JupiteX Get the app
Culture & Arts21 Nov 2026 · about 6 min

Who gets blamed when families fall apart in Nepali films?

The brief

Women, especially daughters-in-law, are most often blamed when families fall apart in the Nepali films discussed. Their wishes or disagreements are often presented as the spark for conflict, making them seem like the people tearing families apart. In Paran, the daughter-in-law urges her husband to apply for a US Diversity Visa, and the father is left behind when the couple moves. In Ba: Ek Yoddha and Aa Bata Aama, wives are also blamed for influencing husbands to leave their parents or move abroad. The pattern appears in several other films too. The article argues that this focus leaves much unexplored. Sons’ own decisions, money pressures, household power and family communication receive less attention. Women’s rights activist Rita Sah says such portrayals reflect patriarchal attitudes, not necessarily reality. The repeated blame matters because it frames women as one another’s adversaries instead of examining the wider reasons families come into conflict.

01

In the films discussed, who is most often blamed when family relationships break down?

Women, especially daughters-in-law, are most often blamed when families fall apart in the Nepali films discussed. Their wishes or disagreements are often presented as the spark for conflict, making them seem like the people tearing families apart.

In Paran, the daughter-in-law urges her husband to apply for a US Diversity Visa, and the father is left behind when the couple moves. In Ba: Ek Yoddha and Aa Bata Aama, wives are also blamed for influencing husbands to leave their parents or move abroad. The pattern appears in several other films too.

The article argues that this focus leaves much unexplored. Sons’ own decisions, money pressures, household power and family communication receive less attention. Women’s rights activist Rita Sah says such portrayals reflect patriarchal attitudes, not necessarily reality. The repeated blame matters because it frames women as one another’s adversaries instead of examining the wider reasons families come into conflict.

02

How many films in the article portray a daughter-in-law as a main source of family conflict?

Six films in the article portray a daughter-in-law as a main source of family conflict: Paran, Ba: Ek Yoddha, Aa Bata Aama, Chha Maya Chhapakkai-2, Jhingedau-2 and Mahabhoj. Across these stories, her ambition, influence or behaviour is used to explain discord within the family.

The conflicts take different forms. In Paran, a wife presses her husband to seek a life in the United States. In Ba: Ek Yoddha and Aa Bata Aama, wives are blamed for pushing husbands away from parents. Chha Maya Chhapakkai-2 focuses on a wife’s wish to move abroad, while Jhingedau-2 uses rivalry between two daughters-in-law. Mahabhoj links hostility at home with tension over a loan.

The count reflects the films the article discusses, not every Nepali film. The article’s broader point is that these stories give women’s choices much of the blame, while examining sons’ decisions, finances and family expectations far less.

03

What does blaming the daughter-in-law leave out of the explanation for family conflict?

When a daughter-in-law is made the main culprit, the story can reduce a complicated family breakdown to one woman’s ambition or behaviour. The article says this leaves important causes in the background, even though family conflict may involve several people and pressures.

For example, Paran focuses on the wife’s wish to move to the United States, while giving far less attention to the son’s decision, the family’s economic and social circumstances, or the generations’ differing expectations. Other films similarly foreground the wife’s influence rather than asking why a son chooses to leave or how relatives communicate.

The article also points to household power dynamics and financial pressure as factors that receive too little examination. It asks what wives want for themselves and whether family expectations limit their choices. Looking at these elements would provide a fuller account than simply assigning blame to the daughter-in-law, and could make the conflicts feel less one-sided.

04

What kinds of disagreements—such as moving abroad, money, or family authority—drive the conflicts in these films?

The films link family discord to practical choices and competing expectations. Moving abroad is a recurring source of tension: younger couples may seek a more comfortable life, while parents may want their sons to stay close or remain in the village. The article also notes economic and social circumstances, though the films often give these less attention.

Paran’s wife pushes her husband to apply for the US Diversity Visa, while his ageing father wants him to stay. In Chha Maya Chhapakkai-2, the wife wants to move abroad and the father wants his son to stay in the village and pursue politics. Mahabhoj adds a financial dispute: the wife pressures her husband to repay a loan from his father-in-law.

Family authority and inheritance also feature. In Ba: Ek Yoddha, a father gives land to his daughter, angering his son and daughter-in-law. The stories show how migration, money and family expectations can overlap, though blame often falls chiefly on women.

05

What does patriarchy mean, and how can it shape the way women are portrayed in family stories?

In common usage, patriarchy means a social system in which men hold greater power or authority in family and public life. The article does not define the term, but women’s rights activist Rita Sah says the female characters’ portrayals reflect patriarchal attitudes in society.

In the films discussed, daughters-in-law are repeatedly blamed for family discord, while a mother-in-law is the villain in Gaunthali. Sah connects this pattern to earlier television serials that routinely cast women within their own homes as villains. Women are often shown as adversaries of other women, rather than as people facing pressures or making choices within unequal family dynamics.

Sah cautions that such portrayals do not necessarily reflect reality. The article also says who writes and directs female characters matters, and screenwriter Sampada Malla begins to trace the pattern to Hindi television. Looking more closely at whose perspective shapes a story could help audiences see how stereotypes are made and whose actions remain unexplored.

06

Why can decisions about moving abroad create tension between younger couples and older parents?

Moving abroad can create tension when family members want different things from the future. In the films discussed, younger couples’ plans to seek a more comfortable life abroad conflict with parents’ wishes for their sons to stay with them or remain in the village. The article also notes that economic and social circumstances shape these choices.

In Paran, an ageing father wants his younger son to stay, but the son’s wife urges him to apply for the US Diversity Visa. The couple eventually leaves, and the father faces a very different life. In Chha Maya Chhapakkai-2, a father wants his son to stay in the village and pursue politics, while the wife hopes to move abroad.

These examples show how one decision can affect several generations. The films often attribute the move chiefly to the wife, while giving less attention to the son’s own decision, the family’s circumstances and differing expectations. Those factors offer a fuller picture of why migration becomes a family flashpoint.

07

How can giving characters mixed motives and flaws help films move beyond simple hero-and-villain stereotypes?

Giving characters mixed motives means showing that people can want something understandable while still making choices that hurt others. This can move a family story beyond a simple hero-and-villain split. The article’s central criticism is that films often make the daughter-in-law’s ambition or behaviour the explanation for family discord.

In Paran, for instance, the wife wants a more comfortable life in the United States, the father wants his son nearby, and the son is initially reluctant to leave. A fuller story could give weight to all three perspectives and examine the son’s eventual choice, as well as the family’s economic and social circumstances. The article says these elements receive much less attention.

This is a possible storytelling approach, not a change the article reports has already happened. It follows from the article’s questions about household power, financial pressure, communication and women’s choices. Showing how each person contributes to conflict could make characters more complex and avoid treating women as automatic adversaries.

This brief was written by AI from the original reporting and checked by other models. Names, figures and quotes come from the source; read it for full context.

Read more in the JupiteX app

Pulse is free. New stories every 4 hours, each one broken into the questions that explain it.

Or read more news on the web