employment statistics not supplied in the text. So the responsible conclusion from this source is that tourism is influential, but its share cannot be calculated here.
How did the history of slavery, export economies, and 20th-century tourism shape outside images of the Caribbean?
The article describes a shift in how outsiders viewed the Bahamas and other Caribbean countries. After the abolition of transatlantic enslavement, perceptions of danger, poverty, and uncleanliness persisted well into the 20th century. This matters because those views were not fixed: tourism later helped replace one outside image with another, also shaped by economic interests.
Economies reliant on exports such as sugar gave way to tourism. In the middle of the 20th century, postcards and photography intentionally depicted the Caribbean as a holiday destination. The Bahamas became a testing ground for this tourist economy, and impressions of the region—especially in the United States—were shaped by the idea of a tropical playground. Roberts notes that flights from southern Florida can take as little as 30 minutes.
The newer image brought visitors, but it also narrowed expectations to beaches, relaxation, and service. Artists in the article challenge that view by foregrounding local craft, colour, dignity, and cultural traditions. The text shows the image-making process continuing through tourism and cruise companies, which Roberts says curate what customers see, including by excluding political art and climate breakdown.
How can migration and diaspora shape a person’s sense of belonging to a place or culture?
Migration and diaspora can give people ties to more than one place, shaping how they understand belonging, heritage, and distance. A person may feel cultural connection through family background while also encountering a place as a visitor. That distinction matters in the article, where the writer asks whether heritage makes her an insider or whether tourism shapes how she sees the Bahamas.
The writer says she has Antiguan and Jamaican heritage, and describes being familiar with the fantasies the Caribbean evokes. At the resort, she says she is “not like” the American tourists. A Black British curator who regularly visits her sister in the Bahamas replies, “You are.” The exchange unsettles any simple division between belonging and visiting.
The article does not explain the writer’s family migration history or define her identity for her. Instead, it shows her reflecting on her position while encountering Caribbean art and landscape. She wonders whether her love of vivid colours is reclamation or exoticisation. More broadly, diaspora can make belonging layered, but the source’s specific account is limited to heritage, travel, and this moment of challenge.
This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.
Read more in the JupiteX app
Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.
Or read more news on the web